1. Sun Zhigang: (Sun Zhigang, male, graduated from Wuhan University of Science and Engineering in 2001, and later to work in Shenzhen)

 

 2003Years 3On 17Day10 in the eveningPoint, he went out to the Internet as usual. In the subsequent 3Day, he had previously not been to 3Place: Guangzhou Huang Cun Street police station, Guangzhou city housing and repatriation transfer station and Guangzhou receiving personnel rescue station. The 3On the 3 dayA place, what Sun Zhigang actually happened, now he has not told us.    --"Inmate Sun Zhigang's death""Nanfang Dushi Bao" in April 25, 2003

The case after:

3On 17DayLate 10PM, Sun Zhigang out on the Internet, when passers-by Tianhe District Huang Cun Street police station ID check, for failing to take ID card, was brought back to the police station.

3On 18DayPolice: as a "staff" (without legal certificates and no normal residence, without proper source of life and living on the streets of Guangzhou) sent to detention and repatriation transfer station. In the evening, because the "discomfort" was transferred to the housing staff in Guangzhou city rescue station.

3On 20Day: 1 in the morningWhen the same ward, was 8By the staff treated twice take turns beating, 10 in the morningPM, treatment station announced the victim died, death certificate that the cause of death is "heart disease".

4On 18Day: Zhongshan Medical College forensic autopsy examination issued by the Zhongshan University Center for the book, autopsy results show that, the victim died before 72The hour once beaten.

4On 25Day: "Southern Metropolis Daily" to "inmate Sun Zhigang's death -- heaven without the need for temporary residence permits" theme first disclosed the tragic death of Sun Zhigang event. The next day, the national each big media have reproduced the article, and began tracking reports. Then, the CPC Central Committee Political Bureau Standing Committee, the committee secretary Luo Gan and Secretariat of the CPC Central Committee, deputy secretary of politics and Law Committee, Ministry of Public Security Minister Zhou Yongkang makes instructions.

4On 29DayZhangfa: Yu, Yang Zhizhu sent a letter to the National People's Congress, hundreds of people, called for the repeal of detention and repatriation system and the system of temporary residence permits, then, well-known scholars Kuang Xinnian, Li Tuo 5Scholars sent a letter to the National People's Congress, called for support.

5On 12Day: spread in 6A province of all 18Suspects who were arrested.

 

5On 14DayXu Zhiyong, Yu Jiang, Teng Biao: a National People's Congress, put forward to the "city vagrants and beggars detention and repatriation measures" to "constitutional review" proposal.

5On 16DayChina: "Youth Daily" news, the national media have reproduced, overseas media, network echo, academia

Pay attention to the deportation system, called the "constitutional review".

5On 19DayMethod, Zhongpingwang, and Beijing Huayi law firm jointly held in Beijing "detention system of constitutionality" seminar, Mao Yushi, Sheng Hong, He Weifang, Ma Huaide, Jiao Honglv, Xiao Han, He Bing et al were published views.

5On 21DayJiang Ping: famous law, Qin Hui, He Guanghu, Shen Kui and so on 8Scholars on the detention and repatriation system is discussed.

5On 23DaySheng Hong: he, Shen Kui, Xiao Han, He Haibo, 5Famous jurist in the name of Chinese Citizens United, a National People's Congress, to start the special investigation procedures, requirements for the detention and repatriation system "constitutional review" entered a substantive legal operation level.

5On 29Day200: the networkMany citizens signature induced high open letter, 10Days later, the number of signatures to 374People.

6On 5Day18The accused three courts in Guangzhou city at the same time. The day of the trial of the atmosphere is very tense, after the selection of the auditor must pass two security and five validation shall enter.

6On 7DayThe people's congresses and parliaments: Center for the study of the Law School of Peking University held "the Citizens Advice unconstitutional review case conference". Method also specially set up 4One group, the refinement of "legislation law" in the constitutional review process as a research project, and drawing up a relatively perfect program design, as a legislative proposal submitted to the National People's congress.

6On 9Day18The accused man was sentenced to death, a man a reprieve, life imprisonment, the remaining 15Add up to about 100 peopleYears. At the same time, Guangzhou city announced: 23Government officials should be subject to a penalty from removed.

