BrokenThe prisonNote

                Author: idiotic judge

   

    Idiotic judge of Shuangfeng County People's Court of non party vice president Lv Yinhua. In this paper, stick up for a long time. Strange is that from November 10th onwards, see this post suddenly up once more. Since want to see, suggest that you also read the following two links

Http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_6afaff570101faiq.html

Http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_6afaff570101f35i.html

 

I am no pack adult hen, nor the Song Dynasty of the intellect, not broken any shaking heaven and earth's case, but not washed many miscarriage of justice, no qualification to write what "case". One person once caught, meteorites can also hit on the head, think unstoppable. An accidental opportunity, the Xinhua County Liu Moubai et al of triad gangs, originally is the most common not with ordinary criminal cases, the defendant commissioned in famous barrister, writer Yang Jinzhu, Zhang Lei, Zhu Mingyong, Chen Guangwu et al. Defense, makes the case suddenly had a significant impact, I also follow moneymaking businesses the famous, greatly. Especially Zhang Lei lawyers work "Shuangfeng Ji", say "judge" how to legally blind, how idiotic, "judge", I also. Although big lawyer not write me a few words, but the known is always good, don't you see her? Relying on several shocking pictures known as Song Zuying, appearance fees; have you not seen Gan Lulu? The shy cloth is thrown, online show the slide, reputation big explosion, earning large quantities of gold each day, we Loudi people to honor her money; don't you see Ye Haiyan? The parents give a file to be immediately known around the world, literally, code words and literary, prostitution of thing anyone on the internet;Don't you see the Lawyer Zhang, Yang? In court a noisy, second days became a barrister, 54 million fee. A good mood when, some fraction of the people, affixed to the face, gold, and to help people in distress of a Buddism godness Guanyin bodhisattva. People more money, silly, and a lot of money to send the door to, what is there against it?Ha-ha.

By Zhang, Yang big lawyer light, cases have a significant impact, but it does not have special place, nothing to write. But the court promised big lawyers, I will also write an article "a note", to quote Dade counsel famous, though slightly, also should know how to Thanksgiving, for the way.All are residues of the brain, still do not know what to write good, but still the right toe, the thought, have the experienceGenerally, celebrity biography, defense lawyer a case is an experience, have a lawyer to write his memoirs, heWrite big lawyers valiant recordNow, Gu for barristers biography do what little one can to help, and that.

(a), at first I counsel

I smell, never heard of the Chinese a lawyer, only heard of a lawyer, Hongkong lawyer, the English a lawyer...... The Liu Moubai case, eye opening, not only hear counsel, and have the pleasure of seeing live bar.

Liu Moubai is Hunan Xinhua people, the crime in Xinhua, Xu is for instance big convention, the designated court. I left the court, has been in charge of civil trial for four years, reasonable in the circumstances it is not for me to judge the case. However, the weather is unpredictable, in mid July last year, I suddenly find a conversation, asked me to trial the case, there are two reasons, one is my leisure; two is our trial shehei cases. I immediately Kennedy speech without reason, also has two, one is the criminal trial time is short, the level difference; two is I left the criminal trial years, business has been born. No, the Dean had to submit the group discussion, the two party will have decided I the. Organization of my party principles, is the individual is subordinate to the organization, It is all up with I'm doomed, doomed. It seems the leisure is not necessarily a good thing, it, anyway.

A few days after the court files, and colleagues in the discussion, Guiyang Xiaohe court a shehei cases, the lawyers make division, led by a series of lawyer Yang Jinzhu, the court can not control the situation, in the Supreme People's court, the Supreme People's commissar, Ministry of justice, school leadership in command, makes the case. This is the first time I heard the Chinese a lawyer, is also the first time I heard the term "Nao division", at that time did not care, do not believe. I thought, not a court rules? Who dares to make the court? Gradually, began a lawyer friend told me a tribunal Guiyang thing, say lawyers made hero, words are all revealed a cult situation, face quite satisfaction. See I don't believe it, he put on a court information online through the mobile phone QQ sent me to see, to prove that Yang Jinzhu et al have a tribunal courage, Yang Jinzhu called President Wang Shengjun to resign and the nine standing committee of the letter was sent to me. So, I have to believe it. But the Guiyang too distant, tense marking plus, also has not gone to pay attention. After a period of time, the tribunal president suddenly told me, Yang Jinzhu would have defended Liu Moubai, Guiyang a tribunal team will attend classes, remind me to make preparations, I surface answer, it was like, I strictly according to the law of criminal procedure "trial", Kim, silver column he shouts. Speaking of many people, I began to recall more than twenty years ago Loudi teachers college part-time lawyer named Yang Jinzhu, my case and he has argued, just don't know this whether Yang Jinzhu is Peter Yang Jinzhu, based on my teachers know Yang Jinzhu, he should not make family capital and confidence. He does, is a curse can never hide, hide not evil, that time to say it.

(two), project group

I mainly specified trial after the person, who routinely established case group, another rent site office, I because "big government", no doubt as a leader. "Task force", special, special, handling a case. Baidu Search.Understanding to the lawyers speak highly of the western free world also has the project group. Later learned, barristers have declared the project groupIllegal organizationThat project, group behavior invalid. Counsel of Italy, the arrested people for a case is wrong, must a little, as the great lawyers in a court, halfway to open a court to another, to do something, make a little extra money, or the United States and the United States get some sleep, or to Beijing to look for a big leadership, both in court, midway have several times on the toilet, to the court for a stroll, smoked cigarettes. The school leadership has no authority, knowing that the lawyers have been sentenced to death penalty project group, still committing the crime against the wind, really hateful. We also have to follow the customs examination, public security, set up a task force consisting of dozens of police officers, specially the case, by the public security organs to members, in order to prevent foreign investigators do not listen to the local public security organ command, then the Municipal Committee Secretary nominal commander, led the city Public Security Bureau is responsible for the operational guidance. Unfortunately, they are indeed special project, not really something else, estimates will be the big lawyers batch batch of smelly.

(three), at the beginning of counsel

One August morning, the collegial panel is tense marking, office burst into two men, stature is not high, an approximately 50 year old, wearing a delicate, wearing a pair of glasses in Phnom Penh, the other a much younger. The young man pointed to the glasses man said: This is Yang Jinzhu's lawyer, Liu Moubai's lawyer. My heart sank, Murphy legendary make court really will be staged in Shuangfeng? I'm not uncover timbres, immediately stepped forward to shake hands, and asked him whether in Loudi division commander, Yang Jinzhu face over the slightest surprised expression, immediately recognized. It seems that Yang Jinzhu is Peter Yang Jin, tilting moment, my confidence, then took Yang Jinzhu as saying: "old friends, you don't know me? I'm a lawyer, had done, more than twenty years ago and you have defended a case." Yang obvious surprise, ask what is the case. I replied: "Zi bridge that seven man gang rape case." The expected scene really happen, Yang big lawyer face and neck "唰" red, of course, I have to admire the young barrister self adjustment ability, only one or two seconds, turned on the restoration of the original state, if not observed my deliberate, it is difficult to find abnormal, from this moment I firmly believe that, doubleA tribunal phenomenon too big not appear peak court, at least not make to in commissar and the Supreme Court took command.I see the purpose has been achieved, is incomplete, no longer talking things through. But Yang big law but to a a clumsy denial resulting in self-exposure, immediately explained: "the second trial is not me." I smiled, to avoid embarrassment, quickly put the topic to the legend of the River Court events make up. Yang immediately to the spirit, the voice also many, even dance with joy, when it comes to how they make the public prosecution, they can, how to make the case to pause, to delay the time trial court to force them, how to stand up in court, how to let the Beihai police sweat on the court, how to let the court notice send a fly, how to group of Wang Shengjun, Zhang Jun and so on to scold, I hear the terrified, a word is not inserted. When he had finished, I put forward a suggestion: "if you don't make the court in Shuangfeng, the image will greatly, Zhang Jun scold you unscrupulous lawyer also is less evidence." Yang Liji response, immediately said to a good cooperation with the court, the court will not make. Because discourse speculation, both from each other not made some jokes. I put through this case to his bag, he readily promised, give me $one hundred thousand. The morning passed imperceptibly, although wasted the precious marking time, I think it is worth it. Next is the main way to the satisfaction of all, speech, not press.

 

(four), the great theory of the lawyers

The lawyer behaviour aroused high attention, aroused me to explore the people desire, while Yang big lawyer has said not to be in court, but heard about this man speak not count, in order to make the court not to make too much, I decided to find out more about the so-called "unscrupulous lawyer", Sun Tzu said: "knowing yourself, know yourself". So, my day marking, see Yang lawyer blog night. From case to case of Beihai River, and then to the Li Zhuang case...... Sometimes we make some notes, write down the big lawyers make family routines, to prepare for possible period of want or need. A month later, quite some experience, also summarizes some insight barristers, roughly as follows:

A large, lawyer's case, the trial shall have a higher level, at least is the vice president. Otherwise, barristers are uneven. The river court trial Huang Min although for your vice president, but also a size of leadership, but the lawyers are despised, and that they don't deserve, make every attempt to court. I have to admire the leaders have farsightedness, though I steal in the vice president position, but de thin was widowed, business than in many judges, just for leisure and the case. But at any rate and lawyers match probability, make court has minus one;

Two, big lawyers defense officials they were honest, the incumbent officials all corrupt officials, all lawyers defense cases, each of them is a grievance, are the police torture to extract confessions induced miscarriage of justice. Big lawyers to defend, I guarantee to Chairman Mao, no interference, a tribunal probability and minus one;

Three, Chinese no organization with underworld society nature, all the forces are "black", criminal law should cancel the underworld crime, for the rich can not be the underworld crime, otherwise is robbing entrepreneur property. If I do not need to be expressed conviction, no conflict, risk a tribunal to minus one;

Four, where the police were the devil, designed to catch the good man, never catch villains; one is the clown, dedicated to confuse right and wrong, good judge sewage settlement; everyone is an idiot, every day for the public endorsement, paste confused th; great glory, only lawyers, right, is the rule of the pioneer, the moral model. If I am in the trial period not to read the lawyers work, should not conflict, risk alarm court dropped six points;

Five, big lawyer is a man of God, as long as the defendant in the law is not money, material, also do not meet the defendant, without investigation, will be announced the case is the case, and would have a torture to extract confessions. Although I was not easily dry lawyer pleaded not guilty, the defendant also tend to plead guilty. There is a conflict as management concept, but such actions, not hurt me, Lai was to risk a tribunal, fell to five points;

Under the jurisdiction of six cases, lawyers say, the court decided not to count. Have an impact on the jurisdiction of the case for designation of jurisdiction has become the judicial practice, from the Chen Xitong case, Chen Liangyu case, and more recently, the thin king case, all the same, although there is no clear legal provisions, but in practice, good effect, can eliminate a lot of disturbance, the defendant is more fair trial. Social law, no not from the start, and then rise to the law. Domestic law, foreign law, international law and so. But law is often the custom evaluation according to their own needs, when a conflict with a court of competent jurisdiction, that the case shall designate jurisdiction, when the conflict with the specified under the jurisdiction of the court, then that designated jurisdiction is not legitimate, and therefore the trouble raising. This kind of behavior, I will not go to war, even if they carry out the court has no jurisdiction, I better go, risk a court to four points;

Seven, the lawyer's client procedures and relevant materials allows anyone to post, also can judge, lawyer to do can phone text messages and instructions to send notice to appear, the court lawyer must be in court three days ago to delivery, and can not affect the attorney to rest, telephone and SMS notification is absolutely out of the question, or lawyer. Not to appear in court. I grew up in the ravine, rarely seen much of the world, the mind if big lawyers to such a hand, and let me free once aircraft addiction, all over the country sightseeing, no trouble, risk alarm court down to three points;

Eight, the public prosecutor, the work must be the pink of perfection, typos are sin unforgivable appear in documents, the lawyer's job can not do, everything on the court, it can't write, record is the obligation of the court. I am not the sage, work inevitably omissions, there may be a family risk;

Nine, the judge can not stop the defendant speech, even irrelevant speech, even if repeated ten times more content, or to deprive the defendant's right to defense. I don't like to repeat the words, not as long as it is not too much, can endure, caused a family risk;

Ten, the court should hear lawyers, lawyers said the long trial lawyer how long, what you want to do, say what you want to say, the judge can not stop, otherwise is to restrict the right to defense lawyers, can make the court, the court is the court rules formulated, can not restrain the lawyer. Although I am stupid, after all, not wood Bodhisattva, cause trouble tribunal risk odd.

Laws are innumerable remarks, I to one one lists, and other point of view although many I disagree, but as long as you can bear, most do not cause a tribunal, press not to mention.

