Liu GuimingA former Chinese National Lawyers Association Chinese "lawyer" magazine editor in chief, the current Chinese law "democracy and the rule of law" editor)

   Beihai law case occurred not only in the teeth of the storm, the Beihai public security and judicial organs in micro-blog, blog and the media attention and discussion, but also lawyers association to focus on a platform, let a person look forward to attract people's attention.

   The core is in focus, the lawyer rights suffered a serious violation, as the industry authority Lawyers Association, should have what? Especially the lawyer off self protection climax, lawyers association how to debut, how to position, how to be?

   In four Beihai lawyers perjury crime more than in January July 22nd, China lawyer finally revealed serious concern from the all China Lawyers Association "":

    The all China Lawyers Association on the legal practice course, expressed serious concern about the personal rights are aggrieved situation, urge the Beihai City, the judicial organs take immediate measures, and guarantee the lawyers' personal safety, and effectively safeguard the lawyer to meet, investigation and evidence collection and checking the legitimate right to practice. The all China Lawyers Association will continue to follow closely the developments.

   This is unlike the "statement" and not "talk" short "position", in fact, not only has the National Lawyers especially devoted to the Beihai lawyer lawyer long and eagerly looking forward to, and inadvertently revealed the association of lawyers in the current industry management in the awkward and embarrassed.

   And this is the need to discuss the topic of this paper, in the four Beihai lawyers perjury and other similar by lawyer industry topic evolved into a public event, in the past, present and future, lawyers' Association shall how lawyers representing the demand, how to respond to concerns that the association of lawyers, how to play a role?

Have the right to make

   Articles of association according to association of lawyers, lawyers' Association shall perform the duties of as many as 16, power is not big. But in fact, nothing but is licensed security rights, regulation, supervision and management of the right right right, dispute mediation, disciplinary power and industry representatives.

According to the Ministry of justice of the current location, the lawyer management system of our country is the administrative and judicial administrative organs of the lawyers association of industry management by combining. This was the industry called "two combination" divide and conquer model system, since 1993, has continued to the present reality of "I have you, my close".

   As the supreme organ of the administration of justice, the Justice Department over the years has been trying to change this reality. This time about ten years ago, the Justice Department official pointed out that, in the future, the judicial administrative organs should focus on support, supervision, guidance on the direction of work continues to focus on the Association; on the other hand, also want to change the idea, to cede power, this should belong to the legal profession management organization function to peruse, the lawyers association be responsible for the industry management.

   But ten years later, still seems to be little change. IBA is still unable to establish their authority. On the one hand, the judicial administrative agencies delivered or entrusted to the Lawyers Association's power is extremely limited, on the other hand, the association has no subject status in the political system, non representative lawyer industry express their demands and propositions, are not the ability and conditions representations and external social forces. In addition, the radiation force bar up to association level, not specifically affect every firm and every lawyer.

   In fact, the association became managing directors of the main body, and did not become autonomous organizations of all lawyers; lawyers association leadership is often only a title card related law, does not indicate that they are practical as in management. In this case, the association of management may not pay too much expectation.

   So, is because the autonomous nature of lawyer association can not reflect.

   To this end, the National Lawyers Association has repeatedly put forward legislative suggestions, requirements in the "lawyer law" revision, clearly Bar Association as the nature of identity profession autonomy organization, and increase the lawyer industry access rights, registration rights, right of discipline inspection industry, membership fee and use rights, participate in relevant law major policy formulation power industry management authority.

   However, we in the new version that is in 2007 the newly revised "law", has not seen the relevant content. We have seen the reality is the administration color lawyers, as in the past the leading professional management law; localization management and lawyers, and more seriously obscured the lawyer industry and chemical properties. So, in some public events of great, we saw lots of judicial administrative supervision of lawyers to service more than power, resistance. From first to last, there is no industry management words, no more autonomous trade trip.

