The Criminal Misjudged Case can be avoided?

  • Created:
  • / Author: Aaron Lewis

Liu Guiming ":

   What is the Criminal Misjudged Case? The Criminal Misjudged Case and why? The Criminal Misjudged Case is inevitable or can avoid? How to prevent and control the Criminal Misjudged Case?

   This a series of problems become just in Changchun held "International Symposium on prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case" the main theme, the main problem of scholar of expert attending the meeting, has become a major topic of domestic and foreign counterparts to exchange.

 

Procuratorial Daily: prevent misjudged cases in addition to law also conscience

Release date: 2012-08-20 10:44:33Authors: Guan ShixinSource: Procuratorial daily   
 
Abstract:

   Prevention of crime and safeguard civil rights, not only depends on the good judicial organization and perfect legal system, but also depends on the value of litigation idea transformation, should establish the procedure priority, change more deep-seated needs to achieve judicial functions.

 

The innocent man was found guilty, wronged person, the Criminal Misjudged as a miscarriage of justice, is the concern of most ordinary people, experts and scholars continue to explore and question.

   

　August 7th to 8, "prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case international seminar" held in Changchun City, Jilin province. Nearly 150 domestic and foreign experts and scholars, with a cross regional multi perspective (foreign and domestic, Hong Kong and Macao) look, many (history, society, system, mechanism, legal issues) comb, multi-level (causes, a process, relief, prevention measures, strategies to explore in depth, more) occupation (lawmakers, academics, judges, prosecutors, police, lawyers) to discuss ways, roundly discusses prevention misjudged criminal cases that people's simple desire, the common pursuit of the legal person, the judicial organ's mission of choroid.

   

　　The Criminal Misjudged Case causes: concepts, ideas, technology and system

   

wrongly occurs not only has the space of common, but also have time. The contemporary society has wrongly, ancient societies have wrongly. Chinese history, misjudged cases have occurred from time to time, there are many handed down celebrity case, such as death prison Han Feizi, framed Yue Fei, Yuan Chonghuan etc..

   

Many historical data showed that, the Criminal Misjudged Case is a common problem of the society, not only the legal system is not too perfect country is erroneous, the relatively sound legal system countries have wrongly. Professor He Jiahong of Renmin University of China Research Center Director of the Criminal Misjudged Case is introduced, America started from twentieth Century 90 time metaphase, many states have established "the innocent center" (Innocence Center), through the "innocent" (Innocence Projects, also known as the innocent project) review the possible misjudged case. From 1989 to 2009, USA states have passed DNA test results found and corrected the 242 error; if the error found on non DNA test methods, such as the case found that the murderer or murderers pleaded guilty, then the error number can reach 500.

   

From the understanding of the process, understanding and judgment can not always correct. In the Criminal Misjudged Case, including the formation of misjudged cases, interleaving legal context and social context, political, economic, cultural, social, moral, religious and legal, rational and irrational factors intertwined. Dean of the Jilin University law school professor Yao Jianzong and other delegates that the occurrence of the misjudged criminal case, which is inevitable, the focus should be to improve the judicial system, prevent and control the occurrence of Criminal Misjudged case. Delegates most think, occurs almost inevitable misjudged case, prevent misjudged cases should return to rational.

   

The Jilin Provincial Higher People's court, Jilin University professor Zhang Wenxian think, the causes of Criminal Misjudged Case is in many aspects, is a fact, the application of the law, but the deeper reason is the social system phenomenon. Professor Long Zongzhi of Sichuan University law school, one of effective means to prevent the Criminal Misjudged Case, is to solve the system problems, checks and balances by different subjects in different procedures of judicial organs, improving the error correcting capability.

   

Some delegates put forward, in addition to improper judicial staff (torture to extract confessions, in violation of the statutory procedures act), resulting in many places worthy of study of the causes of misjudged case. Professor, vice president of Song Yinghui College of criminal law science, Beijing Normal University, is not a scientific evaluation system to promote the investigators to pursue the detection rate, easy to cause the miscarriage of justice. Associate professor of National School of Administration law department Wang Jia that, due to witness will appear error identification, and the investigators identify improper organization or wrongly accepted conclusion of identification is also an important cause of miscarriage occurred. Professor Zou Mingli of Southwest University of Political Science and Law School of thought of criminal investigation, Criminal Misjudged Case and error identification and authentication opinions are closely linked.

   

　　To prevent wrong: perfect from the control system

   

"Litigation reform history is the prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case History progress." Macao international law at St. Joseph's University professor Yang Cheng views endorsed unanimously by the delegates. "Wrong reason is multiple, prevent wrong measures should also be comprehensive." Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer Wang Wensheng said.