(five), goodbye bar

Forget what time, Yang Jinzhu lawyer second came to my office, and at the same time, to have the Kyoto lawyers Yang Xuelin, after a busy noisy, Yang big lawyer gave us some formalities, the backbone of most present at court, were Yang Jinzhu, Yang Xuelin, Chen Guangwu, Zhu Mingyong, Zhang Lei, Wang Xing. Then the young barrister give us some indication, first, the case is the case, the collegial panel can not listen to the Commission of politics and law, to be independent, don't put yourself to take into. He has been remitted to the dean Kang Weimin, and Secretary Zhou Qiang also made contact, Secretary Zhou Qiang will have instructions down; second, the police to testify in court, barristers have to let the police very nervous in court two strands; third, trembling, he built a blog for the Liu Moubai case, and prepare the hundreds of articles for for case, simultaneously published in the trial period, and preparation in the Hongkong book, if we found "guilty, will not look good. Fourthly, this case can't start in the eighteen period, otherwise he blog attention will reduce. Fifth, should organize the lawyer called before the court session; the six, the trial should be illegal evidence exclusion. Yang Xuelin lawyers are said to Li Zhuang case season second defenders, dress is very simple, the more impressive is to wear a pair of shoes, has been sitting on the sofa did not say many words, always a smile on his face, several short sentences rather Confucian temperament refined and cultured, from first to last, not mention to Li Zhuang defense the heroic style, formation and Yang Jinzhu counsel is a strong contrast.

I answer: first, the substantive processing we have independent thinking, won't listen to anyone. But the trial organization and coordination to listen to the Commission of politics and law, the court does not have the ability to organize such a big trial activities. Secondly, the collegial panel also wished the police would be in court, and as far as possible to do the work, when necessary, will report to the committee, please law committee leaders to do the work, but what can appear in court, depending on the police, the court has no power to force things; third, court lawyers write book without interference; the four, by the time of the session the court determined, according to the reading progress of course, will be as far as possible into the advice of counsel; fifthly, the Loudi court before the meeting has a long history, black and other large cases are before the court session, the lawyer did not mention will also open. The six row, a non, as long as the defendant or defendants application, the court will take this program. Obviously, Yang big lawyer on my reply is satisfactory, again said to a good cooperation with the collegiate bench, conflict and the court not to sign, the trial into a classic, typical case, makes the contribution for the rule of law in Hunan, winning glory for secretary Zhou Qiang. The good mood, cross language very joyous, Yang big lawyer still did not forget to invite me to his bag.

(six) the pre-trial

In early September, the collegial panel to pre-trial preparation work, one of the most important work is called before the court session, notify the court trial and make work scheme.

Pretrial conference and notify the court is relatively simple, we in the early September through short message platform to all the defenders have sent a pretrial conference information, and ask for confirmation, local lawyer most reply. But Yang big lawyer team but only a people reply. It seems there are big lawyer Chinese, natural and common law different attitude. No way, we have to call to confirm, in order to level match, I choose to call, but his tone as humble as possible. Big lawyers gave me great face, all return to sms.

The meeting was held as scheduled by the end of September, local law to a large, Yang Da lawyer team to two place, one is Yang lawyer himself, a lawyer Yang Xuelin. The collegial panel proposes ten questions for the lawyers are decided, even the toilet things into consideration, we quickly agreed, only a row of non lawyers ask questions about longer. I was thinking, in order to improve the efficiency of the trial, the illegal collection of evidence by the court the lawyer asked clues, try not to ask (if the lawyer insisted on asking questions, we would agree). But by the young barrister against. I propose, row non lawyers ask no law. Other lawyers proposed many solutions, including lawyers put forward written questions by asking questions and so on class, the court. Finally, Yang Xuelin lawyers, lawyers in court to ask, whether to allow the court ruling by the court, lawyers, respect the court's ruling. It seems necessary to adhere to or should be, if Yang Dalv hold, we will give, but he did not adhere to in the end. In addition Yang Da lawyers also raised a question, asked the prosecution organ to provide proof catalogue, convenient defender for evidence of, in order to improve the efficiency of the trial. The prosecutor, defender for the prosecution organ to provide evidence directory has no legal basis, but it does help to improve the efficiency of the trial, so with the intention to provide on the spot defenders, and gave Yang lawyer. Yang lawyer after reading, that the directory is not accurate enough, to provide proof, required directory must be accurate to every word the prosecutor read out in court, the prosecutor was firmly opposed, limited to functions, the collegial panel cannot award, had to let this issue is pending, let the time to solve. We see the notice of hearing is ripe, immediately to the scene of the defender service appearance notice, is scheduled for October 23rd, Yang big lawyer very generous, signed for all team defender to notice. Afterwards, the two lawyer Yang respectively in the blog praised the Shuangfeng court, and predict the trial did not make tribunal. By two lawyers light, led also praised the collegial panel.

The trial scheme formulated relative to the more hard, involving 10 departments and hundreds of people, and the deeds of independent lawyers, took the opportunity of table tables only, not press.

(seven) change the storm

To create a harmonious Wai for instance between the two parties, the collegial panel as far as possible into the lawyers request. In order not to affect the public attention to the lawyer, we set the session time trying to avoid the eighteen Congress, time message but left wait right etc is not the meeting statutory time limit, urgent, no, we have to according to the usual time before meeting to calculate, determined for the time trial in October 23rd. Clinker, the unexpected, the date from eighteen only half a month. According to the usual efficiency, half a month after the trial of cases is no problem, but the lawyers asked us to at least try for eighteen days, so the case is bound to the two trial, the trial organization difficulty is so great, who is not willing to do two times. At the same time, we must from the public security police deployed more than 100 in escort and security, according to the instructions of their superiors, public security to advance from the beginning in November 1st, security and stability, they give us seven days. In addition, we intend to transform for the custody room to live, I could not find the place, the transformation of progress is blocked. Therefore, we decided to postpone the trial. To change notification when, we expend setbacks quite, so many reasons why, how to summarize the brief words? Too simple, it is not clear, easy to mislead people. Too numerous, finite message capacity.Finally, I suggest, even our justices said the lawyers had, we might as well do a test, to be a relatively short messages sent out, to give them a test of how unscrupulous, everyone agreed. The content of the message I want to is "due to causes beyond the control of the collegiate bench trial," change "". In principle, big lawyer asked to review eighteen days, the collegial panel cannot control; alarm can not, can not control the detention room; unable to reform, can not control, the content of the message the no ground for blame, but sent out after, a lawyer responded immediately, grand online, insists the collegial panel has received the Commission of politics and law control, even the time of the session they can't decide, future decision must be the result of politics and Law Committee said Suan Yunyun. Leading after hearing the news, I hate not deep hatred for the enemy, so I went to apologize, but I was a better off without bending your knees, finally not to die.

The results of the test are out, but the price is too high.

(eight) the origin of the lawyers

The pretrial conference, it was found that the young barrister Liu Moubai case opened a blog, the blog the first article is without any treatment of the indictment, investigation materials is the case after hundreds of articles, up to now no Yang lawyer claims. I was very surprised when, should not have to their own evil world, more important is, and Liu Moubai bigamy charges the indictment, the fact and the two-year-old daughter's real name. Even if the judgment documents system network announced, will be hidden to the names of the parties, the privacy of the plot will be processing technology. Counsel is really a lawyer, style is out of the ordinary, dare anyone dare not to do.

The time of the session be postponed for some reason the original, because Yang counsel did not reply our message on the morning of October 12th, I call him, Yang Da lawyers agree, but questioned the reason that change, the collegial panel by the control commission of politics and law, so the collegial panel of independent case handling, not when the politics and Law Committee. I explained to him the reason for change, and ensure the future of the decision is entirely a collegial panel will. Then the two men started talking about, I asked: "are you a Chen Youxi debates with Qin Xiyan, a ruthless struggle, a criticism of Zhang Jun, not a minute to spare, where have time to read the file". Yang answered: "as we have such a big bar is no one marking." Oh, this guy is now developed, dare in front of me as a lawyer. I was half a mouth cannot close, asked: "how the examination opinions to defend you, word how to write ah." Yang Xiande is very easy: "cross examination opinions by the handwriting, it never write, speak directly in court." I'm about to extremely admire, Yang counsel it is God, such a case does not read the material would dare to defend a defendant.

Finally, Yang big lawyer asked the prosecution to provide proof outline more precise, I said this to do it, the court can't rule, he understands that, but did not give up their requirements.

As the saying goes, good in the first, this is true. The reasons for the change in the open court, after the court, lawyer Yang Da told me, he results through the leadership of the province to put pressure on Loudi. Oh, I really Speechless, since you decided to change period, why blame us? Tell yourself to judge.

(nine) vicissitudes

Eighteen, we also decided to trial on December 5th, in accordance with the pretrial conference agreement, we still through short message platform in to the lawyers send notice to appear, all as before, local lawyers are back to the message, reassuring. Big lawyers was a also did not return, and had a telephone, four of them smoothly through, not to mention. Hit Chen Guang Wu lawyers, lawyers said Chen Da received the message, the reply is not very willing, I catch a favour, please all please him back to a lawyer, Chen Da said: "you are a proof." I have no direct admit, just said is litigation need roll archive, was scolded: "nonsense, thanks to you or a lawyer, I'm not what evidence?" Rare Chen lawyer mercy, finally give us back the message. But to Zhang Lei counsel when, two mobile phone can't get through, is secretary service, and a few days would not call back, my heart Qiexi, do I really have the opportunity to take a fly around the Chinese? But soon, my dream in vain, Yang, Chen Da lawyers for make Nanchang, prepared to strike the court, no reason and evidence, hurriedly came to my office, asked to receive notice of appearance, the way to inform all lawyers are sign. There is a saying, impermanence, encounter things, lawyer also changed the usual reserved, put down your door, personally led the notice.

Ten a sudden change in the situation

Because I always take lawyers when God as for a communication section, and lawyers, despite some minor discomfort, overall it is passable, big lawyers have said this to make a model trial, not a tribunal. Who knows,Big lawyers work such as the Empress Dowager's face, says to change. On December 1st morning 10 when Xu (with a tribunal signs, I began to write simple notes, so time is accurate), lawyer Yang Da suddenly called me, give me the two orders, one must submit proof outline with the prosecution to them, two is must submit the defendant did not entrust his list to them, they have to specify the counsel for the defendant, the court or a good-looking, and to let the trial to the end of the chinese. I was about to explode, would not give him any explanation, replied angrily: "do you love what you do, you those tricks in front of me come on, those methods have not fresh, unable to attract the eye, to play something new, what right have you to the burden of proof the gang? What qualifications do you have to specify the counsel?"

At 5 pm, I called Liu Moubai another defender Guo Zhenfeng lawyer on the phone, the lawyers if they really want to make the court, so that the corresponding adjustment of the idea. Guo said Yang should be talk, not really a tribunal, and offered to do the work of yang. I don't need to do work, it's going to rain, mother will marry, go by him, but I'm a court will take than the brethren court more severe punitive measures.

Xu is a little angry also have a terrible place, on December 2nd at eleven thirty PM, Mr. Yang Da gave me a call, explain to me the two requirements of the reason, and again said no trouble tribunal, but let the public prosecutor good-looking, also allowed the stenographer to record requirements. I'm hanging heart finally put down, said it would consider the stenographer into the court record. But the good times don't last long, second days, Mr. Yang Da gave me a call, once again put forward the two requirements, if the court does not meet, there will be a tribunal, to let the trial was to February 8th (the day before the Spring Festival). Large cases, the number of participants up to hundreds of people every day, the cost of up to tens of thousands of dollars, time is the bane of lawyer in court, one point one quasi. The court may not be more big lawyer rich, a lawyer can charge during the first half of five million, as the grass-roots court we this valley, more than 100 people, to do every year five, six thousand case, annual fee is only about four million, much to waste one hundred thousand dollars is enough to cause no method in normal operation. Since the law a court decision has been made, I'm not intercede, two people give tit for tat on the phone. A ruthless, angry, I couldn't control my Shuang son was dumb.

The second day, people in charge of 10 units of politics and Law Committee Organization Participating in the hearing of the meeting, to understand the family trial preparation. I report the lawyers at the meeting will be a court case, and puts forward such as lawyers in violation of the rules of court, resolutely detention, never compromise, to make them a little bigger, I put forward two detention standards, one is take a table, two is not a court ruling, and the court fight, the court cannot, and said that if the leader doesn't agree with, I'll place. The presence of the Judicial Bureau and firmly opposed, think big lawyers are celebrities, their detention will make Shuangfeng become the hot spot, the scene is not good clean. The court's leadership serious criticism of me, that I am a little vice president, has no power to detain people. Although I have no opinion, to offend Leadership Conference, detailed arrangements for the trial work.