Sensitive "autonomous"

   When it comes to self governance of lawyers, now seems to be a sensitive words. Some officials as capitalist property, some leaders be demonized, and some sectors are regarded as the forbidden words and deeds. Interpretation in accordance with the relevant scholars, "autonomous is the main body of certain subject relative to the external to its own affairs independently processed state". In fact, the so-called "law of autonomy" is composed of outstanding lawyers Lawyers Association, self service, self-discipline, self management of lawyers. This kind of community autonomy architecture with state power, agreement directly from the specific social members due to safeguard their common interests and groups need a "". With the continuous development of public administration in the countries all over the world, there are many exercise of the public power of the government industry organizations. Lawyers Association as autonomous trade management organizations, has a dual identity, on the one hand, as it represents the interests of members of the organization, the responsibility of safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of member functions; on the other hand, it also shoulders the practice mechanism of supervision and management of the lawyer and lawyer's duty.

   However, China seems to be willing to accept the lawyer industry belongs to the "self-discipline" rather than "autonomy" statement. In fact, self-discipline is aimed at individual lawyer and lawyer practicing institutions, the lawyer industry should be emphasized autonomy. Because the lawyer profession autonomy for the formation of the industry common behavioral patterns, constraints industry illegal behavior, to fight for their rights and improve the industry's social influence is necessary.

   So, in the current judicial system of our country lawyer profession autonomy has become a real obstacle and distant proposition. In this way, we will not be difficult to understand, why Beihai four lawyers perjury case occurs, the National Lawyers Association cannot stand. Easier to understand is, after Beihai lawyers under siege, in the National Lawyers repeatedly called for concern, concern national lawyers association can't talk but must stand "".

"Concern" to "action"

   In my opinion, "attention" is the primary responsibility of lawyers association. As the industry authority, for their own members, practice, practice practice rights problem puzzled and the practice environment, all need to pay attention. Must pay attention to the case, more attention should be paid to the major; must pay attention to the local, but also should pay attention to all; should pay attention to not only the successful lawyer, more attention should be paid to the edge of the lawyer; must pay attention to the, also pay attention to small and medium-sized; should pay close attention to the reality, more attention should be paid to the future.

   Secondly, also has the "response", which is the necessary step in the bar association "concern" after. Be honest, after the four Beihai lawyers perjury case occurs, the National Lawyers Association or action. A notice of the association of Guangxi is to understand the situation and communicate with Beihai and Guangxi relevant departments; two is to express sympathy and solicitude for calling Beihai lawyers for core members to understand the situation and report; three is to listen to the Beihai lawyers core members; four is the comment and expressed "serious concern".

   It should be said, these actions are necessary, but only fourth can be a real "response". Although the "response" seems to be somewhat slow, but still in time. In fact, the "answer" can earlier by the National Lawyers Association Rights Commission came, and the effect may be better. Therefore, from the industry management "response" is very important, very need. Because the "response" law concerns, social concerns, the people concerned, it is one of the effective means of management innovation.

   "Response" to "guide", which is used as a trade management institutions should have a high degree of. When the public events and legal related happens, when it comes to the lawyers' rights are violated when, as a lawyer for an event or a phenomenon There were many discussions. Be at a loss what to do when, lawyers or Lawyers Association Professional Committee should guide. Like a raging fire the Beihai lawyer activist occasion, lawyers association shall coordinate Rights Committee or criminal Business Committee to comment and give guidance. Shall rejoice is, the Beihai lawyers have been relatively clear and calm, calm and rational, rational and wise. They are exploring the lawyer self advocacy model innovation at the same time, but also to the bar association rights has raised many new issues.

   Finally, the bar association shall act. The so-called "action" is the National People's Congress and political science and law, and other relevant departments and the media, scholars of communication and coordination, which is the basic work of lawyers association. Although the coordination the lawyers association is not enough, but in a wide range of relying on judicial administrative and relevant government departments or DOSOMETHINPREVIOUSLYUNRELEASED resources under the background of the. 23 years ago, "Liaoning Taian three law case", it is because the lawyers association fully rely on party and government departments, coordination of organs of the National People's Congress, the mobilization of the mainstream media, finally obtained the satisfactory solution. The majority of lawyers, representatives, lawyers association assume endorsement, agent, should have it all is a trade association of the "action" ability.

   Can be expected, in the present and future, lawyer autonomous must be lawyers association and play as. Although the road is long, but as long as the action, not long.