   

The experts think, should from the investigation, prosecution, trial link link link link, defense constantly improve the judicial system, prevention of Criminal Misjudged case. Deputy director general of the Supreme People's Procuratorate prosecution department of the Yellow River think, should improve case quality evaluation mechanism, code review, refined case management and other aspects, found the wrong ability to improve prosecution. Zhang Wenxian thinks, should strengthen the supervision of the procuratorial organs, and strengthen internal supervision judicial authorities for trial link. Some delegates think, prevent the Criminal Misjudged Cases from the evidence of continuous improvement, evidence rules. Cui Min, a law professor at Chinese People's Public Security University, in our country in the practice of litigation defense function is too weak is the important reason for the misjudged law case, should focus on strengthening the defense function. "Democracy and the rule of law" editor in chief Liu Guiming and other representatives, to give full play to the role of lawyers, lawyers in the exercise of rights protection, lawyer found wrong to give legal support and system protection.

   

The China University of Political Science and Law Vice Chancellor professor Zhang Baosheng think, study the Criminal Misjudged Case, relates to the principle of evidence, burden of persuasion and the standard of proof of evidence law theory; prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case, must strengthen the evidence system construction. From America, delegates are introduced, some experts think, is of great significance to explore the evidence preservation technology and improving our evidence preservation system, should cause enough attention.

   

Another deep-seated causes of miscarriage occurred, is the thought idea, the Supreme People's court research director Hu Yunteng representatives think, the judicial personnel should have the correct concept of law enforcement, to strengthen the legal education and judicial personnel occupation. We should not only strengthen the knowledge and skills of education, but also to strengthen the ideological and political, judicial ethics education, the correct law enforcement philosophy has the importance of special sense.

   

China University of Political Science and Law professor Fan Chongyi think, from some of the more famous cases such as the She Xianglin case causes, prevention of crime and safeguard civil rights, not only depends on the good judicial organization and perfect legal system, but also depends on the value of litigation idea transformation, should establish the procedure priority, change more deep-seated needs to achieve judicial functions.

   

The Supreme People's Procuratorate investigation supervision department director Wan Chun think, prevent the Criminal Misjudged Case, is not only the judicial personnel to update the concept, and concept update problem, how to form a good social idea renewal, is a major problem the current urgent need to consider. Criminal Law Institute of Beijing Normal University Dean Professor Zhao Bingzhi and other representatives, the establishment of prevention and control mechanism for misjudged cases, one should pay attention to improve the existing rules of criminal procedure, such as the establishment of the principle of presumption of innocence on real significance, fully protect the suspect, the defendant's legitimate rights and interests; on the other hand, also should abide by the rational concept of justice, uphold judicial neutrality, rational treatment of public opinion.

   

　　The new path to prevent wrong: try to independent institutions

   

To prevent the Criminal Misjudged Case, the experience of other countries for China, what inspiration? Mark Godese (Mark Godsey) introduced the "USA innocent action" and the recent situation of the global development in. According to the research center "" misjudged USA Northwestern University law school data show, the center of some staff before the center was built in Illinois, "innocent action" and successfully for 14 grievance cleared. From 1998 to 2010 November, the center has successfully for 23 grievance cleared.

   

As composed of folk force organization movement, "the innocent action" met a lot of problems and challenges, there is USA delegate attending the meeting thinks, Norway and other countries on Chinese, meaningful.

   

Professor of public law at University of Oslo in Norway method Ulf Stydbeck (Ulf Stridbeck), established a relatively independent of the criminal Review Committee Norway in the justice system, a relatively complete the working procedures and the relatively independent personnel in independent work, in work mode, don't accept any department. And the experts, the UK and Canada also has the Criminal Cases Review Committee of the specialized agencies, is responsible for investigating the case and announced. The review committee independent judiciary, absorption law, the media, judges, prosecutors and other multi participants, preliminary filtering that evidence more grasp and then transferred to the judicial organ. They think, these independent institutions play a very important role in the aspect that misjudged case.

   

 Associate professor Huang Shiyuan of the Shandong University School of law, slightly different Sino US misjudged case causes, conditions of society and world is different, independent social institutions to set up similar to that America "innocent" movement is not the reality, should maintain a cautious attitude in the study reference.

   

　　The perfect legal system: seize the opportunity of the re amendment of Criminal Procedure Law

   

Perfecting the mechanism of prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case, each aspect and the reform of the judicial system are closely related, members of the Committee for internal and judicial affairs, director of Renmin University of China's Center for criminal law science professor Dai Yuzhong think, the formal implementation of the revised criminal procedure law, will play an important role on the prevention of Criminal Misjudged case.