 

Guangzhou City Intermediate People's court"The Sun Zhigang case"The trial site

 

6On 10Day: Beijing Bar Association Professional Committee of human rights and constitution, the Unirule Institute of Tsinghua University, constitution and civil rights center again organization of legal theory and practice circles senior scholars, law, economics and administration and other experts to conduct seminars on the Sun Zhigang case legal dilemma after a trial.

6On 16DayLegislative Affairs Office of the State Council held: the expert argumentation. Jiang Mingan, Ma Huaide, Ying Songnian, Yuan Shuhong, Han Dayuan 5A well-known legal experts invited to.

6On 18Day: Premier Wen Jiabao chaired a State Council executive meeting, considered by the "city living without the street begging rescue personnel management approach (Draft)"

 

6On 20Day381: the State Council promulgatedOrders, new measures shall be implemented as of August 1st shall be abolished at the same time, the old method.

8On 1Day1982The year began to implement "city vagrants and beggars detention and repatriation measures" abolished.

 

 

"Annals of Guangzhou" 2004Annual: June 9th, Wuhan young Sun Zhigang in Guangzhou was intentional injury case in Guangzhou City Intermediate People's Court of first instance judgement. In June 27th, Guangdong Province High Court made a final decision on "Sun Zhigang case". That year, the national abolition of detention and repatriation measures, the implementation of management measures.

 

Review: Sun Zhigang to his death for the repeal of a bad law, in this sense, he is a hero!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2The Liu Yong case:

Liu Yong 1960Years, Shenyang city. 1995Years of its private enterprises Jiayang group. Served as chairman of the Shenyang Municipal People's Congress, China Zhi Gong Party Shenyang branch assistant director committee member, the group, also received the outstanding private entrepreneurs, the local poverty advanced individual title, become Shenyang Heping District CPPCC members)

 

The case after: since 1995Years ago, Liu Yong to Shenyang Jiayang group as the basis, take the violence, threats and other means to amass wealth, dominate the party, business to the black.

1999Years 10For months, Liu Yong Yunwushan cigarette sales situation is not good, letting Cheng Jian go to the market to view and "pack" dealing in the same kind of cigarette industry, in October 15th, Song Jianfei and others on business Yunwu Mountain cigarettes owner Wang Yongxue were beaten by Wang Yongxue, right hilar rupture, right atrial rupture, acute hemorrhagic shock and death.

2000Years 7On 11DayBy the Shenyang Municipal Public Security Bureau of criminal detention, 10 August the same year by the Shenyang City People's Procuratorate approved the arrest.

In the process of Liu Yong case at trial in court, intentional injury of Liu Yong and the gang, the earliest can be traced back to September 11, 1989, Liu Yong suspected his then girlfriend, and singing in the second session of the National Youth Games Theme Song actor Ning Yong ambiguous relationship, he and Song Jianfei were on Ning Yong beatings, removed to the spleen rupture.

1995Years ago, Liu Yong crime and gangs mainly focused on the problem of intentional injuries, but from 1995Years later, Liu Yong "Organization, leadership organization with underworld society nature" involved in the plot and behavior appear. For example, according to the survey, the public prosecutor: 1995Years 9, 10In August, Liu Yong to occupy the street Shenyang Shuangxing Shopping Center opened PARKnSHOP supermarket, directs the beater to shopping center manager Wu were beaten, and then to the Wu threats and harassment, forced Wu will spend 200Multi million renovation of 470 goodSquare meters room window "leased" to him. Later, Liu Yong again to the others for 25Million yuan, out of 5Million to the Wu as compensation; 1997In the fall, the monopoly cigarette market, Liu Yong sent hitmen to owners Lee, Zhang wounded, will be paved smashed; 1998Years 5In August, Liu Yong inspired Song Jianfei 3In Shenyang Spring Leisure Square smashed two paved; in June 11, 1998, Liu Yong's thugs at the behest of performing official duties according to law, Liaoning Province Technical Supervision Information Research Institute 3Workers were beaten, two of them were injured; 1999Years 5Month, Liu Yong won the Shenyang Street commercial development rights, means the use of violence, forced relocation. And letting the hatchet man holding knives, bayonets and other weapons, in said of peaceful times. under smashed pharmacy, cut the duty manager and staff.