Http://www.nbweekly.com/news/special/201108/27046.aspx

The all China Lawyers lawyers rescue group Beihai fighting for rights

                           2011-8-8 15:53:09 source: Nandu weekly

　　           (lawyers) from left to right: Wu Lei, Zhu Mingyong, Chen Guangwu, Zhang Kai. Photography _ Hong Jianpeng
　　
　　

    July 18, 2011 10 am, Shandong lawyer Chen Guangwu appeared in a Guangxi Bar Association office door, followed by Beijing lawyer Wu Lei. With the Beihai lawyers Yunnan lawyer Yang Mingkua, from Kunming by the night train to Nanning and meet them.

This is an unexpected visit. Chen Guangwu is worried about each other too formal, so without consulting it, man to the door, only to the Guangxi lawyers association secretary general Li Ping hung up the phone. Yan Liping is Guangxi Chongzuo City, acting as deputy attorney general, she told Chen on the phone, make sure the main leadership reception they.

Three from all over the country, different age of lawyers, appears in the association of Guangxi, and a be strangers to each other colleagues in Guangxi was arrested by the police for. The morning of June 14th, Guangxi lawyer Yang Zaixin was taken away by the police in Beihai, half a month after being arrested, suspected of crimes is prevented.

Experienced the Li Zhuang case lawyers, peers for perjury caught especially sensitive. Shandong lawyer Chen Guangwu and Hunan lawyer Yang Jinzhu quickly raised the banner of self-help, the formation of lawyers to provide legal aid to lose freedom fellow.

The morning of July 12th, Shaanxi lawyer Fang Ligang to the Beihai detention center meeting with the parties, suffering six security, or even be asked to take off pants belt. Lawyers realized, must seek the organization support. They hope to obtain the local lawyers association's support, pipeline and then find the dialogue with the authorities. Therefore, 60 year Chen Guangwu decided to go to the association of Guangxi.

"It seems, they also eager to meet us. Some leaders are come from the work site." Chen Guangwu feel each other sincere attitude. In addition to the vice president of the Guangxi Lawyers Association Luo Weixiong, a criminal defense committee deputy director Liu Chaolin, member department deputy director Xu Zhijiang, director of Guangxi Department of justice at the Li Jian also rushed there, he was the most important official judicial department specializes in lawyer work.

In the two hour of the meeting, Chen Guangwu put forward four requirements, including, cancel the meeting obstacles all outside the law, security and so on, cancel, accompanied by. Answer: try to coordinate. Li Jian told them, the day afternoon through organizational procedures, to do a report on the Autonomous District Committee of political science and law.

In the official channels, Li Jian also used personal relationship coordination, Guangxi public security bureau director of the rule of law, and he is an alumnus, know well.

The three lawyers are meeting was satisfied with the. "We are both very frankly, no reservation in communication." Wu Lei of the Nandu weekly reporter said, the association of Guangxi or do a lot of work, it should be said that doing good. "They can't high-profile publicity, must and local consistency. They do the work, according to our understanding, communication, coordination, more is to report."

After leaving the association, Wu Lei quickly sent a micro-blog: "very touched, very sincere, without reservation, very professional." He is also known as "mother" in the micro-blog, immediately someone teases: "is there."

And the end of the association of Guangxi meeting, have to eat lunch time, but out of caution, Chen Guangwu and other lawyers in spite of hungry, declined to other nearby for lunch. They stopped a taxi, to Nanning Lang Dong bus station. In fast food restaurants, a poor bus station, three people spent 30 multivariate run out of breakfast and lunch. Yang Mingkua is worried about Chen Guangwu before food is not enough, especially for he bought more than 8 yuan beef.

The Beihai lawyers action, every lawyer members out of their own pockets, some spontaneous donations to support the front rear lawyer lawyer, but Chen Guangwu refused any social sponsorship.

"Head"

Fine back Yang Zaixin perjury case, investigation and evidence collection of the witness, seems to be buried under the fate of foreshadowing.

Yang Zaixin and other four lawyers is the agent of Beihai a case of intentional injury. Since most according to the defendant's confession, no other evidence, material evidence, the case for more than half a year after the two session, has not yet been decided.

Take the case of intentional injury, Yang Zaixin and colleagues found three witnesses, cameras, recording, investigation records forensics.

In the camera eye witnesses to testify, lawyers said, on the night of the murder and the first defendant had Pei Jinde.