Eleven, the supreme instructions

Perhaps I should detain counsel's comments being proper go up, in the evening, politics and Law Committee leadership call me, want me to go to a hotel meeting, said that the province to the leadership, to the grand summoned me. I was frightened, during the day of the speech, can not help her two shares, have misgivings: not a bar, bar ability can be really big, even about all speak not detain.

Despite the guillotine the feeling, still must go to. Just have not seen what big leadership, do not know how to see the leader of the rules, do not know whether to kowtow, ha ha.

Came to the meeting, although the house filled with people, but a silence, conference table sat two people, a little fat, relatively young, another is thin, looked older, on the other side sat county politics and Law Committee leadership and County Municipal Judicial Bureau leadership. Introduced to me, young is the Provincial Department of tube lawyer, older is province lawyers association secretary general. The first is the director of the adult speech, said they had not come to intervention trial, but to help Loudi do a good job, and then ask me something about with the bar into the lives of. I thought, anyway, his head is cut, head is cut, simply pain come on, the bar into the lives and made a comprehensive report, even the detention law idea without reservation. Of adults four to interrupt my report, I vaguely remember, are my grand lawyers very performance, director of the adult me when, and then issued a great indication of their own, of course I can't interrupt of adult instructions, let him I report finished. Director of the instructions in adults:A large, national defense lawyers level top view, can not be questioned; two, barristers professionalism, like the reincarnation of Jiao Yulu; three, barrister at court are the responsibility of the court, the judge should respect the lawyer, detention is absolutely not; four, Zhang Lei lawyer science rich ten cars, a world this paper, is a lawyer of the writer, is a lawyer community pride, like Mo Yan did not dare to approach somebody's greatness; five, barrister landed in court, to the anti pattern of negation, negation position and role of commission of politics and law, they will no doubt is the rule of vanguard; six, barrister acoustic shock of the whole, be of noble character and high prestige, hard work, justice the administrative organs of the local to the honors, good reception.Instructions to the sixth time, the expression of Judicial Bureau leadership immediately, a lawyer by the Justice Bureau is responsible for the Chinese politics and Law Committee, at the same time request to solve the funds. Politics and Law Committee leadership although undaunted, or difficult points of the head. Heard here, I finally understand,Why make trial lawyers leader will be in Hunan.

Director of the adult instructions after, I will make the phenomenon of law court to submit to the secretary general opinion: lawyers are not necessary at court in any case, the court has a problem, legal provisions of the relief measures, the NAO tribunal shrew, lossy image of lawyers and court dignity; the court is the lawyer's biggest stage once lost, the lawyer, the image of the highest high, will lose the glory, that the Secretary General had agreed.

Dreamy out of the conference room, can't help but worry, not to say to uphold the party's leadership? Does the law department is the exception? A large trial committee cannot coordinate, what can they do? The necessary institutions still? The lawyer had a party to raise, why eat taxpayers? If the court can make, also have dignity? The court once lost dignity, the court's decision will have credibility? Even if the court were not letter, how to solve the China social contradictions, by how a department to solve it?

Then, these things not I consider small characters, monsters have a high one top.

(twelve), black sets terror

The account of "Shuangfeng" as in, the first day of the trial, the county town of Shuangfeng was shrouded in a fog, "escort vehicle carrying the thirty-six defendants into the court yard, each person is wearing aBlack jacket, a lot of, each have". A judicial common sense would know, give the man in a black cap for what. The TV people see most, was extradited from the foreign criminal suspects, head always wears black sleeve, the prisoner was escorted, transfer time, will wear a black hood. Black head effect is very simple, the main is to protect the defendant's privacy. The mortgage of the defendant, several kilometers away, to swagger hit City, in order to avoid the passers-by look, of course, to give them wearing hoods, not one less. Clinker, it was unfortunately Zhang Lei lawyer "surprised to see", not "be a veteran in battle, asked the lawyer Zhu Mingyong", "Zhu said the lawyer, he saw no elsewhere". Noon recess, a Dalv eagerly asked me, "why every defendant wore black suit? This seems to be inhumane ". My intuition is funny, had big lawyers do not understand, feel they can do it, thinking that they want to do is let them do, or "Shuangfeng" nothing to remember, so the answer is: "in order to prevent the collusion (auxiliary function headgear)". Zhu lawyer that he had never seen the accused wearing hoods, I can only say that he has never seen what is called normative escort!

Before the court, Yang Da's lawyer to see my face as I announced, the case to trial in February 8th of the second year, face quite satisfaction. I answer: "the time is too short, the Tokyo Trial three or four crimes trial for two years, the case for more than 20 charges, at least one year trial, you must be prepared to." Although I don't want to drag the time, but in the momentum must not be lost to him. And the gentleman gentleman, and rogue rogue wrapped around the world, this also.

"Shuangfeng" records, "the defendant was brought into the court, the gallery, suddenly there came a woman couldn't help cry". This is not false, big lawyer "XXX" have a routine, like some casual plot, linked to the case, making a snow in June's "remember" Wai, Shuangfeng is no exception. Unfortunately, just cry with big lawyer draw further apart after the women's desire. This woman is the wife of Liu Moubai, see Liu Moubai and bigamy object field so in pairs were brought into the court, so loud cry scold her cry, condemning Liu Moubai bigamy fact is the best proof. But the big lawyers don't understand the Xinhua dialect, then a "miscarriage of justice". Zhang Da lawyers "so and so", also is such, reader, understand?

Because only three people listed in the indictment of public prosecution, an increase of two prosecutors and two clerks in the trial, the court investigation began, Yang Jinzhu barrister in court has no legal basis, increase public prosecutor, in addition they also increased scrutiny of whether Shuangfeng's Procuratorate procurator. Other lawyers also proposed the clerk could not sit the public prosecutor's position. I know, let big lawyers when prosecutors "good-looking" to.

In order not to affect the progress of the trial, I put it to the public prosecutor for the specified procedures, in order to make a good big lawyers up, also say thanks for reminding words. But the lawyer he's really not letting this go, Zhu Mingyong lawyers insist that the prosecutor may increase.

Admittedly, the prosecution didn't specify procedures have flaws, personally think that, in theory, even if the above the prosecutor, should also do the specified procedures, but usually do the habit, but does not affect any right of the accused, no one to care about. When the four sets of solutions, one is that the public prosecutor has the specified procedures, then the prosecutor who is secretly, but defender has no right to review; two is the requirement of public prosecution procedure, the trial continued; the three is to make the book didn't sign the public prosecutor court, court trial was adjourned to four; the public prosecution organ, go through the formalities after the court. Just these four solutions, we very difficult choice, had to let both sides debate with each other, so as to give us the determination of time. Although the first set of scheme can reduce disputes, save time, but still I was quickly ruled out, deliberately misrepresent, gentleman not to have; third sets of plans will not mistake, but will make the embarrassment, the public prosecutor may not accept, also be excluded; fourth sets of plans will greatly delay time, this is I will not accept, therefore also excluded; only second sets of programs both the preservation of the public prosecutor's face, to advocate "good-looking" objective, so we decided to use second scheme, however, has been made after the lawyer, Zhu Mingyong firmly opposed, urged the new prosecutor retired, the lawyer Yang Xuelin the persuasion, Zhu counsel did not insist again. Because of this, I liked Yang Xuelin lawyer arise spontaneously, after the trial, he has failed to live up to my liking, whenever the other lawyer to "good" when, he showed no "good". I know, with his in law circles, he doesn't need a "good" to give prize, he is to defend, not to "good".

The next step is to read the indictment, must not have what wind waves. However, in today's society, there will be waves. The prosecutor read halfway, Yang big lawyer suddenly raised their hands to ask for the floor, I hurriedly asked prosecutors to stop reading. Yang lawyer puts it: "the request to release the defendant equipment". I reply:"According to the Supreme People's Court on the trial of criminal cases the use of public instruments of regulations, to ensure the safety and order, can not release equipment,And the case number, and murder, not release equipment". Yang pointed out: "Liu Moubai did not murder, Liu Moubai request release equipment". I reply: "the defendant number, should make no exception, not Liu Yibai alone release equipment, is also a fair.The court ruling to reject your request, to the court". Yang did not adhere to the. After the adjournment, Yang came to trial, still request releaseThe defendant's equipment. I suggested: "so much the defendant, if the equipment, run the person who is responsible? You are responsible for?" Yang Da: "that I am not responsible for". I said: "you are not responsible for anything. Why call me to bear the risk?" Silent, yang.

The indictment finally read over, Yang, Chen Da law and puts forward two problems, one is the legal punishment in the case of the case of injury to death for no period or the death penalty, a trial by court of jurisdiction; two is the supplementary prosecution indictment should be delivered to the defendant. I know, the court's "good" began. If the lawyers is true, the case must be adjourned for a longer period of time. Fortunately, we have a strict review, our program is not the problem. So I reply: "intentional injury death penalty starting point is ten years, not without period, the highest can be sentenced to death penalty, in this case the most important principal has been sentenced to fifteen years, the court review, other defendant shall not imprisonment, to appoint the court, such as after the trial shall be sentenced to not do above, can be transferred to. The other criminal law defense is the responsibility of the defendant mitigated, reduce, exempt from criminal liability advice, counsel Hierarchical Jurisdiction is actually increase the criminal punishment on the defendant, not in conformity with the law occupation ethics; the defendant Liu Mouchang is prosecuted, the hospital decided to combine the trial, instead of supplementary prosecution, criminal all the facts derived from the first indictment, not add to any crime, it is not necessary to other defendant or lawyer served a copy of the bill of prosecution". While the argument for several rounds, counsel did not finally let us too "".

The evening of politics and Law Committee and court leadership opened a short summary of each department, a day work problems, the deployment of second day's work. Leadership severely criticized me, don't think I'm good prosecutor's dignity, they think the public prosecutor has led the deputy attorney general, deputy chief procurators according to the authorization (unless major matters, the general work usually is granted rights, such as judicial detention, the law shall be decided by the court president, but are delegated to the vice president supervisor), have the right to assign prosecutors oral, shall not require the prosecution procedure. I'm too tired all day, rice didn't eat much, the toilets are not on time, do not want to argue with them, they go about it.

Thirteen rise to one's full height and smite the table

Yang lawyer blog show, big lawyers everywhere, will stand up for what is right, to the public prosecutor, law. I had let the wind, no matter how big character, dare to conclude in a Shuangfeng court, resolutely detained, this also alerted a director of adults, presumably large lawyers not to wind pee. Xu is the lawyer for beat addiction, the sudden change of habit, in the face of the typhoon also couldn't help then up urine.

The first day of the trial, counsel to appear in court is relatively homogeneous, but the discipline but let me drop eyes, speak it, close it, call it, and go out to the toilet, stroll, smokers have, let me the most unbearable is the lawyers to go out frequently, more than 30 defense people, was half a day to go out three or four times, defend seats with The stream never stops flowing. to describe is not an exaggeration, has seriously affected the trial. Therefore, the second day trial, I remind the defender tried to control the number of times out.

Then a day before the procedure, the public prosecutor interrogating the defendant Liu Moubai, interrogation to bigamy when lawyers, Yang Da and Guo lawyers, privacy relates to the defendant and the child's bigamy cases, not a public hearing. Feel comedy Yang counsel things really will not be inferior to the uncle, Liu Moubai's bigamy fact that you're not already has been released to the whole world? Now also talk about what privacy. And the people a lot of money, so the grand meeting before trial should also put forward. More importantly, the basic conditions of bigamy constitutes the parties, is disclosed in the name of husband and wife living together, their own already in pairs, swagger through the streets, and what not public? Panel, we solemnly replied: "bigamy cases is not related to the sex party's description, not related to human dignity, the defendant's privacy, can be heard in public. In order to ensure the growth of Juveniles Education is not affected, please ask when you try not to involve minor situation".

Courts and prosecutors questioned the first defendant Liu Moubai, by Yang big lawyers for the accused to ask questions, the lawyer said Yang Da to stand back and ask questions, according to his theory, Chinese lawyer must have the courage to stand up. In fact, I was more liberal in this regard, I can accept the prosecutors and defenders in his speech a rant, side walk, I thought to myself: "you want to stand on the station now, baby, I hope you are really stand up, not just the body". So the ruling shall be permitted.

Yang lawyer stood up when some self-conscious, and later to the defendant made several asked, "but the investigation conclusion report" published opinion. Why? Now ask stage, evidence stage has not come, even if the evidence, "the investigation conclusion report" is not evidence, the debate is far. Big lawyers say in accordance with the law, this is in accordance with the law? In spite of the trial procedure is the so-called "stand up"?