According to statistics, Liu Yong underworld organization from 1995Initially formed to 2000 at the end of the yearYears 7Month by police in Shenyang arrested 4Year and a half, Liu Yong personally involved in crime or have inspired others 27Play.

2002Years 4In August, Liu Yong was in Liaoning Province, Tieling City Intermediate People's court to organization, leadership organization with underworld society crime, the crime of intentional injury, the illegal business crime, the crime of intentional destruction of property, bribery crime, the crime of obstructing, illegal possession of firearms charges sentenced to death. Subsequently, Liu Yong refuses to accept. In August 15, 2003, Liu Yong was the Liaoning Provincial Higher People's court at approximately the same charges commuted the death sentence, suspended for two years. Revision of the reason is because Liu Yong took off his jacket in court, the obvious signs of being hit on the body. Liu Yong pointed out that the public security organs using torture to extract confessions of the. Criminal law expert Chen Xingliang said Liu Yong case revision is to protect human rights, is a great progress of our legal system reform. But many of the media on the judgment of the question. Shanghai "the Bund pictorial" published in August 21st by Li Shuming the "question" to the Shenyang gang leader Liu Yong commuted sentence, the first stone is aroused waves of public opinion.

The social public opinion has changed have questioned, and questioned the Liu Yong commuted defense expert. In view of the strong pressure of public opinion. In December 22, 2003, the Supreme People's court for trial in Jinzhou city of Liaoning Province Liu Yong case. Make a decision after the retrial: to the crime of intentional injury, Liu Yong was sentenced to death, deprived of political rights for life; and committed other crimes, decided to implement the death penalty, deprivation of political rights for life.

 

  Review: Liu Yong case was brought to court for trial, some people think that this is a kind of progress, because it conforms to the nominal. But can not be ignored, when we uphold the justice of entity, has once again ignored the procedural justice. Liu Yong case is China Xin Pusheng case, but China Xin Pusheng dead. Use the umsxxxEvaluation: the death of Sun Zhigang, his sacrifice for the abolition of the darkness of the detention and repatriation system, we say that he is a hero. The death of Liu Yong, his sacrifice is not to the dark Chinese criminal justice system change, his throat for 13Billion Chinese call for a better tomorrow, but this 13Million people in the most"The naive view of justice"Buried his blood, he just as the execution of Tan Sitong, left a calling method of the blood, the blood was eventually abandoned by people. He is a more than Sun Zhigang the meaning of tragic hero, his body has not only killed himself with this dark system of sorrow, 13 moreBillion Chinese do not want to change the system, and could not even see the dark dark sorrow.

 

 

 

The death of Liu Yong!......The victory! A victory for justice! According to the law of victory! It This cheers the people greatly!......Liu Yong is dead, but if you think the death of Liu Yong, the case is One finished, all is finished. Everything will be fine., I see too early. Some of the problems, and even some serious problems, not Liu Yong go to the coffin, it was still wandering in society, its ghost has not dispersed, it still affects people's lives, exposing the lies in said of peaceful times. contrast is the principle of ruling the country.......Chen Xingliang and friends come from Beijing that the Liu Yong case to be recorded in the law school textbooks, but I do not know to remember is Chinese jurisprudence shame or glory. ...... [According to people.com.cn]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

3Xu Ting case:

                 

 

The case after: in late April 21, 2006 10, Xu Ting came to a bank of Whampoa　 road in Tianhe District ATMTeller machine withdrawals. Results out of 1000Yuan, he was surprised to find that the bank card account only held 1Yuan, ecstasy, Xu Ting continuous withdrawal 5.4Million yuan. That night, Xu Ting back home, will tell the Guo Anshan companion. Two people immediately back to the drawing, after repeated operations several times. After the police investigation, Xu Ting successively withdraw 171A pen, a total of 17.5Million yuan; Guo Anshan teller 1.8Million yuan. Afterwards, two of the articles money abscond, Xu Ting in April 24, 2006 from Guangzhou to return home at noon.