   

Beijing people's Procuratorate of Huairou district attorney Lan Xiangdong think, provides the system safeguard the revised criminal procedure law for the prevention and correction of misjudged criminal cases, reflected in the case to the whole procedure of judicial review of death sentence. Improve and implement the system of evidence, the defense system, supervision system and three system is the key to prevent and correct the wrong.

   　　

Some delegates put forward, the exclusionary rule of illegally obtained evidence may be in difficulties still exist in practice, some problems are difficult to solve. Beijing, director of law firm Tian Wenchang think, should be clearly defined in the synchronization of audio and video in the law, before the revision of criminal procedure law enforcement, improve the implementation details, so as to prevent an occurrence of such cases.

   

The conference was co sponsored by the College of criminal law science research center of Renmin University of China and Jilin University Law Center, Renmin University of China Criminal Misjudged Case Study and criminal law science research center of Jilin University jointly hosted.

   

          International Symposium held in prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case
　

      The Changchun on 8 August, reporter Zhang Liang

      August 7th to 8, the prevention of CO sponsored by the College of criminal law science research center of Renmin University of China and Jilin University law "The Criminal Misjudged CaseInternational seminar "held in Changchun City, Jilin province.

      From China's judicial practice department, college, Hong Kong and Macao regions and countries such as the UK America, more than 150 delegates around the causes of misjudged criminal cases, Criminal Misjudged Cases, relief system for the Criminal Misjudged Cases, system, responsibility of misjudged criminal cases misjudged criminal cases and other criminal justice system and the relationship between the discussion topic.

      Renmin University of China Criminal Misjudged Case Research Center Director He Jiahong said, the seminar aims to cause, comparison of Chinese and Foreign Criminal Misjudged Case relief way, analysis of possible ways to prevent the Criminal Misjudged Case, and put forward the corresponding countermeasures.

　　                                        (source: Legal Daily)

 

 

 International Conference on the prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case

Conference introduction:

        In at all times and in all countries, to prohibit misjudged case is always in the field of criminal justice phenomenon. The case will often bring violations of human rights and the innocent of harmful consequences, thus both experts and the common people are widely criticized. Therefore, experts and scholars of criminal law in our organizations at home and abroad and misjudged criminal cases of the witnesses, the typical cases in the world occur deep research in the practice of criminal justice, mining various causes of Criminal Misjudged Case, construct the misjudged case prevention system and misjudged case relief mechanism.In the concept of human rights increasingly deepening Chinese, organized the International Symposium on the Criminal Misjudged Case, has extremely important realistic meaning and theoretical significance.

The meeting time:

        August 6, 2012 (Monday) to August 8th (Wednesday)

Meeting place:

        Jilin province Chinese Changchun Li Ting Hotel (Jilin province senior Prosecutor Training Center)

The theme of the conference:

Improvement of the judicial system,PreventionThe Criminal Misjudged Case

The theme of the conference include but not limited to the following:

 

  • The Criminal Misjudged Case phenomenon in human society;
  • Causes of Criminal Misjudged case;
  • The prevention mechanism of misjudged criminal cases;
  • All of the judicial reform crime prevention
  • Perfect China misjudged criminal case prevention mechanism;
  • Criminal Misjudged Case error correction system, accountability system and compensation system and other related system.

The organizer:
    Criminal law science research center of Renmin University of China
   Jilin University School of law

The undertaker:
    The Criminal Misjudged Case Research Center of Renmin University of China

 

 

 

 

 Liu Guiming: the mechanism, prevention and public opinion influence system

               From the prevention of International Symposium on Criminal Misjudged Case Law Blog
                                  Figure for "democracy and the rule of law" editor in chief Liu Guiming

              

                                Photo Workshop
 
   The following is the editor in chief of Fan Chongyi Liu Guiming, Zhao Bingzhi, Mark Gedesai spokesman commented in three.

   

All the leaders, experts, dear lawyer:

   Very happy and honored here as comment comment! About more than three experts commented, I firmly support the just professor Long Zongzhi made the comments, and then I make three supplement.

   In additional, I give you read a what is "wrong" message:We know our mistakes and admit, is honest! Not sure about the wrong and wrong, is a sophisticated! Sure to wrong and admit, is a veteran! Knowing the wrong don't admit, is the wife! Knowing the right but admit, is the husband! Know someone is wrong but recognize your own faults,! Know yourself wrong but someone is wrong, is the boss! Don't know oneself wrong don't know someone is wrong, is the old-fashioned! Know yourself wrong know someone is wrong, is a teacher! Never admit it specially batch of others, is the boss!