Because want to have a look "stand up" lawyers to be what kind, therefore has not stopped speaking, Xu's lawyer Yang Da feel good, so more said more vigorously, I will dance with joy, the emotion, he unexpectedly beat heavily at the defense table, drawing the audience attention, in perfect silence. I immediately to stop, and severely criticized, but Yang big lawyer didn't admit that took a table. At this time, Zhang Lei lawyer hands requirements statement, published Greatest Story Ever Told statement, Yang said the law is not on the table, but body language. My intuition funny: where barristers often stand up the courage to go? The fashion should not be encouraged., I must resolve and they care about clear, then answer: "did not take a table, our camera records, put to them to you now? In a Shuangfeng court to never allow such body language". Yang lawyer said after the age of 65 will "to the walls of reading", this time should be the time has not come, be afraid of my gun, so the court immediately apologize.

Level as Yang lawyer ask the director of the adults said, stand without peer in one's generation, for example:"You as the only organization and leadership, an active participant in your inner, how many you never knew and relatives?" So the public prosecutor against. I ruled: "set against it, the defenders set the accused have the people they don't know, please pay attention to the way of question". Yang lawyer immediately agreed to correct.

I can't help some like young lawyer here, although sometimes don't play by the rules, is fairly straightforward, not play, and my character is somewhat similar.

After the adjournment, Zhang Lei lawyer came to trial, published his great theory, say lawyers have the right in court on the table, I replied: "in my courtroom is not allowed". Said to himself: "other places I don't tube, the courts have a try."

Yang lawyer came to trial, the collegial panel to smoke, each one is two, we are happy to enjoy. Since then, the conflict where the court and counsel, after the adjournment Yang lawyer will smoke to us, and we talked for a while.

At night, the Committee and the organization of the meeting, to sum up experience, job placement (every night this will during the trial,). Leadership seriously surface Yang my meal, call me master powerful trial lawyers in court, even big apology, as the shift of Pingxingguan.

The trial was only two days, perhaps the years not bountiful person, I began to appear vertigo, tinnitus, fatigue, sore throat and other symptoms, the road is still very long, feel more and more pressure, I do not know can stick to the end, so the content of the conference I didn't listen to, nor how seriously think, my goal is to do their own thing.

(fourteen) simply can not afford

The trial into the third day, also entered the big lawyers show significant day.

Announced after the hearing, then the first day schedule, by Yang lawyer continue to question the first defendant lawyer, can not directly ask, first made a chase with questions unrelated words. Speaking of Xinhua Public Security Bureau police officers in the audit, participate in the criminal police escort, the gallery is empty and so on.

What about audit, lawyer Yang Da in front of the court gave the collegial panel under the instruction, requires unlimited audit, and asked the court mounted displays, live the trial content. I reply: "I even agree on TV, but this case is no TV station to broadcast. Our hospital was moved to new site, installed monitor is waste, where financial resources are limited, and no one will agree. No restriction on is impossible, only a total of more than one hundred seats in the galleries, to many people, caused by trampling who is responsible?" Yang no longer stick. Then according to the provisions of the Supreme Court issued by hearing, according to Yang statue barrister instructions, each of the defendants have made two relatives by hearing, a total of seventy-two, in addition to the Yang great lawyers special hair four tickets, the other the far end, not empty seat. Two days before the public gallery packed, this day many of the relatives of the accused did not come, resulting in some empty seats. So shit buckle to the court on the head.

Before the hearing, Xinhua County Public Security Bureau contact us, asked to send officers to observe, to raise the level of business. A lawyer involved in the trial, is a learning opportunity, I have to admire the police leadership vision, so that they were. Just don't know, public security officers to attend the trial, which is a violation of law!

Police in the matter, since there are a drama, and listen to the later decomposition.

Yang lawyer finally going to ask a question, he first proposed to the illegal evidence question, I am not permitted, the reason is pretrial meeting has been agreed, all ask after the completion of non uniform row, Yang agreed, but asked for other procedural question. I've read Yang lawyer blog, know that the so-called procedural problem is captured from the defendant to play all the process before the trial, including where to catch, when caught, there are several police, police wear uniforms, what did not speak, call the police, not the the toilet is not, car added oil no, tell the police what in the car and so on, without question, a defendant can say a few days, the purpose is to let the case until February 8th. I do not agree, the reason is not the effect of these procedures on the conviction and sentencing of cases, if the defender believes the case handling organ problems, can complain to the relevant departments, no need special questions in court. But the young barrister insisted on asking questions, I answered: "I hope the lawyer can respect the court's ruling, if as a legal person don't respect the court's ruling, how to let other people respect? If you think our decision is wrong, can solve through the procedure of second instance". But the young barrister he's really not letting this go, still insisted on asking questions. At this time, Zhu Mingyong lawyers said: "there is no legal effect in the pretrial conference agreement, the lawyer may apply for start of illegal evidence exclusion procedure at any time."

I know, if you do not agree with Yang counsel called procedural question, case is not on trial. A nameless fire burning in my heart, my self-control to the limit, immediately put down the face, voice a lot: "pretrial conference agreement can not obey, then before the court session and what meaning? A businessman knows to keep its promise, lawyers don't even businessmen are not? Where did you go to the occupation morals? Do you accept the case for so long, for a defendant to understand clearly, what are you doing before, some be of no great importance question why in court? Please clerk record, lawyers said the court before the meeting agreed not to follow". Voice did not fall, the court would scamper opened boiler, Chen Guangwu pats the table, but did not stand up, Yang Jinzhu, Zhu Mingyong, Zhang Lei, Wang Xing shouted, side to raise a hand and called, and stood up, only Yang Xuelin and local law did not move.

The court has become a see Niu Ping, Chen Guangwu has touched my bottom line, no matter later arrested not detained, I decided to insult him, and cried: "who is that on the table? Call what name? Who advocate?"

The lawyer old qualifications all know, eighty or ninety in the Supreme Court and the Justice Department document, the judges not in court interrogation, lawyer's name and other basic information, all to the entrustment shall prevail. I met Chen Guangwu, also saw his website, the court asked his name, than the defendant tone more severely, because he is trampling on the dignity of the court. Apparently Chen Guangwu after fierce ideological struggle, not for a long time silent, finally answered in a low voice: "my name is Chen Guang Wu, Liu Jing advocate a". Fancy, known as the "right for barristers, at this time will give up the statutory power to their own.

Before the trial, I have a plan, during the trial, or an all Huairou, no criticism, no warning, no training instrument, not expelled, not detained a lawyer. Either resolutely strong, up to a certain extent, starting directly from the detention. From the brethren court experience, criticism, warning, training mechanical and expulsion effect is not good at all. For a start, I decided to take Huairou policy, therefore, in the trial, although I criticism and warning some defenders, but never use "criticism" and "warning" these two words.

Chen Guangwu's behavior should be enough detention, but leadership without authorization, they don't necessarily agree with. But I should say or want to say, and said: "here is the solemn court, your face is the people's Republic of China, with two of the most sacred places in the world, a church, a court, Church of the holy is because of the belief, the court sacred because law provisions, you look up, the national emblem is red, our national flag is red, why is the national emblem and the flag of red? Because of too much through our country in the fight for independence, liberation and freedom on the road of blood, I think of Qiu Jin, remembered Cai Hesen, think of her, this one will have their blood, because their blood we have this court. As a legal person, does not have the authority to trample on the dignity of the court, hope you abide by the rules of the court, to respect the court ruling, I am a little judge, you do not need to respect, but this is the case in court, is part of the ruling of the court, should also be respected." When I finished, the big lawyers to front court and brought a lot of problems, in order to is very good, I'm one one debate, and they were a little lecturefield Oh, sense, however, there is a "Confucian"?

Leadership under audit, see trial in this way, anxious straight stomp, the bailiff to give two note to me, the first one is to I hastened to apologize, don't talk reason, second is to get an adjournment, I did not understand. The debate until two party to speak almost, Yang Xuelin suggested an adjournment, I decided to adjourn, recess, I declare, on whether Chen Guangwu detained, the collegiate panel after the decision.

After the adjournment, the leaders held a lot of me, that I should not criticize big lawyer, think big lawyer not easily character, not our kind of people can criticize, and asked me to teach a confession of lawyers, asked the lawyer to forgive. The Justice Department leadership that I said in court that too much, those words were dirt. I said, beheaded is possible, confession is not to. Leadership said angrily, you have to think clearly, if not guilty, the case does not go, to me. The collegial panel has an honest elder, said the judge but to turn to, or he pleaded guilty to recognize tacitly, leadership.

So, please Judicial Bureau to invite Yang Jinzhu and Chen Wu lawyer office negotiations. For whatever reason, big lawyers had come. Sit not steady, Chen Wu lawyers to collegiate apology, said he is old, heart bypass operation, easily excited, do a sorry court, asking the court to forgive, and one by one, and the collegial panel staff cordially shook hands. At this point, my gas is of course completely disappear. Should say, we have no need to lawyers to plead guilty, but, the honest elder is very cute, the execution of the instructions of the leadership to do not discount, even to the lawyer apologize, big lawyers to be very humble, that do not need to apologize, all of a sudden become gas dissolve it up. So please barrister asked, Yang lawyer said, procedural problems would not ask a question, they will ask the illegal evidence. Requires no more than we planned, only non program in advance, we agreed. The next trial lawyer exceptionally smooth, without wasting a minute of time.

After a local lawyer friend told me, in our meeting time, lawyer Yang Xuelin severely criticized the Chen Guangwu a meal, said he scores of years old, still do that special thing, for others to their own defense, go not worth.

At night, Zhang Lei lawyer for "Shuangfeng" Fenmo issued, put some scene upside down, put some words break off both ends, then, a blind and idiotic judge appeared, a group of fearless of death for a just cause big lawyer also appeared to stroke the table, can not afford a lawyer did not mention Chen Guang wu.

"Shuangfeng" is a significant contribution, is to me the criticizing them as I comment, and said the judge wouldn't comment power, there is a name for the lawyer, also want to take counsel light fame, wrote a masterpiece, known only in court to express feelings of this point, the presiding judge shall be avoided. Ha ha, want to be famous like crazy, what dare write articles. From the big lawyer and Kim Dae lawyers can be seen in the works, their knowledge is very knowledgeable, they actually know I mentioned at the court of Qiu Jin, Cai Hesen, Xiang Jingyu Shuangfeng celebrity. But unfortunately, I did not want to Shuangfeng famous, but that they are of revolutionary martyrs, they for the new China every drop of blood, only barristers make court, counsel at court, at least for the martyrs of the disrespect!

Zhang Lei lawyers have an indelible contribution, enough to go down in history, is found I say two words. Lawyers see the defendant called "meet", the judge accused person is called "questioned", I did the lawyer, is to know the difference, but the day old and confused, actually the lawyers see the defendant said "questioned". Zhang Da lawyers not to lose is the University asked the home, in the large specially written out, and a grand a note. I found that very night fasting, bathing, burn incense and pray, pray God to forgive. The second day trial, apologize to the audience immediately, rare big lawyer have mercy, to an apology after solemn written "Shuangfeng Ji", I have peace of mind.

(fifteen) the court "interpol"

The criminal trial by the judicial police escorted the defendant, as is the usual practice, however, the case of 36 defendants, according to the provisions of the two police crime, the staff at least 72 people. However, the school only 10 officers, add up to the Loudi court system has no 72 marshals, then, applied by our institute, politics and Law Committee decided to participate in the public security police escort from. It should be said, this arrangement is not what can be blamed, clinker, it has violated laws, Yang big lawyer first declared loudly in the court, there are 5.12 project group police escort team, is an illegal act. Xu is the inspection found no project team members, so in the online announced criminal police escort team, and solemnly declare, the court will not allow the criminal police, also known as the view has been confirmed by judicial department leadership support. A few days later built momentum, Yang big lawyer finally officially to the court: criminal police can not participate in the criminal trial of the escort. Oh, look up Chinese law, no classification of criminal police, the street is seen marked "police" the words of the vehicle. Counsel to create new styles, in court for vehicle identification points from the police categories. So we ruled: according to the regulations of the people's police law, the classification Chinese is the police, the state security organs, prisons, reeducation through labor, the judicial police, no criminal police, criminal police of public security is relatively temporary internal division of labor, can at any time adjust. Property law gives the bailiffs and police work is the same, encountered significant matters can cooperate. Because the accused the large number of people, my courtyard, even the bailiff police are not enough, so from the public security police escort and security to participate in, is in accordance with the law. The defender's opinion, our hospital shall not be accepted.