   In November 7, 2006, Guo Anshan to surrender to the public security organs, and refund the money 1.8Million yuan, the Tianhe District court, 2007Years 5On the court finds its constitute the crime of theft, but considering their surrender and take the initiative to return, so the sentenced to one year in prison, fined 1000Element. And with a year of Xu Ting, 17.5Million yuan of money because of the failure of investment spending a space, in May 22, 2007, was arrested in Shaanxi Baoji Railway Station. 9 the same yearOn 27Day, Guangzhou city procuratorate to sue Xu Ting larceny. In November 6, 2007, the Guangzhou City Intermediate People's court began hearing the case of Xu Ting, prosecutors say, the defendant knowingly teller machine failure, malicious withdrawal of theft. 11 the same yearOn 20Day, the court held that the defendant Xu Tingyi illegal occupation, for the purpose of the same case, group by means of stealing secrets, financial institutions, if the amount involved is especially huge, behavior has constitute the crime of theft, was sentenced to life imprisonment, deprived of political rights for life, confiscation of all personal property, the illegal income or the defendant Xu Ting 17.5Million reimbursement of Guangzhou city commercial bank.

     The decision came out, immediately aroused Public opinion is seething with indignation. People generally think that the sentence is too heavy, and not on the banks of the negligence responsibility. 2008Years 1Earlier this month, the case into the procedure of second instance. The provincial high court in Criminal Adjudication "confirmation": "the original verdict that the defendant Xu Ting theft facts unclear, insufficient evidence, according to the" law of criminal procedure "189thThe provisions of the third paragraph of rule to cancel the criminal judgments, Guangzhou City Intermediate People's court, back to City Intermediate People's court re trial. The withdrawal of the original trial the defendant Xu Ting 'theft, sentenced to life imprisonment, deprived of political rights for life, confiscation of personal property; or

The illegal income the defendant Xu Ting 175000Yuan returned to Guangzhou commercial bank ' Charge.

2008Years 2On 22Day9 in the morning, Xu Ting case to trial in Guangzhou City Intermediate People's court, and in March 31, 2008 the Guangzhou intermediate people's court sentenced to the crime of theft, financial institutions, sentenced to Xu Ting sentenced to 5Years, fined 2Million, and the recovery of 17Million yuan of illegal income.

       

 

 

2008Years 4On 9DayMorning, Xu Ting formally to the Guangdong Provincial Higher People's Court of appeal, Ting Xu insisted: its behavior is civil relationship negligence, not criminal, should not constitute a theft, reviewing the original judgment qualitative error, second instance shall make a verdict of not guilty.

   In May 22, 2008, Guangdong Provincial Higher People's court public hearing to reopen the case of Xu Ting, after the court, the court made a final ruling: the collegial panel in accordance with the law, the court rejected the Xu Ting appeal, upheld the. In this regard, Xu Ting will be sentenced to 5Years and fined 2Million yuan, continue to pursue illegal income 173826Element. In May 23, 2008, Guangdong Province High Court Criminal rulings, and shall be submitted to the approval of the Supreme People's court.

    The Supreme Court shall form a collegial panel to review, regarding the case of Xu Ting, Ting Xu in the knowledge that their bank card only 170The multivariate case, take the machine has not yet found the bank staff, illegal withdrawal 174825Element, and absconded with the money behavior, already constituted larceny; Xu Ting theft of financial institutions, especially huge amount, according to the law should be sentenced to life imprisonment or criminal punishment; but considering the Xu Ting is found in ATM fault conditions of impromptu theft, their behavior has a certain chance, compared with premeditated, ready to stealing financial agency crime, subjective malice is relatively small; Xu Ting's failure while ATM machine, using the input method instruction withdrawals of stealing money, compared with the means of destruction to steal money, crime circumstances are relatively light. Then that a trial, appellate ruling facts are clear, the evidence is, well, the conviction is accurate, appropriate sentencing, judge the legal procedure, and make the criminal ruling in August 20, 2008, Guangdong Province high court approval to maintain the appeal verdict. So far, the Xu Ting case of final judgment in effect and executed.

