A survey report Fudan University law professor Xie Youping on suspicion of "multi contribution of one manuscript"

The academic standard word[2012] 12No.

    One, after the events

    2012Years9Month2DayUnder the pseudonym of "sunshine in winter20127"'In a member of Academic Committee of Fudan University micro-blog made a non real name to report,Said Xie Youping professor of our university law school with an article published three times, almost intact.9Month3Day, alias"Non-public known quasi five wool"Published in" new threads "website"The success of Xie Youping professor of Fudan University Law School: a draft multiple and cooperation" article published.

    9Month5DayI sent a letter to the academic committee of Standardization Committee of law school, and sent the stockNetwork in conjunction with the academic committee members responsible for law school surveyTheSolutionXie Youping"A draft multiple and cooperation"Things.School of law and government leaders and the Academic Committee attached great importance to the issue, has the interview and communication with Xie Youping.

     11Month6DaySchool of law, the academic committee held a meeting on the suspected, Xie Youping"A draft multiple"Problems are considered, and in11Month8DayTo the school academic committee"About Xie Youping suspected a draft multiple of the preliminary investigation report". Academic Committee of Law School of thought, Xie Youping suspected"A draft multiple"The facts are clear, he himself has acknowledged this fact, and has carried on the profound introspection. The relevant provisions of law school Academic Committee submitted to the academic standards committee further verification and according to the school for processing.

    The same day, the law school also turn to Xie Youping himself11Month5DayWrite"A manuscript to askProblem description and reflection"The committee admits, to the school academic norms"Online article cited a draft multiple problem is the fact that". The"A draft multiple"The basic situation:"1Each time, a draft multiple are behind my name with the students or the name of a friend.2Some of their independence, is published, then add another name to publish.3Some of their original, with another name was published and others name published."And analysis"A draft multiple"Reason."One is for my own published academic norms should be lack of understanding, not strictly implement the provisions of, two is some periodicals need well-known professor manuscript to me to write in no deal with the new situation, the three is for helping himPeople."Xie Youping realized that,"No matter what the reason, can not deny the existing draft multiple errors, which I must have the self-examination","Apologize for adverse effects caused by the reputation of the school. This problem arises in the responsibility of my own, not in the students and friends. I'm willing to bear all the consequences of academic is not standard". The letter said:"In order to show their attitude, I on9Month3DayThrough my Sina, Sohu micro-blog published "response" one article, related problems were explained, and the presence of errors to the whole society to a public apology."After he wrote the letter with a"I micro-blog published in the "response" one article".

      11Month9DayThe academic standards committee, after study again sent a letter to the law school, please them details on some important issues for investigation and solutions, detailed example: what it is"A two vote,Multiple submission"? What the article is published? These collaborative papers is Xie Youping himself to write or write? There is no teacher-student mutual plagiarism? Xie Youping in the title promotion, reward and project reporting is used to"Multiple submission"Article? Ready to adopt what remedies to eliminate or reduce the negative impact?

      11Month16DayLawAcademy Committee to submit the supplementary investigation---"About Xie Youping's alleged"A draft multiple"TheInvestigation report ", and" written by Xie Youping2001Years9Months into Fudan University scientific research and draft multiple supplement ".

    Two, the survey results

   (a) About"Duplicate publication"The specific circumstances of the verification

1, self2001Years9Xie Youping was introduced to the Fudan University, the"Duplicate publication"The article altogether13Article, the"Three timesRepeatedTable"2Article,"2Repeat"11Articles, a total of"Repeatedly published"28Story time. In the2Article"Three timesRepeatedTable"In the paper, an Xie Youping signed independently, another piece of the first author was Xie Youping, the second author Zi Ming yan. In the11Article"A draftTwo hair"The paper,2Article name Xie Youping alone;9The first author papers for the second author was Wan Yi Xie Youping(5Jiang Yong (article)2Article), Zi Ming Yan(1Article) and Zhang Haixiang(1Article).

2"New threads", the report of Xie Youping18Article alleged"A draft multiple"Among them2Article"A draft of three",16Article"A draft of two"Total38Papers, including2001Years9Xie Youping was introduced to the Fudan University before10Story time.

   Two.About"Repeatedly published"This paper is for a title, fund project and the application of awards such as the use of verification

      Xie Youping in the "supplement" said:"Do not use retransmission in the draft declaration promotion, awards and grants the application process."Via checking:

     1In, Xie Youping1998Annual assessment"Professor"Title.2001Years9Month as the introduction of talent in our law school work, so there is no use published participating titles during his tenure in our problem.

     2In, Xie Youping2006By Shanghai City eighth excellent achievements in philosophy and Social Science Award (three prize essay), winning results for constitutional and judicial papers: "power configuration and operation of the criminal proceedings in the" load "(China law"2005No.4Period), this paper also published in "Journal of Fudan University" (SOCIAL SCIENCE EDITION, publication date2005Years9In August) and "social science"2007No.1Period, belong to"Repeated three times"One of the.