The collegial panel to hear the case, major issues to the full court after a collegiate decision, procedural problems simply by the presiding judge directly order, this is a fool all know the truth. Before the court, we review and forecast, put forward more than 50 of the pre, the uncertain problem to a higher court was asked, and then formed a written plan. As we carefully studied the lawyers of the blog, so the lawyers in the trial of the proposed problems, only the individual problem is not in our scheme. Therefore, I made in the court ruled that, on the surface is a personal decision, actually after the. Zhu Mingyong lawyer blazing with anger, that grabbed my small plait, open to my trained armed, said no see collegiate collegiate I ruled, that I be a law onto oneself, hope the court not as a mere formality. Ha ha, barrister is big lawyer, is really have a well-deserved reputation, the view always walk in the forefront of the National People's. It seems that I have to learn from Yang counsel learning, seven Standing Committee and President Zhou Qiang writes to boring of time, urged to amend the current legal provisions, the collegial panel the case when must be in Tiananmen square, but also must invite lawyers to participate in, otherwise the referee is invalid. No way, I had to make a solemn promise to Zhu lawyer, I announced that the collegiate bench must on the future, not as a mere formality. Therefore, the later trial, some problems barrister, despite some resolutions, we did a look to Zhu lawyer, major problems still pretend adjournment, just because of the limitations of law, did not invite Zhu counsel in. Why? With hindsight, not the law? The law firm is not also have a major case study system? The lawyer to study the case how don't let the judges saw?

Zhu lawyer training equipment for me, naturally into Zhang Lei s masterpiece "Shuangfeng lawyer", then, an ignorant and goddam trial long going online, so I was almost a powder slobber.

(sixteen) torture to extract confessions

Then a dog bites a man not news, a man bites a dog that is a news, the trial of this case, we understand this is a truth. The criminals killed police is not news, police moved the criminal root hairs, absolutely is big news, lawyers are a deep dark this truth. So, in what lawyers defense cases, there will be torture to extract confessions, I most admire big lawyers place, their dyeing ability of torture to extract confessions noisy. Torture to extract confessions this topic is too big, I don't want to say what, only about one or two things, you may be able to see what.

Zhu Mingyong lawyers are the second defendant Liu Moubin's lawyer, in the interrogation Liu Moubin Hou, the defendant claimed that the police handcuffed played on the tiger bench covered all over with cuts and bruises, be, several times to bite tongue to commit suicide, severity of the case without right of its people, attracted the gallery's family a cry. The defendant and Zhu lawyer court for exclusion of illegal evidence, at the same time application identification. However, when we delegate identification time, shocking scene took place, the claim that the defendant is the worst torture to extract confessions, had written to withdraw the application. When we questioned Liu Moubin, asked him what tiger stool, he replied that he was sitting in his chair is the. We are surprised to find, this chair is the interrogation chair type, and Jiang's sitting tiger stool is completely different. History has a strikingly similar scene, barristers in the River Court insisted that tiger stool, the interrogation chair is not standard? The information is well-informed, separated by thousands of miles of tiger bench information could break through the wall, all of a sudden to Shuangfeng.

The trial, the defendant Liu Mouping on the right side of the head with a place where there is no hair, a round, as if out of the park planning, the defendant insisted that public security personnel dozen, big lawyers also cling to one's view is the public security. I was secretly admire, the eldest brother really have the ability, beatings are playing such a level, and park planning out of the same. Rows of non proof, prosecutors cited the defendant was captured photos, photo shows the defendant before being caught here have no hair, prosecutors said, the police is afraid of someone plant, I took this photo. On this evidence, the defendant still claims that police beat, bar is not known exactly the police to fight, but was renamed the police beating aggravate alopecia, and questioned why don't give any other defendant photos. I suddenly think, will head hit was not born, the head will have?

Interrogate the defendant Liu Jing some time, I found on the right side of the judges to support the head by hand, so remind him sitting posture, maintain the image, he says he is not better than the heart, it is difficult to support. I want him to overcome it, and then continue to preside over the trial. A few minutes later, found his reclining chair side, head bent, attitude is indecent, and began to push him, pushed a few times did not respond, I feel great, and announce an adjournment, inform the duty doctor gave him a check, inspection results frightened me, high blood pressure is only sixty or seventy. Have to shock, critical point. Some prosecutors and lawyers swarmed to propose solutions, many people face showing sympathy and anxious expression, and makes me very touched, decided to send to the hospital for treatment, twenty minutes later, the news from the hospital, said the judge in serious condition, need hospital treatment. The morning was adjourned. With both parties negotiate and inform the superior court, inform the defendant, decided to replace the personnel hearing.

I know, we judge is too tired, we hardships and pain no one can understand that, big lawyers would even want to all dare not to think. "Shuangfeng" after the introduction, barristers fans should cling to one's view, we judge was torture to extract confessions scared disease. Archaism cloud: "like father, like son". My chest without ink, to paraphrase: "the celebrity, must have its fans", do not know but not.

(seventeen) A single word of gold. and free lunch

The trial after four days, the progress has been slower than we expected, a lot of time to waste in some unnecessary disputes, sometimes to the meaning of a word, half an hour lawyer will argue with me, a court ruling is no effect, counsel only obey their will, local lawyers have looking for my complaint, saying they charge only a few thousand dollars, if the too long, even the accommodation meals are not enough. I reply: "cases, long big lawyers say, they announced that the trial is to February 8th, as you can see, the trial is by counsel command." Hear my answer, the lawyers face full of anger. Then, later in the day of the trial, a city's identity of local lawyers: she represents all the local lawyers, resolutely follow the court's command, to obey the court's ruling, a court will not support any form of.

Interrogation to the defendant Yuan Moubin Hou, Yang Da lawyers, he wants to ask Yuan Moubin row non clues, the public prosecutor against, reason is according to the two grade discharge non regulations, only the defendant and his defense personnel have the right to provide non clues, other defendants defenders didn't have this right. The court ruled that the prosecution against the panel established. But lawyers he's really not letting this go, take turns speaking, Zhang Lei and Wang Xingda law is a long and minute statement to the court ruling, change. I had to put the irregular fifth read out in court, and explain "the defendant and his counsel," refers to the defendant's counsel, but not the accused person I advocate outside counsel. However, big lawyers are still not convinced, adhere to refer to all the defense of the accused person. I was very angry, advised them to look up in the dictionary, or "Baidu". Although the "Baidu" results will have a variety of answers, believe that sit in the defense table, completely has the ability to judge which one is the correct answer. Really big woods, what are birds, big lawyer should buy the dictionary suggest at disregarding, insists that his explanation is a truth, "Baidu" than to authority.

Home to ask to read primary school's nephew, nephew not hesitate to reply, I am right, ha ha, I got award him a piece of money, still feeling pain, because is not worth the problem a piece of money. Therefore, suggested that Zhang Lei and Wang Xingda law, put down your, ask the students, don't spoil your teacher name, teacher taught you when, I definitely that understanding. In order to "and" these two words, three parties takes about half an hour, I lost a piece of money, we have lost two thousand dollars, we review a day costs is 20000 yuan, the more than 7 hours each day, each hour spent about four thousand yuan, is each word one thousand yuan, "A single word of gold." to find the most appropriate interpretation here.

Sage cloud: "there is no free lunch". However, the sage makes mistakes when, Shuangfeng has a free lunch, not only lawyers, the defendant also. As director of the adult's instructions, the judicial administrative organ provides free lunch for lawyers, but the lawyers don't buy it, not only waste every day the people of Loudi silver, while eating Loudi people's hard-earned, while in court at the Loudi police be utterly devoid of conscience, Xu is found independent of the police and case investigation escort the second day, swear, Yang Da lawyers in court to the police to apologize, to lambaste case group policeman.

The defendant to eat our hospital to provide free lunch worth mentioning, worthy of great praise Pinter is Yang counsel for the defendant to provide free lawyer. Before and after trial, Yang counsel repeatedly claimed to offer a free lawyer, a defendant's counsel did not entrust the trial, and in the blog advertising, soliciting free defense volunteers. To have individual lawyer gave Yang lawyer face, came all the way, came to Shuangfeng. Local lawyers see "lawyer" and the defendant family on the sidewalk for a supply of sth. the wonderful scene, attorney fees to be free, but the cost of transportation, accommodation charge family pocket, it scared the shit out of you, as long as thirty thousand yuan, equivalent to one year of wages, and Yang counsel to Li Qinghong two million travel "free defense" have different approaches but equally satisfactory results and wonderful, and family members to give up. You know, a local lawyer is not free, there are a lot of people in charge only a few thousand dollars. Boring Jiangxi Ji'an "lawyer" (because of the reason as everyone knows, I am not for its fame), had to find Yang big lawyer to a side hearing, learn big lawyers "Sike" ability, also not forget the photos to the court with a mobile phone, send micro-blog, and in micro-blog under the ruling, finds that the case is age-old grievances Qi, ha ha, another want crazy. The value of court bailiff is not smart, actually the counsel for the fans to the office, seized a mobile phone. Leadership decided to detain, anxious Yang counsel in the court playing straight ring, in desperation to find me, please I beg for the "lawyer". For more than 20 years of friendship, but also for post trial favorable consideration, I never speak up, had to pull down the face to intercede, thought leadership could give me face, agreed to a fine, mobile phone attachment to the end. Yang big lawyers are still not satisfied, I say good words, request is not fine, mobile phone as soon as possible, because the "lawyer" no business, with limited funds, should not stay long. It is also a back, knees kneeling, knees two times is kneeling. Then again, for, although I didn't give leadership what face, leading to is give me face, agreed to my request, write a review leave.

(eighteen) typos and dangerous heinous members

The first day of trial, Yang Jinzhu is in the hundreds of thousands of words in the indictment found typos, seem to have hit the jackpot, and stresses how important, how serious the indictment, is absolutely can not go wrong, the public prosecutor innocent face, that is not good for release. Since there is no way for the court "good-looking", also did not go to the tube. A few days later, Zhu Mingyong's lawyer had also found typos, so serious criticism of the public prosecutor irresponsible, occupation morality and sense of responsibility has serious problems, it is committed the unforgivable crime. After all the wrong in their own, prosecutors did not dare to struggle. Xu is the defender found the wrong words still worse than the missile lethality, trial questions towards the end of the time, the local has a lawyer also found typos, so learn bar shape, speak in excitement emotion. Never do with me what, but for a few typos, wasted too much of our time and money, so stop said: "defend typos things said too much, hundreds of thousands of words of no typos? Even during the cultural revolution of "Mao" all errors and omissions, such a long trial, you promise not to tell a lie? Can guarantee no plea a typo? I'm not sure I don't say a word, also can't guarantee our judgment. In a word, hope the defenders don't sweat the details." Yang lawyer warned me: "please judge with the word 'entangled'." I'm afraid to draw fire against oneself, immediately didn't dare make a sound. Since then, big law no longer wrong character, often require the public prosecutor and the court.

From eighty time since the crackdown, in "steady, accurate, very" fight against crime, under the guidance of thinking, China judiciary has always been a controversial approach, namely, early intervention, the public security and procuratorial early intervention for investigation of the case, the advance in the investigation of public security cases, the court early intervention the prosecution case aim in order to shorten the cycle, handling, prevent the case of overdue. I don't have the ability to evaluate the merits of this approach, only the great theory to counsel the interested, so released, readers.

This is also the case in early intervention in the process of investigating the phenomenon, Discipline Inspection Commission Liu Moubai corruption, embezzlement, found there was a lot of public security under the jurisdiction of the criminal facts, so the early intervention. Barristers found, baby to death, therefore lashed out at. However, they attack is not this case of legitimacy and rationality, but cling to one's view this case to do out of the case must be the case, and concluded that, since then, the ninety million Party members are in danger, everyone is discipline inspection commission and the public security's next target. Even a fool knows, the way and the case is not necessarily linked, Chinese "early intervention" for thirty years, and not how many grievance. Counsel of the heart, people do not know, listen to a few times, finally understand, counsel for the target is not entirely the case, but in the ninety million Party, they should let ninety million Party angry public security organs and the Commission for Discipline inspection. In laws' as this kind of situation, never stop at this. If they find out which court detained a lawyer, immediately announced, the 200000 lawyers will be the next target, and then call the lawyer gathered around the court, in order to make the court put people; if found where a misjudged case, will be announced in the first time, the people all over the country are in dire straits, all people will be wronged. Then, the lawyers to the court when the enemy, the people of the whole country hates not smash the public, prosecutors, law.

According to legal rule, every year hundreds of thousands of criminal cases, a few cases is the most natural thing. Five thousand years of Chinese civilization, which once not wrong? More than 200 made the earth, and what a country not the case? Even big lawyers to thousands of Uncle Sam, also came from the beauty of the smell of miscarriage of justice. It seems to want to resolutely put an end to the wrong, only let the lawyers to the judge.