 

 

Review: Xu Ting is unfortunate, he China such system was sentenced. If he was born in England, did not. But he is lucky, because there are a lot of Xu Ting man was sentenced to no period. Worthy of our reflection is,

"The Supreme People's Court on the trial of theft of concrete application of law interpretation of several issues"The law is in1997Years11Month4DayIntroductionWhen a huge amount, that is3Million to10Million yuan. And in the10Years later, this provision applies.

 

 

 

4She Xianglin: (She Xianglin, male, born 7 March 1966, Jingshan County, Kou Zhen He Chang Cun, nine groups of people, before catching Department of Jingshan County Public Security Bureau police station public security patrol raw Ma Dian.)

        

Case: in January 20, 1994, after She Xianglin's wife Zhang Zaiyu disappeared, Zhang relatives suspect Zhang she was killed. In April 11th the same year, Yan men Kou Zhen Lu Chong Cun a pond where they found the body of Zhang Zaiyu, the deceased relatives to identify consistent with as Zhang characteristics, the public security organ for investigation.

   In April 12, 1994 She Xianglin was Jingshan County Public Security Bureau residential surveillance for suspected of intentional homicide, the same year 4On 22Japan was under criminal detention, approved the arrest in April 28 of the Jingshan County People's procuratorate.

1994Years 10On 13DayThe Jingzhou intermediate court of First Instance sentenced She Xianglin to death, she appealed. Hubei province high court in January 6, 1995 ruled, in fact is not clear, the evidence is insufficient remand.

1995Years 5On 15DayThe former Jingzhou district attorney branch of the supplemental investigation. In February 7, 1996, Jingshan County procuratorate for supplementary investigation again after checking. 1997Due to the change of administrative districts, Jingshan County Procuratorate in November 23, 1997 will be the case to the Jingmen city procuratorate prosecution. 12 the same yearOn 15Day, Jingmen city procuratorate review She Xianglin's behavior that is not enough for the sentenced to life imprisonment or criminal punishment, the case to be transferred to the Jingshan County procuratorate for prosecution. In March 31, 1998, Jingshan County procuratorate the case will be prosecuted to the court of Jingshan county.

   In June 15, 1998, Jingshan county court to voluntary manslaughter and sentenced She Xianglin sentenced to 15Years, 5 additional deprivation of political rightsYears. She's appeal, the same year 9On 22Day, Jingmen City Intermediate Court rejected the appeal, upheld the. Later, She Xianglin was put into the prison in Shayang.

   In March 28, 2005, was identified in 11Town residents in Jingshan County, years ago by her husband She Xianglin killed Zhang Zaiyu suddenly back, immediately become a sensational news event, She Xianglin has become the misjudged case.

 

2005Years 4On 13DayHubei, Jingshan County People's court in front of Harusu Roteru. From the country's 120Several media 200Journalists and thousands of local people gathered in the 20 meters wide streets, hoping to witness the grievance redress process. 9 in the morningUp to 1040Divided, retrial procedure is completed, She Xianglin got his innocence, was declared acquittal, he had to pay 3995Day held. After being widely disclosed in the She Xianglin case, case causes a focus of public attention, in April 7th, a Xinhua on the problem down she judicial procedures for the presumption of guilt, set after the first trial, and illegal evidence three lessons. Just before she was reviewed, the Beijing News reporters access to the files of the case, tries hard from the fact she was 11 reductionThe judicial process years ago.

Focus one: identify the corpse

  On April 11, 1994 morning 11Yanmen town of Jingshan County, Hubei police received a report said, a female body was found floating in the water in Lu Chong Cun near a pond, on the afternoon of the same day 245Points, the township police station rushed to the scene. Prior to this, the night of January 20th, She Xianglin mentally ill wife Zhang Zaiyu missing, Zhang Zaiyu's cousin in the January 22nd report, but have been unable to find. Therefore, the evening of April 11th, when Ma Dian police station when security patrol She Xianglin was taken to a hotel and then Jingshan County Public Security Bureau police battalion captain Lu Dingcheng told: "your wife has been found, belong to him, you must accept our review." However, the identification of the unknown woman is Zhang Zaiyu, She Xianglin did not see the bodies, the reason is, this is not for you to say, the government must be true. Further confirmation of the corpse, but local police with no funds for without a paternity test. 11Days later, identification certificate issued by the Jingshan County Public Security Bureau forensic display, the She Xianglin wife Zhang Zaiyu, the evening of January 20, 1993 from the home, is blunt injury sank drowning suffocated, and from internal extraction such as diatoms. In April 22nd, She Xianglin was detained, arrested in April 28th.