   In fact, so many mistakes, as long as we remember"Knowing the wrong don't admit, is the wife! Knowing the right but admit, is the husband!"You can. Because many wrong in our reality is so happened, some people are busy in error, some people are stupid mistakes, some not, some people are wrong.

   For the three point I just said, I have an idea, please enlighten!

   First, three.

   The first time coincidence coincidence. All of you have seen the London Olympic Games is like a raging fire, at the same time, we also found that the largest Olympic topic or phenomena is wrong, and wrong is wrong place. Last night I reported later also asked Professor He Jiahong to the Olympic games badminton competition because let the ball incident and punish players event view. Teacher He made a concise and comprehensive review, he said: "this is a misjudged case". I think this meeting held at this time, is obviously a very interesting coincidence. We think, in the Olympic Games the referee so many wrong case, we study the occurrence and prevention of crime here, this is a very meaningful time coincidence!

   Second coincidence is professional. As we all know, misjudged case does not occur in the process that occurred in the results. In other words, wrong or occurred in the criminal lawsuit, or is happening in the last criminal results. Just Fan Chongyi teacher and teacher Zhao Bingzhi introduced the She Xianglin case, Zhao Zuohai case, both the procedural issues, there are substantial problems. Fan teacher is the criminal law's authority, Miss Zhao is the criminal law experts, they talk about the Criminal Misjudged Case, what a coincidence.

   Third a coincidence coincidence is expert. In 2005 March, I once made a entitled "Chinese jurist scenery line" speech at the Sichuan University law school, where I sum up the present China jurist school. When talking about regional jurist genre, I put forward a concept of the "Nanyang school". We note that, in addition to Professor Fan Chongyi, Zhao Bingzhi spoke just now, and the presence of Professor Zhang Wenxian, Professor Wang Qing, are out of Nanyang. This is an interesting coincidence, the other without the presence of Nanyang nationality law expert, Professor Fu Zitang, Renmin University of China and Southwest University of Political Science and Law law professor Wang Yi.

   This is the three coincidence I reviews before first see "".

   Second, three common.

   Now, several experts including Professor USA, have talked about three issues, namely three common point. The first common point is they all talked about the handling mechanism. Talking about the mechanism, it reminds me of one of our familiar poetic couplet "rain the sound of the wind in my ear, state housework do care about everything". Today I want to put on the change, the inspiration is from them about public security joint case handling mechanism, on the "big small case sensitive case and case", the constant. This pair of poetic couplet reflect just handling mechanism of reality. You see, all similar, some are big, some are small, some are sensitive to the case, but in the end is a joint case handling. Let us feel incapable of action is, so just before the end of the trial of Guiyang Xiaohe case, which is a typical joint case handling cases. The case has a lot of problems are worth our reflection on the procedure. Can say, the joint case handling mechanism is not terminated, She Xianglin, Zhao Zuohai, misjudged case will continue to occur.

   Second common prevention system. At the opening ceremony just now, President Zhang Wenxian said, it is difficult to error correction, the court very entanglements. This shows that not only the court trying to solve, we want to solve the crime problem. We all know the misjudged case is inevitable, but just fan professor told we misjudged cases could be avoided. Since it is inevitable, but also can be completely avoided, this is a very tangled process. Just include America Professor, several experts said the prevention system, our system to prevent any? Yes. But do not do? I think may or may not be able to do. In fact, the system of Criminal Misjudged Case, prevention is the key, it should be said is not missing, the key is how we do the problem.

   Third common problems is the public opinion influence. Everyone notices, public opinion has affected a lot of people, whether professional or related to the leadership of you are so. In fact, both the Criminal Misjudged Case, or a case, there is a public opinion influence question. For example, these years some hot cases, focus, difficult cases cases occur, are more or less influenced by the public thinking and emotion, especially the influence of leadership. There are public opinion influence in the USA, but its unlikely to influence the judges inner conviction and discretion.

   Third, three little sigh.

   The first emotion is how to play the role of lawyers. I can just say even can be arbitrarily absolutely, one should give full play to the role of lawyers in the case, the general would be less likely to be wrong. If you don't pay attention to the role of lawyers and always will be the lawyer as dissent and hostile, and wrong cases it can hardly be avoided.

   The second feeling is how to use the value of evidence. If fully in accordance with the relevance and objectivity of evidence to determine the value of words, we in the values must avoid torture to extract confessions, resolutely exclusion of illegally obtained evidence, if so, we can avoid the maximum misjudged case.