Court trial, the defendant did not testify crime time three witnesses in court, four defendants confession, lawyers for their respective parties pleaded not guilty.

The four lawyers not to kill murder reported polishing agent. The association of Guangxi said a person familiar with the situation: "pleaded not guilty to the criminal case, we also asked the lawyer to the judicial administrative organ law union, lawyers also can ask a lawyer association guidance, to discuss, but they are not reported."

The person said, "the report we will have some more active, we understand the situation, can put forward our opinions. Of course, they can stick to their point of view, we just provide some guidance, remind risk exists between them."

The risk is coming soon. Soon after the trial, three witnesses by Beihai police criminal detention. The witness was arrested, Yang Zaixin felt that his trouble, he and the Guangxi hundred for Ming director of law firm Tan Yongpei signed a power of attorney, and put the materials had once sent to Hunan lawyer Yang Jinzhu.

Yang Zaixin, Beihai Hepu County, "the human rights lawyer", in the eyes of local officials is a "head lawyer". He worked as a secondary school teacher, 10 years ago through self-study obtained lawyer qualification. The agent of the case, many involved in sensitive areas of land disputes, demolition resettlement, administrative litigation, national compensation and so easy to conflict with the public power. "In the civil rights movement in extremely hard and bitter, Yong Tam responsibility of one of the human rights lawyer, A new force suddenly rises." Yang Zaixin was so introduce myself.

In 2003, Yang Zaixin was police detention half a year. In Guangdong Foshan, Yang was caught two times.

The stem is offending local work, Yang Shin cautious, agency cases must sign the contract, collect fees will open invoice, sauna places more dare not go, even someone knocking at the door to live in a hotel, not easy to open the door. Although a variety of cautious, but this is accused of perjury caught.

Yang Zaixin had consulted Tan Yongpei: the parties met Hanyuan, says suffered torture, want to report? "I said don't report. As a lawyer, not necessary to expose the public security organs of the short." Tan Yongpei answered.

Second days, Yang Zaixin was arrested, Tan Yongpei with the material has to Nanning IBA, Nanning Judicial Bureau and the association of Guangxi. At this time, Tan Yongpei learned that three other counsel cases are taken away by the police.

The same day, Yang Jinzhu received Yang's wife Huang Zhongyan calls, and then in the blog published "Guangxi Beihai lawyer Yang Zaixin was detained on suspicion of crime of perjury" news, Beihai lawyer perjury was known to the outside world.

A week later, Beihai official bulletin said, Yang Zaixin and other 4 lawyers, the parties and witnesses to lure perjury, and overthrow the prosecution allegations, "the trial of cases come to a deadlock", suspected of the crime.

Ask for help

Guangxi lawyer says to the reporter, Beihai lawyer after the incident, Nanning Municipal successively to convene the relevant law firms and lawyers for the meeting, "don't touch the law, do not contact the media".

In July 20th, reporters call the Nanning Municipal rotating president Zhou Xuzhao, that reporter identity, Zhou said "wrong", then hang up the phone. Nanning City, vice chairman of the association Zhang Hongxin said, when lawyers "with adults", however, said he had just come back from a business trip, do not understand the detailed case, inconvenience comment more.

After Yang Zaixin, the association of Nanning and Guangxi lawyers two IBA rapid intervention, specifically to discuss, the association of Guangxi also submitted a special report to the National Lawyers Association, and a Shanghai lawyer Chen Youxi's article "suggests that the Ministry of public security, the National Lawyers Association quickly attention and involvement of four Guangxi lawyers.".

Chen Youxi at the airport to the National Lawyers Association President Yu Ning on the phone. Yu Ning told Chen, the National Lawyers Association on the matter of high concern, has asked Guangxi Lvxie directly concerned, to negotiate with the local public security organ. "At the very least, the lawyer was arrested 24 hours shall inform the lawyer association, 48 hours should arrange the meeting, the Guangxi public security organs do not. This is very should not. The National Lawyers Association will further focus on the case and take action." Yu Ning said.

According to the National Lawyers Association charter, every lawyer is the National Lawyers Association member, each law firm is the organization members. Each level of IBA corresponding set up a service to the members of the human rights committee. The Beihai lawyer trauma, many lawyers hope three can stand in solidarity with the association, to investigate, for the attorney rights.