 

Two focus: the four way of committing the crime

N           From She Xiang Lin case files can be seen in April 11, 1994, to April 22nd, 11Days of interrogation, She Xianglin confessed that four kind of modus operandi. In the subsequent trial has been proposed as doubts.
The first kind of modus operandi: the twelfth lunar month lunar month (January 20, 1994 1993)At night, She Xianglin will Zhang Zaiyu go out at the gate, she took a dray crowbar, Zhang Yan men Kou Zhen Hong Qi to gravel plant hillside, Zhang killed buried ditch.
The second kind of modus operandi: the twelfth lunar month lunar month, see Wei Taiping (She XianglinShe's friend, at that time in the township transportation management station work)In the township veterinary station opposite the entrance to play table tennis, she will Zhang Zaiyu to Wei Taiping let it away, Wei Zhang to Long Gang Cun two sets of pumps, twelfth lunar month twelve, She Xianglin and Wei Taiping stone Zhang killed, into the water.
In third ways: 1993The ninth year twelfth lunar month in the township veterinary station, She Xianglin met with Wei Taiping, let Wei Taiping 11 in the eveningAt home that evening, she said something, and Wei to bring Zhang Zaiyu to Long Gang Cun two sets of pumps, to Zhang Huan good clothes, then to the Lv Chongjiu group kiln Ao Ba Shan stone Zhang killed, then will sink into the water with a four stone snakeskin bag.
Police believe the first is a false statement, because a body not in the ditch, She Xianglin tentatively to see the police will find the body. Second, three kinds of modus operandi was later denied. The evidence is long Gang Cun, two groups of Hu Mingde (Male, 65Years old)About these past few nights, he slept in the pumping, no interval of one day, and the day locked room, in addition, nor could Zhang Zaiyu and Wei alone. Since then, the local hospital certificate, Zhang Zaiyu disappeared for several days in the hospital, Wei Taiping is to take medicine, do not have the time to commit the crime.
In this way, fourth kinds of situation She Xianglin confession, identified by police"In accordance with the facts of cases": in late January 20, 1994 10PM, she will be insane wife pulled up from the bed, to a protected, shut up. The second day at two thirty in the morning, she will be six year old daughter to the parents room, that his wife had to go out looking for a wife, and then on the grounds, holding a torch, twine and Zhang Zaiyu's trousers, pushing the bike, to own, to give his wife a change clothes. Then he brought his wife to Lu Chong Cun nine groups of the pond, while Zhang unprepared, move a stone hit a head, face to Zhang can not, will be a drag to the northeast corner of the pond, with the rope will be equipped with four stone snakeskin bag attached the body into the water. The next afternoon from a body clothes are burned in their kitchen. This statement in time for the April 20, 1994.  

       To this, She Xianglin says, the statement is in the police inducement and torture to extract confessions made under:"I dare say that 10Day 11Night pain and not everyone can understand, the nose has been broken, they have put my head brutally to the bathtub, I several times due to lack of strength to drink water in the tub to choke the almost unconscious......Long Bu, also wearing leather shoes feet kicked my foot." "So, they don't stop was beaten, for me, in order to avoid that corporal punishment, torture, and again I made up that night to find his wife on the way home in the closed bridge reservoir met my wife."