     3Xie Youping once used, part "Repeatedly published"The declaration and won the award from the Academy of scientific research workload method.

     4, about whether to use"Repeatedly published"The paper used for talent project fund project, problems, because of the large span of years, but the project declaration and other original material is not retained,At present there is no specific material, no further investigation.

  (Three. About Xie Youping"Repeatedly published"His behavior is active, or as Xie Youping said,"Some are because of the magazine to my articles and manuscripts, in my statement provided no new cases"

       With the "social science" magazine, the answer is: because of2007Since the "editor" of social science has changed several times, the editor of this situation is not clear; second,2007Law editor years have left, the new law editor not to understand the matter; thirdly, whether it is"Manuscripts"In general, not as an important document into the file, do not leave any written materials, and therefore can not be found. But "social science" magazine think,"In accordance with the normal journal rules, who has published articles, academic influence much whatever the author, or whether the authors of papers written how subtle, even asked him, not to publish an article in other magazines have published papers. The copyright problem which relates to journals. Therefore, the words of Mr. Xie Youping is actually their own behavior is responsible by the editorial department, it is "social science" editorial department will not accept".

      I think the committee, Xie Youping"Repeatedly published"Should belong to the initiative himself.

   Three, the investigation conclusion 

      1,Xie Youping "Repeatedly published"The facts are clear

   Since the2001Years9On the introduction of Fudan University, Xie Youping"Repeatedly published"The article altogether13Article,28Papers in duplicate, publish these articles, the article has nothing to do with the original personnel add new author(Or replace the original author)To help others, fraud, a large number of academic misconduct, which belongs to the serious.

     2,Xie YoupingViolationResearch results publishedBasic academic standard

    Xie YoupingAs a professor at the University for many years, should clearly know the research results publishedBasic academic standard. Xie Youping will be the"Repeatedly published", or the so-called"Helping" others to championTheir papers"Repeatedly published", one is a violation of the teachers in Colleges and UniversitiesThe basic norms of academic research results published, two is the objective to help others "fraud"Effect.

  Four, treatmentOpinions andSuggestions

      1,All Xie Youping "repeatedly published" papers were not as his academic achievements for various application materials. In the future if there are violations, will be held accountable.

     2School of law, must find out by Xie Youping"Repeatedly published"All have received the award in the school and the school of law, and to withdrawAll because"Repeatedly published"And honors, rewards and benefits, and feedback the academic standards committee.

      3,Bulletin of Shanghai Science Committee of social philosophy, suggest Shanghai philosophy and Social Science CommitteeWill re consideration of Xie Youping in2006Years for the"The eighth Shanghai philosophy and Social Sciences outstanding achievement award".

       4Academic Committee, law school instructed Xie YoupingMustTo the"Repeatedly published"The magazine wrote to apologize, proposed the withdrawal of draft requirement, and "Repeatedly published",Change the author,A public apology cause adverse effects to society in the Academic Standards Committee on Webpage.On receipt of4Month11DayInvestigation ReportIn, Xie Youping5Month2To involve"Repeatedly published"The journal to the letter, review the error, and require retraction.

5School of law, the academic committee shouldBasis"Opinions on further regulating the university scientific research of Ministry of education behavior"And Xie Youping, earnestly investigate"Repeatedly publishedRelevant"Nominal authors" whether to use these papers inThe title, job promotions and awards of various benefits, if true, should be responsible for notifying the unit in which the person, ask them to dispose of in accordance with the relevant laws and regulations. At the same time, Xie Youping should beObjective to play to help others "fraud" behavior to the relevant units and partiesTo tell the truth, one one.

6School of law, the academic committee shouldSupervise the handling opinions execution, andXie Youping academic misconduct cases to the teachers and scientific researchMembers of public notification, and to the students and faculty to comply with the academic standard of education.

7,Xie Youping runsThe basic norms of academic research results published,"Repeatedly published"A large number of,In repeated publish these articles, the article has nothing to do with the original personnel add new author(Or replace the original author)Way, to help others,Caused serious negative effects to the Fudan University's academic reputation,Should be punished. ButAfter the incident, Xie Youping for his mistakes have certain knowledge, make a self-examination, admitted responsibility in his own, and actively cooperate with the investigation,Are willing to bear all the consequences arising therefrom.According to the relevant provisions of the state and social security personnel department "institution staff punishment Interim Provisions" and the school,Give him some adviceAdministrationReport the principal punishment, office set.

                                   Fudan University academic standards committee

                                                                                                           2013Years6Month14Day

Reprinted from the academic committee of Fudan University:Http://www.acad.fudan.edu.cn/s/94/t/313/d8/49/info55369.htm