But under the current system, the local lawyers association sometimes involuntarily, even become the judicial role for endorsement. In January 10, 2010, the Chongqing Evening News published a story titled "Gong Gangmo brother Gong Ganghua had 'entertain' Li Zhuang prostitution" report. Reportedly, the association of Chongqing "sun, preliminary confirms related claims, and says it has received the police special letter."

The second day, President of the Chongqing Lawyers Association Sun Farong to the Chongqing evening news sent an open letter, condemning the newspaper in the depiction of Li Zhuang of prostitution in the interview content untrue, the newspaper published a retraction and make an apology to its.

Li Zhuang case after the first quarter, the Ministry of Justice issued a notice, request Lvxie around with Li Zhuangan as the training, deployment warning education to all lawyers. Subsequently, a lawyer in the online issue of "the dissolution of IBA when discussing how to".

However, the Beihai lawyers realized, can not give up, not abandoned the system support.

Yang Jinzhu made a special trip to the National Lawyers Association, the National Lawyers Association member of the identity, reflecting the Yang Zaixin lawyers for alleged obstruction of witnessing by Beihai police arrest conditions. Ten days later, Chen Guangwu, Zhu Mingyong, Wu Lei and other lawyers to the National Lawyers Association of special reports on the case. Some senior National Lawyers Association to listen to their views. The report, Chen Guangwu saw the Guangxi lawyers association secretary general Yan Liping.

In the face of numerous national lawyer look forward to the eyes, in July 22nd, the National Lawyers Association said in a statement on its Web site, "serious concerns the legal practice of unlawful infringement from in Beihai".

Chen Guangwu forwarded the ACLA statement in the blog. Yang Jinzhu lawyers in the media forwarding ACLA statement, all within the system support attitude, they are regarded as "good news".

Embarrassing

Yang Zaixin after the incident, the association of Guangxi set up a working group, judicial department director Li Jian as head of the pipe, including members of vice president of the association of Guangxi, deputy director of the deputy director in charge of Human Rights Commission Director, and criminal defense committee director. The association of each firm to report the situation, followed by several meetings to discuss.

The morning of July 15th working group meeting, on the afternoon of the same day, the association of Guangxi president office will be held an enlarged meeting, special discussion.

"There was a lawyer, we also sent to investigate, but also not the means, sent to Beihai investigation, people can ignore you, you are not welcome. The association did not the means, law does not give such power." People familiar with the matter, the association can use the means that is to reflect the relevant departments, report, only to find the IBA membership survey, but out of lawyer industry, there is no investigative powers.

The insider said, "our later analysis, only to find that to their departments, such as the public security, procuratorate, Department of politics and law committee. We have to have the right to manage their departments, can only do this step. We went to the investigation, do not have this power, also won't have what effect."

In 2010 January, Li Zhuang case first season, the association of Beijing sent an investigation team to Chongqing, then to the National Lawyers Association submitted nearly 7000 words "about the Li Zhuang case report" and its derivative problem, request the National Lawyers Association to start coordination mechanism, report the Justice Department and report to the National People's Congress Standing Committee, Central Committee of political science and law, the supreme law, the high, the Ministry of public security and other departments, reiterated the hope that careful treatment of Li Zhuang case. But the report did not receive a positive response.

The insider said, by means of the association is very limited, it is a trade association, and the women's federations, trade unions such institutions cannot be put on a par with. "We have suggested, the National Lawyers Association is a news spokesman system, but it is difficult to adopt."

A Guangxi lawyer who evaluation say without mincing words: "although attention IBA, several meetings to discuss, but also incapable of action. Even if is the director of the Bureau of justice of Nanning, power is less than the director of the Public Security Bureau of Beihai."

In a very long period of time, the lawyer is the management of administrative management, administrative mode. After the founding of the association of Lawyers Association, and judicial administrative organs have long office together, "two brands, a team", responsible for the judicial administrative organ of the executive member, only the individual lawyers involved.

From 1993 onwards, the lawyer management system began to implement the reform, some lawyers association and judicial administrative organs began to gradually separate. In 2005, the association of Guangxi by the lawyer as chairman, vice chairman, judicial authorities no longer serves as the job. But the president candidate is still determined by the judicial department, director general of the Department of justice of the Association appointed as honorary chairman, the secretary general is the judicial administrative organs of civil servants, by the association of employment.