After the "Shuangfeng seven". Later, finally understand the lawyers intention, Gu cited its ending for this section of the conclusion:"If there really is a God, it is the Almighty God, then, I beg you, save it, or, if you have not saved, it simply to destroy it."

(nineteen) declined to decide the presiding judge

The court shall not refuse to judge, this is All the world knows. truth, however, this idiotic judge is actually rejected once, big lawyers should not make a fuss, but I expected.

To December 12th, court interrogation finally difficult to end, pretrial conference agreement, the next action is non. Because the row non program is a new thing, rarely in the trial practice, I was a big girl chair - head back, "row" provisions of irregular and more general, operability is not strong. In order to avoid the big dispute appear on the court, I find the lawyers in the recess, hope to get big lawyers some instructions, we can follow the instructions. Barristers were given us the eight instructions, some simple, some difficult. For some simple instructions, I was able to stand, are known to obey, to study after the decision on complex problems, hope big lawyer can obey our decision, big lawyers agree. The results of the study, we perform a lawyer seven instructions, decided to decree did not fight on the examination of the question.

Since the first defendant did not ask row non clues, not directly into the row non, at the same time, we also want to gradually accumulate experience, so the decision from easy to difficult, and from the back row, discretion category we the decision belongs to the collegiate bench, does not violate any legal provisions. However, after the hearing, found that many lawyers did not appear, is unable to safeguard the rights of defendants. So, we decided to lawyers in the court of first row, and the emergency notice did not appear lawyer. It should be said, our treatment is comprehensive, not bothering anyone, but not on the lawyers of the tail, so the correct and hold it, bashing, that the court did not according to the usual practice in the front row, causing some lawyers can not appear in court testimony. You idiot knows, only in the trial to master all of the case, can be defended the views of high quality, on time to perform their duties is a legal obligation of lawyers, lawyers without leave doesn't appear for both the contract law. Barristers how clever, actually the lawyer illegal shit buckle to the head. Barristers theory is, if the lawyer in a certain period of no defense task, can not appear in court. My idiotic, can not help but ask, our judges sometimes not all day to say a word, also can not appear in court?

The public prosecutor of the first defendant's illegal evidence proof after the clue, the defender made examination opinions, we are prepared to the next row of non time, big lawyers for a cross examination opinion, the reason is this case is a joint crime, to a defendant's row non affect other people convicted, I according to the predetermined scheme we decided not to pre approved. But the lawyers disagree, must I change my order, secondary second in court the gas, said: "the public prosecutor of the evidence is against a defendant, the defendant has published evidence, the law does not require the other defendants have the right of cross examination, if the other defense people adhere to the published evidence, is a negative defense confrontation ability on the defendant himself, but also for lawyers do not respect,Other defenders, if there are different views on the evidence, can be in the debate on the legality of the evidence put forward opinions. At the same time,According to the provisions of the criminal law interpretation and the lawyers law, a lawyer can not serve as defenders for CO two above to the defendant.I can't guarantee that all our decisions are correct, but the ruling was made, everyone should respect". Zhu Mingyong lawyer asked: "you have no legal basis?" I had no thought of answer: "of course". So start looking for the law, I can't find too quickly, otherwise, Zhang Lei lawyers said on the blog I act with confusion, as he described Beihai as judge. But if it is too slow, the defendant and other people will think I am not familiar with the law, I cannot find the time of the critical point, then find the said: "I is old, eyes a little flower, may slow down". Alas, it's really hard. Find the interpretation of criminal procedure law article thirty-fifth read, Yang barrister, other defenders may not cross examination, but to ensure that the rights of confrontation the first defense of the accused person, and that the case is so. Although the lawyer give in, I still did not agree with the. Speaking from the heart, the two defense confrontation, also do not have what relation, but to my character, since it has been the top, will be the top to bottom. Lawyer must never compromise, so I put an adjournment, decided by the judicial committee, barrister is if we stop, as long as the trial court is interrupted, "attractive", the trial in February 8th to increase the possibility, they won, so all the counsel agree.

We're not out of court, Yang big lawyer just behind me dance with joy, make a hullabaloo about, said the judge how not to know, how does not keep promise, first day promised their testimony second days to change. I ignored him, went straight.

Via defend seats when, hear the local lawyer said: "today the presiding judge injured." In fact, the presiding judge not injured, the injured is court. Since there is a family lawyer, the court no longer sacred, no solemn, the court does not respect. I thought to myself, for oral order, they always asked the court to change, the written decision of our future, they are not satisfied with the time, whether directly returned for we did?

Leadership is not seen Zhang Lei lawyer description about Beihai judge act with confusion, criticism, I find the law is too slow, should not and counsel argue for so long, should not be proposed by the judicial committee decides (personnel, short-term difficult to call), especially about yourself you could be in big trouble (when the media is speculation "dazed judge"), the court may result in the damage on the image. I was angry, listen to the words of leadership more angry, said: "I will not cause, find someone better". So another leading to do a good job, I had promised to continue. The final decision, not the trial committee, the collegial panel review, put the other two judges, not promised counsel's request, the case is not down, let Yang big lawyer cross examination. I don't agree, puts it: "the court has already become a see Niu Ping, since a group of not polite bison, let them eat enough, support him to death! Each counsel cross examination, the efficiency of the trial will no longer pursue". We all agree.

The court announced the decision of reconsideration, lawyers were greatly surprised, all without exception shows surprised expression. After the lawyer quipped: "if you're not in the cultural revolution, left is right, not revolution is counter revolutionary", I smiled and accepted.

Lead me on to another criticism, that I ask to Zhu Mingyong lawyers understand wrong, said Zhu counsel is intended to ask the legal basis I forbid their testimony, instead of a lawyer is not co two accused the basis. I without thinking for a leadership, immediately put down the face, said I don't mind. So from head to foot and scold again. I am very clear, on the criminal trial level, in Shuangfeng in Loudi is the lowest, at the bottom, criticized the leadership should be justified, so no longer say what. On a second thought, in that context, Zhu counsel questions have two kinds of understanding, because of his questions not targeted, more because there is only one problem with clear legal provisions, so I choose one kind of understanding made reply. The leadership of the criticism is right, after all A bystander is always clear-minded. We would like to solemnly apologize Zhu lawyer, because I learned not refined, wrong will honour meaning, future oriented law learning, as far as possible ambiguous reply. The dull, if you only one answer, please express the sense of.

Zhang Lei's lawyer has a famous saying: "no need to wait until the autumn." This is not wrong, complex court soon, the defenders and the people who read the evidence problems arise, contend for several rounds of no results, Yang Da lawyers asked the court ruling. I reply:"No court ruling, the court ruled that because no one followed, both sides continue to debate." After several rounds of debate, until both have nothing to say. I clench teeth: "originally the court shall not refuse to award, I just want to let you see, not a court ruling is what consequences." Guo lawyers answer: "see, the consequences will be grievous."

From this day, Zhang Lei lawyer to other courts go, make a little extra money, did not appear in court, "Shuangfeng" by Wang Xingda lawyer to write, lawyer Wang Xingda is very modest, the big lawyer to Cao Xueqin, but said he not high. Xu is relatively young king lawyer, the defendant is not clean money is not enough, the heart is not completely black, relative ratio of big lawyer should be fair to me, "vertigo" remarks also did not do what the article, no write destroy the country like the spell. Think of the heart or some event, if big lawyer surgeon, guess I was Chinese second "dazed judge".

(twenty) do not want to appear

In the "free world", the police to testify in court have been commonplace, the barristers envy. At home, the police court is not what fresh thing, not what the big deal. Before the court, Yang Da's lawyer has mentioned to me, this case must have the police to court, he let the police be thrown into a panic in the courtroom, sweating. I reply, I hope the police can appear in court, but in the end can not appear in court does not depend on the court, and depend on the police. Of course, we will try our best to do the work, even asked the committee to do the work.

So, I personally find the chief of the Xinhua Public Security Bureau leadership, reported the barrister asked them, Public Security Bureau leaders began some concern. We said: "the police court in Hunan may be the first, more significant, Xinhua public security to be the first one to stand out, even if it is not very successful, will also give the bonus, will not damage the image of public security. Police in the future will become more and more popular, since there is no much point." The public security leaders think we said very reasonable, immediately said agreed to send police to court, and plan to arrange for officers to attend the trial, the trial procedures familiar, even ready to drill in advance. We are glad to meet the requirements, a barrister, future court must go much more smoothly. Of course, we don't have to tell the news to the lawyer, worry about half-way what changes not talk.

Surprisingly, the more worried about the more will appear. Before the court soon, the public security leader told me: police officers saw Yang lawyer blog post, says it does not want to court, they saw the Beihai police are lawyers and defendants in court to insult a scene, they usually will only do case, not practiced mouth Kung Fu, not big lawyers. Such as spring, unwilling to court public humiliation, if it is according to the rules of defense lawyer, they would be willing to appear in court. In this case, we do not report to counsel. The day before the hearing, counsel to submit your application, we notice eight police court. Although it has been expected, but we still to the police issued a notice of appearance. Two police officers out case, six police officers in the family issued a written material to us, that does not appear in court to reason. Of course, they did not write not willing and lawyers the real reason, because they don't want to get big lawyers, they know, once these people touched, always provoke a show.

We read the material that the police, law nature is very indignant, and again a speak in excitement emotion, a lawyer had asked the court to summon the police. Oh, they put the police's appearing in court to explain the situation as a witness. Based on the existing laws and regulations, I was unable to satisfy them, so that the request is not legitimate, and shall not be adopted, big lawyers very rare obey us ruling.

During the trial, I see "Shuangfeng daily". Originally is a confident person, but look at the "Shuangfeng", know yourself how ignorant people, how, how idiotic. "Shuangfeng" as a mirror, as I don't have to come from. Idiotic also have self-esteem, the trial may show some emotion, in one of Zhang Lei's lawyers argue with me when, I brazenly declare: do not think that only you will write the article, perhaps in the future I will learn what you look like, write a "XXX", let the world have a look you guys. People in the courtroom.

After the adjournment, the lawyer Yang Da to find me, said the case has not concluded, the judge is not suitable for writing, I replied, I don't write the case, write only big lawyer's performance, should be no problem.

Tonight will be time, leadership and put forward criticism on me, that I should not go to enjoy the "Shuangfeng", see will affect the mood, in the courtyard to reveal to judge the image is not good. I promised to look after surface, or correct.

Since I write "so and so" threatened to remember later, big lawyers sometimes will be extremely reluctant to obey my orders, Yang big lawyers are used as a young recruit, said: "the court ruling to illegal."

(twenty-one)

 

Rows of non stage last name of the defendant, the case is the first defendant Liu Moubai, counsel questions of evidence, the defendant said the Commission for Discipline Inspection and the process, security personnel had questioned its, and torture to extract confessions behavior, but can not remember the time, place, in the investigation stage of torture no, just said the police had threatened him, but can't remember the time, place, threatening people, at this time, Yang Da lawyers play a superb questions, ask: "Is it right? All interrogation of you threatened?" In this way, only a fool would deny. Liu Moubai is how clever people, immediately recognized. I immediately stopped, the reason is a tricky too. Yang said to obey, ask again: "Is it right? Except the first time, other interrogation is a threat?" Unequal defendant replied, I stopped, for the same reasons. Yang still obey, called my continuous stopped two times, random heart, no longer asking.

Liu Moubai's statement is entered row non, both sides of a fierce controversy, big lawyers think, the defendant admitted to torture to extract confessions behavior, the first defendant does not exhaust the row non, non is meaningless. The prosecution believes that, although the defendant confessed a confession by torture in the Commission for discipline inspection stage, but the time has the initiative to eliminate the confession, confession of defendant investigation stage no confessions by torture, threats the call is not specific, no exhaust into the row of non program. Finally, both sides suggested by the court, I put a question for both sides thinking: the illegal evidence provided clues without time, place, person, the prosecution to prove? Then announced the adjournment.

The time, the two judges agreed that, to Liu Moubai's confession should not row non, because the defendants and their per capita did not provide specific evidence. Although I was completely agree with them, in the legal aspects of it, the first defendant not row non words, in my understanding of the law, they will make the court, the court will "look good", is not conducive to the smooth, not into the row non, let the public prosecutor and the defender. We argue, when the "onlooker". Two judges agree.

According to local law to reflect, in the us the time, counsel for the court will order Liu Moubai into the row non bet, Yang Xuelin side, the other side bar. Yang Xuelin think not ruled row non, lawyers and other. Introduction of the "Shuangfeng evening record" proved a big bet of lawyers. Conclusion Yang Xuelin seems to be lost, in fact they are both winners, Yang Xuelin won in the law, he knew the legal consequences. The other big lawyer win in their theory, they believed in the cry of children milk.