   Third feeling how to build a legal culture. In my opinion, composed of procedural justice, judicial independence, judicial neutrality and value concept of judicial culture, should be a kind of all laws to reach a consensus on the judicial culture.

   The experts, teachers, and finally I use three words to summarize my comments today view: each of us decide the life not the length, but we can broaden the width of life; each of us can not avoid the occurrence of such cases, but can maximize prevent misjudged cases; each of us justice officials can not fully comply with the public opinion storm, but can be magnanimous and tolerant to correct their mistakes.

    Thank you!
 
 
 
 

The agenda of the meeting


86 March
7:00 - 24:00 experts

87 March
The opening ceremony        8:00 - 8:35
Host.
    He Jiahong (Professor, Renmin University of China Research Center Director of the Criminal Misjudged Case Law School)
Speech:
    Dai Yuzhong (the National People's Congress, the judicial committee of the Renmin University of China criminal legal science research center director, Professor)
    Zhang Wenxian.Jilin ProvincePresident of the higher people's court, Jilin University senior professor of philosophy and Social Science)
    Yao Jianzong (Professor, Dean, Jilin University School of law)

(the following speech 15 minutes each, on 8 minutes each)

The first unit      8:35 - 10:05
Host.
    Wang Xinqing (Professor, vice president, China Youth University for Political Science)
    Hu Yunteng (director of the Supreme People's court research laboratory)
Spokesman.
    Fan Chongyi: the legal thoughts of She Xianglin case
    Zhao Bingzhi: look at the prevention mechanism of miscarriages of justice from the case of Zhao Zuohai
    Mark Godese: America innocent movement and its global expansion of recent: issues and challenges
Comment on:
    Long Zongzhi (Professor of Sichuan University law school)
    Liu Guiming ("democracy and the rule of law" editor)
    Freedom of speech

Tea break          10:05 - 10:20

Unit second      10:20 - 11:50
Host.
    Bian Jianlin (Dean of Institute of procedural law, China University of Political Science and Law)
    MillionSpring (Director General of the Supreme People's Procuratorate investigation supervision department)
Spokesman.
    CuiThe causes and Countermeasures of sensitivity of misjudged criminal cases
    Wang Zhaopeng Taiwan prevention status and Prospect of Criminal Misjudged Case
    Marvin shaman America innocent of the reform movement organization, political and social foundation
Comment on:
    Song Yinghui (vice president, Professor of Criminal Law Science Research Institute of Beijing Normal University)
    Jiang Huiling (deputy director of the Supreme People's Court of judicial reform office)
    Freedom of speech

Unit third      14:00 - 15:45
Host.
    Fan Chongyi (Professor of law at the China University of Political Science and Law)
    LeeClean (Professor of Jilin University law school)
Spokesman.
    Yang Zonghui find the coordinates and path control of Criminal Misjudged Case
    The kingGood vigilance of Criminal Misjudged Case another "culprit" -- An Empirical Analysis Based on 19 Criminal Misjudged Case
    Steven Beckett was arrested "very suspect:" the propensity rule and misjudged criminal cases
    Michel Niscott innocent restricted motion in procedural protection: from Maryland experience
Comment on:
    ZhangXu (vice president, Professor of Jilin University law school)
    Liu Lixia (vice president, Professor of Law School of Yanshan University)
    Freedom of speech

Tea break          15:45 - 16:00

Unit fourth      16:00 - 17:45
Host.
    Dai Yuzhong (the National People's Congress, the judicial committee of the Renmin University of China criminal legal science research center director, Professor)
    Sheng Meijun (Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate Deputy procurator general)
Spokesman.
    Liu Zhiyuan that part of the prosecution of Criminal Misjudged Case
    Lan Xiangdong from the motion correction to return to rational prevention -- Reflections on the prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case
    Guo Xinyang case is how to found
    Ulf, Vivienne Beck legal protection to prevent misjudged criminal cases
Comment on:
    HuangRiver (deputy director general of the Supreme People's Procuratorate public prosecution office)
    Li Xuejun (Professor of Renmin University of China law school)
    Freedom of speech

88 March
Unit fifth      8:00 - 9:45
Host.
    Zhao Bingzhi (Professor, Dean, College of criminal law science, Beijing Normal University)
    Zheng Yongchang (vice president of Jilin Provincial Higher People's court)
Spokesman.
    Zhang Xiangdong confirms the rule and prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case
    Li Jianfei path backtracking, find the reasons
    YangWave of Criminal Misjudged Case fact mistake proofing mechanism study
    Michael England and Welsh's crime prevention: justice and judicial injustice
Comment on:
    YangCheng (Professor of international law at the University of Saint Joseph, Macao)
    ZhangBin (Professor of Sichuan University law school)
    Freedom of speech