In the administration, the judicial administrative organ Bar Association industry management "two combination" management system, also cannot be independent of the judicial administrative organs. When the conflict occurs in administrative management and industry management, without exception, is subject to administrative management.

"The association is unreliable." In 2010, Li Zhuang into sin, lawyers Qi Su Zhang Sizhi said: "the association works should have been our mother, but the mother has now become a bad witch."

Zhang Sizhi advocated the abolition of "management mechanism of two combination", execute trade administration according to the law, "the law governing themselves, I can't believe we're not good, I absolutely do not believe. If the association of really good words, not no help at all."

At the beginning of 2011 7, the Chongqing municipal election, Chongqing Lvxie full-time president Sun Farong resigned. Secretary of the Party committee, director general of the Chongqing Justice Bureau Lin Yujun put forward, to catch team, to ensure the correct political orientation of the law.

Save oneself

Yang Zaixin lawyers detained after the news, Hunan lawyer Yang Jinzhu and Shandong lawyer Chen Guangwu on the phone, Chen Guang Wu decided to come forward, four lawyers to provide legal aid for perjury. The two lawyers around the point, draw up a list of lawyers seven members. At that time, Yang Zaixin from the less than two days.

At the end of 6, Yang Zaixin was arrested, Yang Zonghan and other three lawyers get guaranteed pending trial. In Chen Guangwu's opinion, the release of the three people such as Yang Zhonghan is a Beihai police "from the strategic offensive to the important sign of" strategic defense retreated to the police to concentrate on the last line of defense, to focus on the core characters, Yang shin.

"Three grasping a" increased the release of Yang Zaixin's difficulty, lawyers immediately re evaluation strategy, make a plan "a fundamental solution" policy. Yang Zaixin perjury and Beihai intentional injury are closely linked, as long as the intentional injury case the defendant accused does not hold, then, Yang Zaixin perjury charges naturally untenable. Therefore, in July 10th, lawyers decided the case of intentional injury, the lawyer team Wu expanded to more than 20 people, the lawyer - "battle of Beihai" in the second round.

Yang Jinzhu's blog has become lawyers official blog, every step of lawyers, Yang Jinzhu network broadcast. Media reports on the merits of each step, Yang Jinzhu, Chen Guangwu and others are reproduced in the blog. They called on the media attention, Yang Jinzhu also put the main member lawyers phone announced to the media.

The beginning, lawyers tried to seek dialogue with the authorities in Beihai. When Yang Jinzhu sat in front of the computer, write "on Guangxi's four lawyer perjury case evidence interpretation", "Beihai city police discussion Huang Huanhai death doubt" series of articles, commentaries case contradictions, Chen Guangwu is too busy to Guangxi Beihai City Vice Mayor and police chief Zhou Yuansheng wrote an open letter, remind him that "justice is not be humiliated, people can not be illegal".

Wu Lei simply to the Beihai municipal Party committee secretary Wang Xiaodong shouted, "it should be admonished, not content with merely listen to local bureaucrats". Although the letter and call did not get any response, but lawyers do not have gained nothing, one of the witnesses, still in lactation Yang Bingyan was released in July 16th, according to people familiar with the matter, "above is ordered, asked to be released".

In addition to communicate, and the association of Guangxi in July 18th, lawyers originally planned to Guangxi politics and Law Committee to complaints Beihai detention violated Fang Ligang lawyers rights and personal rights, and with the Beihai municipal Party committee secretary Wang Xiaodong.

But in the end, Chen Guangwu and other lawyers cancelled to Guangxi politics and Law Commission complaint, with Beihai municipal Party committee secretary Wang Xiaodong plan, because it might be a "disgrace".

"Or good, good or bad, very bad." Before returning to Beihai, Wu Lei told reporters predict two kinds of situations they may face in Beihai. "If the intentional injury case is not established, is bound to affect the official personal career."

That evening 6 when, Chen Guangwu returned to Beihai Liyuan Hotel, from Nanning six forty PM, dozens of unidentified Beihai native, 5001 room straight into Chen lived, then shout abuse. Chen Guangwu tried to use a portable video forensics, and rush forward, he was pressed on the edge of the bed, the camera was robbed, neck, chest, arms, and other parts of a dozen were injured, the table and a pile of materials in the case was stolen.