Double chamber, we announced: "a collegial panel did not think Liu Moubai needs to start the procedure of excluding illegal evidence in the pretrial confession, but due to the defendant and lawyer row not very strong demand, the court decided to open up the non program." Big lawyers express surprise, ha ha, we kill them to a noisy court opportunities. Next is the burden of proof to prove the legitimacy of Liu Moubai interrogation, prosecutor puts it: "the defendant and his counsel did not provide specific evidence and clues and evidence, the court Liu Moubai clearly confessed the investigation organ not torture to extract confessions, necessary prosecutors have no proof." The public prosecutor answer triggered a lawyer so angry, have denounced the public prosecutor is not proof behavior, but eventually helpless.

Well, cry cry, milk is no eating.

Please see who in the rumor, who is bullshit.

    Yang big lawyer in the "one" idiotic judge bullshit can claim:

     Idiotic judge issued in September 13, 2013"Prison break" (eight) on the origin of the lawyers .

    The article began by sayingAfter the meeting: "before the court, found Yang lawyer Liu Moubai case opened a blog, the blog the first article is without any treatment of the indictment, investigation materials is the case later".

    Judge Lv Yinhua said Yang Jinzhu in the pretrial conference announced the investigation materials in the "Liu Yibai case" the truth of blog, this is the first egg judge Lv Yinhua as idiotic judge at. Yang Jinzhu as the idiotic trial first egg long pull, because the egg is Yang Jinzhu divulges State secrets crime.

    Here are a few specific time:

     1, Liu Yibai shehei case called before the court session time is September 27, 2012.

    2, Yang Jinzhu opened on sina.com.cn"Liu Yibai case" the truth blogTime isOctober 12, 2012, and inOn the same day fifteen fifty-five published Liu Yibai shehei case indictment in the personal blog.   

    3, Shuangfeng County procuratorate 2012 late October will be handed over to the Shuangfeng County Court proof catalogue, Yang Jinzhu got proof catalogue of the case.

    4, October 31, 2012, Yang Jinzhu assistant"Liu Yibai case" the truth blogPersonal blog published second posts"The organization of the structure characteristics of the prosecution directory (witness Zheng Yan): 1, Wang Shanchu Zheng Yan" . Since then, from November 1, 2012 to 14, Yang Jinzhu will make Shuangfeng County procuratorate assistant evidence proof directory published in"Liu Yibai case" the truth blogPersonal blog.

   "Liu Yibai case" the truth blogIn theUnderworld evidence indictment and proof in the directory in 2013 after June (pronounced later) by the assistant decryption Yang Jinzhu, published.

    5,Liu Yibai's case was in session in December 5, 2012.

 

    Yang Jinzhu in 1986 into the law the altar, and experienced the Guiyang Creek case investigation conclusion report published "storm", do not know the investigation of criminal cases of first instance belongs to the material in the trial process of state secrets? Yang Jinzhu is the courage is bigger than the sky, also not in the first instance court announced before the investigation materials and be sent to their high school?

 

     Yang Jinzhu no matter what Yinhua, Jinhua, then to ask a sound idiotic judge judge Lv Yinhua: if you're in the aftermath of the September 27, 2012 pretrial conference from"Liu Yibai case" the truth blogSee the case investigation materials Yang Jinzhu published, don't you know that this is Yang Jinzhu in crime of divulging state secrets? You as the idiotic judge, do not stop the crime Yang Jinzhu, nor to the Hunan Provincial Department of justice and the bar association of Hunan province to reflect and report to the Public Security Bureau of Loudi City, don't you constitute the crime of malfeasance?

     Yang Jinzhu also wants to ask a sound idiotic judge judge Lv Yinhua: as a judge, dare in the blog out of thin air, fabricating facts to frame Yang Jinzhu divulges State secrets constitute a crime, where your credibility?

      Please note the time node red letter, Yang Da's lawyer claimed the decryption is the "2013 June", please see the original, you see no see? Since 2012 November, is a private blog, blog comment is how to return a responsibility? Is it right? Before the court review? Who is bullshit, who all have very obvious. Other content and critical value? Hope you open your eyes, do not be fooled. The other is to remind young barrister, stone don't move much, will hit their own feet.

 

(twenty-two) a barrister Division

[by]:Learn Yang lawyer like click. This work shortly after the phone, Yang lawyer said, I read the text, believe that this decision is made by a collegial panel of independent, and that my words is pure bullshit, he wrote an article on "bullshit" article, hope I read, I promise. This shows the young barrister or have a certain mind, also visible Yang lawyer is able to change the understanding, and not some people still cling to one's view the collegial panel by the politics and Law Committee of control and interference.

 

Starting from the first day of the trial, Yang big lawyer always naturally or half unconsciously to me that, in this case to trial in February 8th, sometimes also with holding a cigarette in hand, walked up and down, in our yard mouth automatic speaking: "this case to trial in February 8th." From the point of view, they have been towards that goal. Plan three days the original row non, actually one and a half days time to complete, this is my surprise, I don't know where exactly is the problem.

The next procedure is the burden of proof. According to the court before the meeting agreed, proof method is grouping proof based on charges, four times for the underworld crime by four feature points, the other five to six times the crime of crimes, a proof, packet for this times above. This is the law, judges, prosecutors agreed, however, such an agreement in the lawyer's eyes, even the children are not as good as the retractor. The public prosecutor on the burden of the basic situation and the proceedings the defendant, Zhu Mingyong lawyer demur, called the grouping proof the defendant not remember, should permit a matter. Its intention is very clear, the purpose is very clear, is to set the trial until February 8th. But other lawyers (including some lawyer) that despite the burden of a packet will read more evidence, but relates to a defendant's content is not much, remember that no problem, strongly request according to the agreed grouping proof before the court session. Zhu lawyer firmly opposed, and put forward the evidence shall be read out in full, hope the court not as a mere formality. I propose: defenders disagree, the courts do not listen to one's opinion, if according to Zhu counsel on the burden of proof, the court will take a long time, suggest the defender can form a unified opinion. Zhu barrister: defenders from all corners of the country, to form a unified opinion is not possible. At the same time criticized my view of the logical problem. I reply: so how proof? Zhang Lei lawyer knowledge, proposes a National People's acceptable solution: "to lift."

The contradiction between human world this is everywhere, can eventually reconcile, mostly the parties compromise, as the rule of pioneer lawyers don't know how to compromise, which I never thought of it. At the time of the "Criminal Procedure Law" does not stipulate a specific way of proof, it should be said, the court has wide discretion. However, a lawyer involved in the trial, the court's ruling is not count. Although big lawyer proposed a universal solution, because it is not specific, not the implementation of our. So, we try to be as barristers instructions. The first great lawyers to diverge in the courtyard, enable us to be at a loss what to do. Let the lawyers to express their views, arguing for a long period of time, Yang Xuelin advised: because the defenders are scoring, published evidence of general proof of public prosecution, suggested to the defendant a choice, if the defendant to see evidence, the court shall be permitted. I answer: Yang Xuelin the lawyer's advice, now first agreed by grouping proof before the court session, the court and then communicate with each other, to determine a reasonable way. All lawyers have accepted the delaying tactics I.

The prosecutor then proof, I remind the public prosecutor in court: what are missing, is not lack of time, please be as detailed as possible. The people of God to understand, a text read up evidence. Read a certain period of time, I found that Yang big lawyer facing the wall behind me, pale, look stupefied. Zhu Mingyong, Chen Guangwu and other front defense people fell onto the table, especially Zhu lawyer head straight at me, very conspicuous, Zhang Lei barrister looked at the computer, from time to time on the keyboard, Xu is written in the masterpiece "Shuangfeng Ji" (actually big lawyer everyday situations, more or less) Wang Xingda lawyers sometimes play computer games, sometimes look around. Some lawyers are simply left the court. See this scene, my confidence is high many, I judge, barrister toughness is inferior to me, even though I have been very tired, but still did not show, every day sit square, even without playing a yawn. Counsel claims to trial until February 8th, just make an empty show of strength, I estimate, big lawyers will form a unified opinion, proposal according to the pre-trial conference agreed manner of proof. So, I put the camera gesture called to him, let her have her glorious image of lawyers one one note. Ha ha, lawyers all day scold the public prosecutor, judge method, will put in live video, should not be when the defendant. That is when a defendant is not afraid, lawyer Wang Xingda has already given me the state of the table, once a lawyer to sue me, he will give me free agent, a lawyer shall not cover, courage to free a lot.

Counsel is like making history, they can also create history, the Beihai case, a criminal facts, they make a trial for twenty days, to create the best of Guangxi River; a case, they make a trial of more than 30 days, the period for half a year, creating the best of Guizhou, also created Chinese the most; in this case, they want to create the best of Hunan. Counsel often to create history proud, proud to force the court adjourned, the police was proud, proud to judge act with confusion, pride with astronomical fee......

The afternoon before the adjournment, I concluded that: even if a predetermined way of proof burden, the case about to lift twenty-four, five, two days from this situation, a burden of evidence to use two days, so, all the participants in the proceedings to fight for a long time. Zhang Lei lawyers are extremely advocated long-term battle, he in the "Shuangfeng", and talk about the necessity for long-term operation, and lists the American longest trial evidence, on which a lawyer for up to 5 days of closing arguments very much.

Recess and lawyer Guo Zhenfeng talking about time, Guo lawyer pointed out that, if a person spent five minutes still unclear about a problem, this person is not a lawyer. Lawyers to view the difference, also how big. Don't think Guo lawyer is a big eater, he in Loudi or some famous, memory is the vice president of the Loudi Institute of criminal law, as the first defense of the accused person. He do not guilty case, should not be less than the big lawyers, in my hands have done not guilty. But lawyers do a guilty case, all over the world to know, he do not guilty case, few people know it.

(twenty-three) apologize counsel ""

Http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_e162ebaf0101ehly.html

[According to the]See Yang big lawyer "bullshit" two, Yang Renwei himself pulled eggs in the contents of the telephone yesterday, says he believes: "Liu Yibai is a trial shehei case decision is the result of my heart," confirmation, rather than "believe that this decision is made by a collegial panel of independent", and said the phone there are several witnesses to testify. A little common sense knows, in this case, judge a person cannot be convicted. You have a few people there, I have dozens of people. Words are blown away by the wind, is not worthy of me too much to care about. Anyway, Yang big lawyer text content and my memory content also be many, politics and Law Committee even without trial length control, not to judge. In fact, Yang big lawyer told me there is a content has not been released, objective for personal, maintaining its image, since few, by the way also released, he also said I hope I can criticize him, he will forward a word is not bad, so his blog will be lively, someone will look, keeping the public pay attention to. In view of this, written after the case, I decided not to criticize him, let him emerge of itself and perish of itself well, I doesn't like pong celebrity. As Qin Xiyan, Yang counsel repeatedly he approved, Qin Li is too boring, Yang Zijue, also from the back Jiangshan. There is a call what about Guo, also a lawyer, seeing an opportunity, want to bang bang counsel to a well-known, also wrote a big batch of old, I do not intend to criticize him, do not succeed by luck also.

 

It is not what I expected, hearing second days time, lawyer Yang Da told me, the lawyers agreed on the way of proof, still before the court testimony, the meeting agreed, this result, gave Zhu Mingyong a lawyer a slap in the face, but also prove, lawyers and ordinary human, is able to compromise.

The prosecution evidence, related defenders by published evidence, Chen Guangwu, Zhang Lei, barrister, the prosecutor read the testimony of witnesses should testify in court, and provides interpretation of Criminal Procedure Law Article141The legal basis. The public prosecutor in the criminal procedure law interpretation of article138And the Supreme Procuratorate criminal procedure rule282The response, that is brought to the witness to appear in court is the thing, not to witness without reason. So, counsel for the prosecutor read the testimony29Witnesses to testify in court.

The defendant and counsel for the witness to testify in the court procedure, interpretation of Criminal Procedure Law119Regulation is very clear, "should be in before the trial5Provide witness identity, address, address clearly..... Name list. We're hearing when sending SMS, inform all the defenders, according to the provisions apply to inform the witnesses to appear in court. However, in addition to lawyer Guo Zhenfeng apply for a witness to appear in court, the other is not a lawyer, in accordance with the provisions of the time and the requirements to apply. The day before the hearing, we received the Wang Xingda lawyer mail application, with only6Witness name, no other information. Oh, Chinese name so much, that we notice how?