 

Three focus: roadmap

      Records show, late on April 21, 1994, She Xianglin was the police to identify the scene of the crime. This is considered to be one of the key links in the case of She Xianglin. Jingshan County Public Security Bureau material proof, this distance is 11Km, and after two the top of the hill, on the same day under a light rain, She Xianglin can find the site, with a walking route map, so that She Xianglin had authentic. But this story, She Xianglin recalls, in the April 15, 1994 criminal police production brigade polices to his interrogation, Criminal Police Brigade instructors see he really can not say the range, he pulled his desk, while explaining how to walk to draw him a"Walking route map"At that time, two other investigators present. She Xianglin in the 1998Years of complaints material recorded in the field after the assignment:"Although they had to draw me walking route map, I still can't take them, because I have never been to that place, was taken to shut off the bridge, they will be highly swollen root legs were beaten

This is unable to walk and comatose I stand off......Can not find the road, the rain, the police have loyalty and the township police station police direct frame me toward the left, in front of me 50 meters and two way, one is He Zeliang, one can not remember the name."

Unfortunately, these points are ignored.

 

2005Years 10On 27DayShe Xianglin and his family, and the Hubei Provincial Public Security Bureau of Jingshan County signed compensation agreement, a total of 45 won the national compensationMillion yuan.

 She Xianglin for this case the destiny is changed, the same is the case changed his destiny and:

 Yang Wuxiang: she is the mother of the woman, the body health, accident due to petitions were kept for nine months, out of death three months detention.

　 Since she Xiang Lin after the accident, she began to reflect the situation of his family to the departments at all levels. Yang Wuxiang went around the villages in order to find out the daughter-in-law. Because She Xianglin told her"I did not kill her "This stubborn, and son of the rural women began to debate the difficult road son.

    Later, she was given a proof of a met Zhang Zaiyu. However, this"Conscience proof"Sent to the relevant departments, have not been so she Jia surprise results, the answer is"This set of us much". But Yang Wuxiang because of repeated petitions and complaints are caught, arrested is the reason"Crime of shield","Obstruction of justice". Nine months later, the notice she family with 3000Yuan to lead people, she Jiachou not so much money, daughter She Cuie borrowed 600Yuan and his father go to the people, the guards took Yang Wuxiang back out, 64Old She Shusheng squat body, arms bent behind . "She became blind and deaf, unable to walk."His wife She Shusheng and his wife just cry, nor in the detention house encounter, just said "The treatment is not good". In pain. After three months, Yang Wuxiang died.

 

She Huarong: She Xianglin's daughter, six year old. An outstanding, grade one was forced to drop out of school, 14Years of work, now a Dongguan electronics factory.

"She is intelligent, good grades, always top." "But her a post, no one is willing to make friends with her, you are not to talk to her, she did not play, by talking."

   On the beginning of time, Petitions and complaints to home run out of money, She Huarong dropped out of school because of poverty. 14Years old, in She Huarong for a 18Fake ID years later, uncle took her to work in Shenzhen.

 

 

10For many years, we have always lived in She Xianglin is a murderer's shadow "-- 　　

    She Suolin: she's older brother, is he Chang Cun, nine groups of Zhibao director, the Communist Party, after a petition was 41Day, Zhibao director, probationary Party member was withdrawn, now for the township post office subscription, the postman, a monthly income of 1000 yuan.

She Guilin: she's brother, unbearable rumors, has to work in Shenzhen.

She Meilin: she's brother, was the villagers discrimination, leaving Guangdong work.

Jiang Yinxi: she's sister-in-law, live in the shadow of the night, in the township to sell barbecue.

 

 

 

Conscience permits people encounter

     "A group calling itself the Jingshan Secretary of County Committee of people at that time"Pa"The pistol to shoot to the desktop, to admit that I do is false, I quarreled with him."Ni Leping said.

   Ni Leping: originally Yao Ling Cun Cun Wei deputy secretary, now retired cadres to do card, it owes usury.  

    Nie Maiqing: Tianmen Shi He Zhen Yao Ling Cun village, Ni wife, healthy woman, was closed in March after heart disease so far.

Ni Xinhai: Yao Ling Cun to testify the villagers, was 22Day out year-round cough, lose labor ability.

 

 

 

(Stewed Assorted Delicacies She Xianglin after prison)

 

Reflection: in this case, many phenomena are very provide much material for thought. Such as the suspect was torture to extract confessions, petitioners were arrested; the legitimate complaints of untreated, legal defense not adopted; dare to testify the people affected, suspect child be implicated......Perhaps we should rethink "homicide cases must be broken" behind the concept of the facts of the case.