Tea break           9:45 - 10:00

Unit Sixth      10:00 - 11:45
Host.
    Song Yinghui (Professor of Beijing Normal University law school)
    Wang Gongyi (director of Research Department of the Ministry of Justice)
Spokesman.
    Tian Wenchang the exclusionary rule of illegally obtained evidence
    Explore the reasons Xu Xiaoping misjudged case
    Causes of Jiang Changming China misjudged criminal cases
    Greta Sharman: reduce misjudged cases proved innocent citizens participation model
Comment on:
    Gu Yongzhong (Professor of China University of Political Science and Law law school)
    Wang Wensheng (Beijing guanheng (Changchun) director of law firm, lawyer)
    Freedom of speech

Unit seventh      14:00 - 15:45
Host.
    Long Zongzhi (Professor of Sichuan University law school)
    Huo Xiandan (director of judicial authentication Administration Department of Justice)
Spokesman.
    Analysis of Zhang Baosheng of Criminal Misjudged Case evidence
    Discussion on Zou Mingli misjudged criminal cases associated with criminal identification problem
    Min Chunlei proved that prevention procedures of Criminal Misjudged Case
    Zou Jinpei: Interpretation of electronic evidence with the error
Comment on:
    Bian Jianlin (Professor of law at the China University of Political Science and Law)
    Cheng Jianfeng (director of the Supreme People's Procuratorate judicial identification center)
    Freedom of speech

Tea break          15:45 - 16:00

Unit eighth      16:00 - 17:45
Host.
    XuDai (Professor of Jilin University law school)
    Zhang Guiyong (director of bureau of the Ministry of public security criminal technology five)
Spokesman.
    HighImprove the causes and prevention mechanism of misjudged criminal cases
    A comparative study of Huang Shiyuan and the causes of misjudged criminal cases and correct
    YangCheng Canada misjudged case study: worth lessons
    Gabe, Tan England, Welsh and Northern Ireland misjudged criminal cases "rehabilitated": evaluation committee in criminal cases
Comment on:
    Liu Mingxiang (criminal law science research center of Renmin University of China, executive director, Professor)
    Li Renfu (Professor of Jilin University law school)
    Freedom of speech

The closing ceremony        17:45
Host.
    XuDai (Professor of Jilin University law school)
Summary of people:
    Liu Mingxiang (vice president, Professor of Renmin University of China law school)

 

 

Appendix: "International Symposium on prevention of Criminal Misjudged Case" the expert list

(sort by name in Chinese Pinyin)

 

No.

Full name

Unit & title

1

Bian Jianlin

China University of Political Science and Law Institute of procedural lawDean, Professor

2

Che Chengjun

Heilongjiang Provincial People's ProcuratorateDeputy Attorney General

3

Chen Clean

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate three director

4

Chen Jinyang

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

5

Chen Peiqun

Taiwan Association of criminal vindicationDirector of general office, legal assistant

6

Chen Xiaohong

Jilin Hengfeng lawyers

7

Chen Xudong

Jilin daily news reporter

8

Chen Youning

The executive secretary of the Taiwan Association of criminal vindication

Hongli law firm Intern

9

Chen Yufan

Professor of Jilin University Law School

10

Cheng Jianfeng

The director of the Supreme People's Procuratorate judicial identification center

11

Cui Sensitivity

Professor of law, Chinese People's Public Security University

12

Dai Yuzhong

Members of the House Judiciary Committee of the National People's Congress

Director of criminal law science research center of Renmin University of China

Professor of Renmin University of China Law School

13

Deng Jinting

Lecturer at the Renmin University of China School of law

14

Ding Jay

Associate professor of Shandong University Law School

15

Dong Kun

The Supreme People's Procuratorate procuratorial theory research

16

Sinus Na

The people's Procuratorate of Tonghua city Jilin Province, assistant inspector

17

Fan Chongyi

Professor of law at the China University of Political Science and Law

18

Pay Feng

Lecturer at the Zhongnan University of Economics and Law School of law

19

High Song

Ma Ying lawyer

20

Greta Sharman

USA Royall oak Michigan city "proven innocent" center lawyer

21

Gu Yongzhong

Professor of law at the China University of Political Science and Law

22

Guan Shixin

"The reporter procuratorial daily" theory

23

Guo Xinyang

Associate professor of law, National Prosecutors College

24

Guo Xinglian

The people's Procuratorate of Beijing city Huairou District Deputy Chief Procurator