A man told Wu Lei, if dare to continue to handle the case, "you don't want to live out of Beihai."

At 9 pm, the restaurant in the hotel after dinner, Chen Guangwu, Wu Lei, Yang Mingkua after the hotel lobby returned to the room, which was surrounded by. Wu Lei recalled later, a group of people even dragged, attempts to bring him out hotel. The door of the hotel has stopped the car they ready vehicles, and was under a heavy rain. Yang Ming cross sees that goes forward to stop, but it is also a group of people surrounded, together to drag at. In this process, Wu Lei was down to the ground, the head had been hit, into a coma.

Afterwards, Chen Guangwu and other lawyers specifically asked the hotel front desk, whether people understand its occupancy information. Front desk told, 3 pm the day had the police came to the hotel to check guest registration and occupancy.

Chen Guangwu and the others under siege, lawyers Zhang Kai, Zhu Mingyong have rushed to Beihai. The application meets the parties concerned in a Beihai jail, again under siege, obstruct. Some people even to lawyers spit slobber. Scene photos officers and lawyers are "evidence photos", while in the micro-blog.

"Should organize lawyers representatives, negotiation and problem solving methods, procedure, way." The National People's Congress, lawyer Sun Guiling said, "don't let the lawyers to be puzzled, calling four, a scene of chaos! This is not in accord with the national interest, nor with the lawyer."

Chen Guangwu called on Beihai to lawyers, "unite, to protect the lawyers", but also from the defendant's family to send protection law. Yang Jinzhu called for a National People's Congress on behalf of the lawyers concerned, received positive response to the National People's Congress, lawyer Chi Susheng.

Late on the night of July 21st, Chi Susheng, rushed to Beihai. As representatives of the National People's Congress, Chi Susheng, come, be interpreted as the Beihai lawyers "support silent but most solemn, rights in accordance with the law to encourage China lawyer". Yang Jinzhu said, the city of Beihai by the relevant organs of the breach of privilege, dereliction of duty, play a certain deterrent effect, but also increase the sense of security of lawyers, lawyers encouraged the morale.

In July 22nd, Beihai City People's Congress Standing Committee under the assistance, Chi Susheng, a day visit the Public Security Bureau, Beihai - Beihai city procuratorate and the Beihai City Intermediate People's court. In order to build the future of communication channels, Chi Susheng, please Beihai police official leave an office telephone contact, refused, Chi Susheng, adhere to leave their contact telephone.

The same day, the National Lawyers Association's statement: "time and again out of the beginning of the all China Lawyers Association are seriously concerned about the illegal invasion from the legal practice in the Beihai process." Chi Susheng, ready to organize and case reflects the problems, to the National People's Congress to submit written criticisms and suggestions.

The National Lawyers Association of phonation, defendants intentional injury case chose however silent. Zhu Mingyong and Zhou Ze met with the parties, the parties make an ambiguous statement, whisper, from time to time, raised his head, glanced at present to monitor. Legal requirements will not be monitoring officer, please leave, but were rejected. The parties immediately fell silent.

July 26th afternoon, Beihai lawyers as planned in Beijing held a news conference, informed the media Beihai encounter, but also a multi fold. In the morning, lawyers informed, scheduled meeting room can not be used due to equipment failure, communication activities are forced to move to another Coffee museum. The lawyer of the siege of the video just put the beginning in Beihai, Coffee the sudden blackout, the darkness.

In July 29th, Chen Guangwu received the news: Beihai case of intentional injury in the morning of August 8th 9 at the Beihai intermediate people's court.

Ten days ago, the Guangxi Lawyers Association's conference room, Chen Guangwu and the association of Guangxi's leaders talk about a topic: if the trial continues, 10 defenders, 5 of the defendants, will not be arrested? The defendant confession, capture the lawyer seemed logical.

"The last time to Beijing National Lawyers Association report, Secretary General Yan Liping said, absolutely not, the leadership of the autonomous region has made, not blind grasping the law phenomenon." Chen Guangwu said. But the day once again talked about this topic, present no one bet.

The association of Guangxi criminal defense committee a deputy director even in the study, "Beihai will catch you?"