25

He Jiahong

Professor and director of the Renmin University of China Center for the study of law, the Criminal Misjudged Case

26

Hu Yunteng

Director of Research Office of the Supreme People's court

27

Huang The river

Deputy director general of the Supreme People's Procuratorate public prosecution office

28

Huang Shiyuan

Associate professor of Shandong University Law School

29

Huang Yongwei

The Supreme People's court for trial supervision court vice president

30

Huo Xiandan

Director of the Ministry of justice Forensic Administration

31

Ji Meijun

Research Associate, the Supreme People's Procuratorate theory

32

Gabe, Tan

Executive director of the University of Bristol "the innocent sites"

33

Jiang Changming

Jilin Changchun lawyer

34

Jiang Huiling

The Supreme People's court, deputy director of the office of judicial reform

35

Jin Xiaodan

The office of the Supreme People's Court of judicial reform

36

Lan Xiangdong

Beijing city Huairou District People's Procuratorate

37

Li Chunguang

Yunnan Lingyun lawyer

38

Li Haiying

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

39

Lee Good

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

40

Li Jianfei

Henan Provincial Higher People's Court of Criminal Tribunal

41

Lee Clean

Professor of Jilin University Law School

42

Li Lifeng

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

43

Li Qitong

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

44

Li Renfu

Professor of Jilin University Law School

45

Li Ronggeng

Assistant Professor Department of Soochow University Law

46

Li Weiwei

The Supreme People's Procuratorate investigation supervision department prosecutor

47

Li Xuejun

Professor of Renmin University of China Law School

48

Lee Extension

The director of Jilin Provincial Department of justice lawyer Management Office

49

Lee Zheng

Changchun City, deputy chief of the District People's Procuratorate department two

50

Beam Kun

"Evidence forum" Edit

Post doctoral fellow at the Renmin University of China School of sociology and population

51

Liao Ming

"Teahouse" Edit jurist

Lecturer in Criminal Law Institute of Beijing Normal University

52

Liu Guiming

"Democracy and the rule of law" editor in chief

53

Liu Jianhua

Lecturer at the Zhongnan University of Economics and Law College of Criminal Justice

54

Liu Lixia

Professor, vice president of Yanshan University School of law

55

Liu Mingxiang

Vice president, Professor of Renmin University of China Law School

56

Liu Pinxin

Deputy director of the Renmin University of China Center for the study of Criminal Misjudged Case

Associate professor of Renmin University of China Law School

57

Liu Renwen

Professor of law Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Institute director, criminal law

58

Liu Yanan

Jilin Provincial Higher People's Court of criminal two court assessors

59

Liu Zhiyuan

Deputy director of the Supreme People's Procuratorate case management office

60

Long Zongzhi

Professor of Sichuan University Law School

61

Lu Yongge

Jin Boda lawyer

62

Rom. North

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

63

Lv Guanglun

The Supreme People's court punishment three Court vice president

64

Ma Dongni

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

65

Mark Gedesai

University of Cincinnati law school professor American

Co founder, director American Ohio miscarriage of justice redress research projects and global misjudged case research center

66

Ma Lidong

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate three deputy director

67

Marvin Shaman

Wayne State University professor USA criminal justice system

68

Horse Ying

Ma Ying lawyer

69

Ma Zhiyun

Director of Beijing Municipal Bureau of justice of judicial authentication management office

70

Michael Norton

The University of Bristol

"Director of the UK's innocent website founder,"

71

Meng Health

Shandong Province Higher People's court punishment three Court vice president

72

Mi Lianjun

Jilin province Changchun City Bureau of justice lawyer management director

73

Michel Niscott

Director of University of Baltimore America innocent Project Office

74

Miao Yanbo

"Deputy editor of the law journal"

75

Min Chunlei

Professor of Jilin University Law School

76

Nanjie • long strong British

Lecturer at the Northwest University For Nationalities School of law

77

Qin Jin

Changchun City People's Procuratorate two assistant inspector

78

Ren Jianbo

The deputy director of the Jilin Provincial Public Security Department

79

Ren Weifeng

Jilin qianrui lawyer

80

Sheng Meijun

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate Deputy procurator

81

Steven Beckett

Professor and director of the trial, defense research center America Illinois College of Criminal Justice

82

Song Yinghui

Vice president, Professor of Criminal Law Science Research Institute, Beijing Normal University

83

Su Dongxu

Assistant director of Department of East Asian community news and news

84

Su Xiaohong

Director China procuratorial press

85

Sun Flute

Zhongnan University of Economics and Law doctoral student

86

Sun Liting

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate at a help inspector

87

Sun Muge

Jilin Huameng lawyer

88

Sun Taoyi

Jilin Provincial Higher People's Court of criminal four court assessors

89

Sun Filial piety

Changchun City, Chaoyang District people's Procuratorate assistant inspector

90

Tian Department

China University of Political Science and Law doctoral student

91

Tian Wenchang

Director, Beijing Kyoto firm lawyers

92

Million Spring

Director General of the Supreme People's Procuratorate investigation supervision department

93

The king Charge

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

94

Wang Gongyi

Director of the research department of Justice

95

Wang Huaiyu

Ministry of justice Forensic Administration Supervision Department cadres

96

The king Good

Associate Professor, National School of Administration School of law

97

The king Jin

The Supreme People's Procuratorate case management office director

98

Wang Liying

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

99

Wang Shiyou

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

100

Wang Wensheng

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

101

Wang Xinqing

Professor of China Youth University for Political Science, vice president

102

The king Yong

Lecturer at the Jilin University School of law

103

Wang Yuzhu

Beijing Assistant District People's Procuratorate of Huairou inspector

104

Wang Zhaofeng

Beijing Deheng Law firm lawyers

105

Wang Zhaopeng

Law school, national National Taiwan University

106

Wang Zhiyuan

Professor of Jilin University Law School

107

Wang Zunyi

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

108

Wen Jifei

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate three deputy director

109

Temperature Man

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

110

Wolfe, Westminster leader Beck

A law professor at University of Oslo law school in Norway

111

Wu Jingbo

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

112

Wu Flat

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

113

Shaw Army

Chinese People's Public Security University doctoral student

114

Xiao Junpeng

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate at the head of the group of three

115

Xu Dai

Professor of Jilin University Law School

116

Xu Xiaoping

Shaanxi Xu Xiaoping law firm lawyers

117

Yang Wave

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

118

Yang Cheng

Professor of international law at the University of Saint Joseph, Macao

119

Yang Jianwen

Judicial Reform Office survey to judge the Supreme People's court

120

Yang Keqin

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate

121

Yang Suwen

Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate a deputy director

122

Yang Zonghui

Professor and director, Center for education of Zhongnan University of Economics and Law, master of law

123

Yao Jianzong

Professor, Dean, Jilin University School of law

124

Leaf Ting

Prosecutors two District People's Procuratorate, Changchun City complained

125

Yuan Ningning

China University of Political Science and Law doctoral students

126

Zhang Aijun

Yitong County People's Procuratorate

127

Zhang Baosheng

Vice president of China University of Political Science and Law, Professor of law at

128

Zhang Bin

Professor of Sichuan University Law School

129

Zhang Guiyong

Director of bureau of the Ministry of public security criminal technology five

130

Zhang Lining

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

131

Zhang Bright

Legal Daily News Agency in Jilin province station

132

Zhang Weike

Beijing Normal University College of criminal law science pH.

133

Zhang Wenxian

The president of the Jilin Provincial Higher People's court

Senior professor of social science of Jilin University

134

Zhang Xiangdong

The criminal trial of three judges of the Supreme People's court

135

Zhang Xu

Vice president, Professor of Jilin University Law School

136

Zhang Yansheng

Beijing Da Yu law firm lawyers

137

Zhang Feather

A magazine editor

138

Zhao Bingzhi

Dean, College of criminal law science, Beijing Normal University

139

Zhao Faguang

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

140

Zhao Navigation

The Jilin Provincial People's Procuratorate two assistant inspector

141

Zhao Xingtian

The Jilin Provincial Higher People's Court Criminal Court vice president

142

Zhao Ziyue

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

143

Zheng Junnan

Associate professor of Jilin University Law School

144

Zheng Sikuan

Deputy director of Changchun City Judicial Bureau of Jilin Province

145

Zheng Yongchang

Vice president of Jilin Provincial Higher People's court

146

Zhou Baoji

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

147

Week Jing

Jilin Provincial Higher People's Court of criminal three Court assessors

148

Zhou Xingchun

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

149

Zhu Crystal

Justice net editor

150

Zou Jinpei

Associate Professor, Department of computer science of University of Hong Kong

Deputy director of the center for information security and Cryptography

151

Zou Mingli

Professor at the Southwest University of Political Science and Law School of criminal investigation

152

Zou Xiaoyan

Beijing guanheng (Changchun) lawyer

 

 
The relevant media reports linking: Http://www.fyfz.cn/zt/201208/21627/
Http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hqsj/shbt/2012-08-09/content_6670598.htmlAnd other well-known domestic news media even reported.