Lawyer put a way not to go, just lying in the gutter to mix son, I never promised. I guess the big lawyers reckon without one's host is, if I promised to inform the29Witnesses to the court, the case is still hundreds of witnesses, please you all notice to appear in court, did not say first trial interrupt, the trial indefinitely, Run away to run you to death. Hey, I although knowledge as a barrister, but it only old sparrows, where can you trick? I would not like the brethren court, temporary to300Several witnesses notifications. So the answer: according to the "Criminal Procedure Law"157Provisions, prosecutors have read the testimony of a witness, the witness was repeated; according to the "Criminal Procedure Law"157Provisions, the right to apply for a new defender only witnesses to testify in court, the prosecutor have sworn testimony, the defender has not applied for new witnesses. The defence of the application shall not be permitted to. So, Zhang Lei lawyers in Shuangfeng "shocked" remember ", desire language without words." In the courtyard is off the reel, said their application belongs to the new witnesses, the judge ruled that the ten thousand wrong; Chen Guang Wuhan University Law is more persuasive, inculcate, said they had asked the judge ruled that the trial is to change into account, the future do not bear the responsibility so long misjudged case trial. The other big lawyer of course good, seems to be not recall one's words never give up potential.

My poor cultivation, third times in the court was very angry, and biting a tooth to reply: "how to use evidence to judge is judge things, evidence is wrong, wrong judge sentenced to jail, don't worry, defender. Do you think is the new witnesses, what new in where? Before the court, we would inform you in court5Recently submitted an application, you do not apply, raid in court today, what is the meaning? My answer clearly annoyed Chen Wu lawyer, he grabbed to Jane said excitedly: I now to judge the apology, not reminded of the presiding judge, should let the judge to do wrong, the presiding judge is willing to go to jail, I shouldn't intervene so. He is speaking of time, I have been for him concernedly, worried about his heart problems, so always dare not to interrupt him. He said enough, I reply: just a defender Liu Jing Ming to apologize, but the curse, the judge will not curse, but not on the table, because the judge civilized. Wish to defend people obey the court's ruling, comment is no longer on the issue, if you speak, the court no longer answer, please other defenders, published evidence.

Lawyer was never argue, the ruling of accidents.

(twenty-four) run away secretly barrister

 

 

Because lawyers are mostly in the pretrial read read files, so the proof stage is a boring thing for lawyers, I totally understand eat leftovers. So many lawyers not involved in the trial adducing evidences, especially commissioned two defenders, there must be a defender does not appear, some even two defenders are not present in court, counsel is not exceptional also, thirty-five people advocate groups, sometimes to only six or seven people. To this kind of behavior, lawyers think is appropriate, not only in the court, that point of view, in the blog is many times more on its rationality. There is a saying, the vicissitudes of life, what. My lawyer when, professional discipline does not seem to be so. However, big lawyers asked for other people participating in the hearing is different. The value of court bailiff forget to close the door, freezing the bar, bar not only serious criticisms of the court, in protest, "Shuangfeng" is more sigh, said the low quality staff, even the pupils are not; the smoke, they also have a dig, said he"As if the past is dead like smoke less";The public prosecutor is more strict requirements, not only the indictment is not a word wrong, they are also required to provide accurate proof according to the outline, even require proof according to the provisions of law; judge said two words, will also do some articles. Oh, somehow people or to the court, lawyers, not to, the public prosecutor evidence as to who? Don't say for the court, judge is reading the volume; of course can be said for the defendant, the defendant has no marking, however, defendants have the evidence ability? If there is, he spent so much money what do lawyers do? He asked the two lawyers is to what? 

Although my judgment, delay the trial lawyer just make an empty show of strength, but still no signs of loosening, then led me to the lawyers on a rope, on the one hand, I was in court that prosecutors detailed proof, the lawyers say, on the other hand, I announced: starting from today, I will not quasi any false, you give me leave, I will not "a bright smile (note)". A lawyer in court against, say lawyers as long as the parties and the good communication, can leave. I answer: consent is one thing, the discipline of the court is another matter, we spend seventy yuan wages (I monthly pay 2200 yuan) to sit here, your daily income of several hundred yuan, thousands of yuan, or even several million, have what reason not to sit here? My intention is very obvious, you want to take time, as long as you stay, I'll be there.

The lawyer is not the time to know the consequences, the court may suggest the lawyer management department to stop his industry. So there are many local lawyer I complained, some call charging too little, long stay here will eat their own capital, some said the defendant own only one or two charges, most evidence has nothing to do with the defendant, may be no matter, want the presiding judge can do me a favor, quasi their false. I quietly reply, our decision is mainly aimed at a family lawyer, you didn't make the court, judicial suggestion I won't send you. See, That cannot be described. smile on the face of the lawyers.

I am very clear, to be released this inside, counsel will condemn both in speech and in writing, severely criticized me selective law enforcement. Hey, has been batch smelly, also is not afraid of many batches of this time. These are powers, I love so much. As the great lawyer at court, judge us is approved, counsel or love how trouble on how busy.

I'm the noose, still a great lawyer necks, the burden of proof in just over a day, Zhu Yong Ming is lawyer asked us not as a mere formality trial of third days, Zhu counsel did not give anyone leave, there are several successive days did not appear, I asked Yang big lawyer asked Zhu Da the lawyer's whereabouts, Yang Zhu counsel another case hearing, go to.

At the moment Guan Jian testimony, Zhu lawyer ran, secretly ran, did not take away a cloud, as he later secretly. "Not as a mere formality" sound is still in court filled, Zhu lawyer but are too lazy to go through.

Note: according to Law blog, barrister North sea trial long leave, "the judge face revealing a bright smile, immediately sighting."

 

(twenty-five) the defendant hold about and give oneself airs

 [statement] have you called, I delete their comments, in fact, I have never had this behavior, I do not know the blog, playing only 10 days after blog, found a comment spam menu, open look, there are some nasty comments on the inside, and then gradually find, the rubbish is automatically deleted, I don't know why. From now on, I no longer reply to anyone's comments, please understand, hereby declare.

A phenomenon is found in the interrogation of class, for the specific facts of a crime, no one accused person basically no confession, the defendant lawyer entrusted to the local small confession, the defendant's confession, the area of lawyers, only Yang Xuelin defendant confession is not much, the idiotic, don't know why. The row non and evidence stage, many defendants to had not retracted the fact gradually. I point out to some of the defendant, and remind them of the confession. A fool can hear, I called the statement refers to the court's statement, however, big lawyer in the "Shuangfeng", but cling to one's view I want the defendant remember in police statement, so I began to recite the public security. 

In the interrogation, row non, evidence stage, lawyers have a common routines, hand attacking the public prosecutor, method, on the other hand all praise the defendant. Said police torture to extract confessions, be utterly devoid of conscience, framed; said deliberately misrepresent play the Jackal to the tiger, said prosecutor, judge illegal trial, violations of human rights; that the defendant defiance and affray activist, intentional injury is defense, corruption is custodial, illegal detention facts are not clear, capital flight is not dry, blackmail and impose exactions on doing good....... As a result, the defendant each became the conquering hero.

In view of the defendant lawyer are heard, feel good sense, seems to really become a hero, and also learn the bar shape, the voice is more and more big, and gradually try to attack the public security and procuratorial, remark, would lift out, with pride.

Continuous appear similar phenomenon, I summed up: "I found a phenomenon, the defendant in handcuffs, speech style is higher than the people on the stage, I remind you, are you not you at the trial court, in court, rational not character is high, you are right, the court will hear." Counsel did not criticize me, still remember "Shuangfeng" in recognition of the serious doubled, "said the judge, personal style, is really an upright honest people."

The evidence stage, do not write the lawyer cross examination level, is obviously sorry big lawyer. Counsel cross examination level, nature is the first in the country, Shuangfeng second, needless to say. That describe one or two cases, prosecutors in the organizational structure of the burden of proof for the underworld crime, for the three kind of the defendant deliberately used even license plate, to show the brothers concentric evidence, to prove the existence of underworld organization. Lawyer: the party and government organs quality preaching license plate number, license plate character, inspection, law also have a block, Is it right? Is the underworld? I'm scared, thought, which have such quality certificate? The party and government organs and public prosecutor, license plate numbers, precisely because they are organized, Defender of the examination opinions not more that exist the defendant organization?

The burden of proof to prove existence of organization shehei organization, a beat all the examination opinions appeared again, big lawyers call these organizational discipline is not illegal, it does not violate the moral, not a kind of organizational discipline. I checked the Green Gang rides, no one is illegal and immoral, checked the Mafia's party, even no one is illegal, we can say that they are not the Mafia? In my humble opinion, the defender should as far as possible to the existence question of organizational discipline, and should not go considering its legitimacy. Sure enough, the public prosecutor for answer: as a kitchen knife, take the chef hands, will make delicious food, in the hand, is the murder weapon. Ha ha, lawyer gave prosecutors the noose, but eventually caught his neck.

Counsel often claim that they do, shehei case is the most experienced, watch case is more accurate, there will be no mistake, in this case, Yang big lawyer took over announced, Guiyang also cause than Li Qinghong, whether they do have shehei case, and successfully convicted.

(twenty-six) took the referee's lawyer

In the interrogation, row non and the burden of evidence stage, the defendant have a common characteristic, is their own participation in crime fact statement, one can imagine, the three stage is to repeat three times, more funny, some defendants wrote written materials, also want to read it three times. Generally speaking, as long as not to repeat too much, I won't stop. The difference between the interpretation to the defendant in three stages, the defendant also repeated statement, I will stop, repeated read materials on the permitted to repeat statements or stop tone, sometimes more severe. How to stop a few times, counsel did not work, call me deprived of the right to defense of the accused. Zhu Mingyong lawyers are some very surprising, said the defendant may be the grounds for I avoided, unfortunately, the defendant did not listen to him, the defendant's counsel did not listen to him. 

After a proof, the defendant Liu Moubin (Zhu Mingyong lawyers) requires evidence, I found that the prosecution did not charge him with the crime, that he didn't have the necessary evidence, but Liu Moubin believes that the prosecutor read the testimony of witnesses are mentioned in his presence, insist on quality certificate. The court ruled that the authority of the challenges, like the plague, quickly from the counsel to defendants, so, I answer: "it's not only the defenders do not obey the command of the court, even the court also listen to the command of, well, you said". Liu Moubin replied "since the presiding judge said so, I do not say." Once again I reply: "you say, you can say."

Liu accused testimony said: "the public prosecutor's allegations are not set up, I'm not guilty of a crime, I have said before, I will not repeat". I immediately affirmed: "the defendant LiuMou interrogation method is relatively standardized." Lawyer Wang Xingda quit on the spot, said: "do not agree with the defendant this interrogation method, because he does not know what is the evidence of the nature, so, in the not too much repeated, I asked my parties in the quality certificate of targeted a brief statement of the facts." Oh, the defendant would understand, also a lawyer stem what? The lawyers have the obligation to tell how the defendant's testimony in front of the court, the court is not very suitable for informing the place. Repeat statement is defendants way, to let other lawyers learned a beautiful new tactics.

Liu Moubai was in evidence, is to restate the relevant facts. Learn by counsel criticism lesson, I decided to let him speak enough. About three, forty minutes, still off the reel. No wonder, the fourteen murder charges ah, one thirty will certainly cannot say. However, Yang Jinzhu lawyers see not bottom go to, to stop. My heart was shocked: "this is not my right? Lawyer how public power?" I slow slow God, said: "the defendant Liu Moubai, you are after the fact, is now the testimony, I had long wanted to interrupt, but did not interrupt you, is the view of the morning one of the defense argued that the defendant can state the facts in evidence stage, but he don't have here, I wish he would listen to you just say some what." Say that finish, I suddenly found Wang Xingda seated at the back row (according to the ranking, he is a middle), and then corrects said: "maybe I was not careful, said the morning of the defendant can be a statement of fact defender sat in the back, I hope that the defense and listen to what Liu Yibai said."

Yang lawyer immediately pointed out that: "the court recommended not too much guidance counsel." I reply: "I'm not guide the defenders, but hope that the defenders take a look at the evidence stage facts should not, I can't guide the defender, because my every word and action will be online."

Originally, Shun Li into a chapter in "Shuangfeng" process, completely changed, it is Yang lawyer interrupts the defendant to speak, but became I interrupted. I say the Internet is not what, just accept it distorts the Internet, this time I have put your cards on the table, the fact has been distorted, not clear when, and how? Can only ask you to imagine.

(twenty-seven) performance of the or speech

Prosecutors have accused the crime of disturbing social order after the burden, Yang's turn Dalv examination time, lawyer Yang Da was standing up. My heart is very clear, wonderful scene be staged, Yang big bar is not easy to stand up and speak, and a stand up with extraordinary things. Indeed, the extraordinary opening language, called the crime is the public security organ and the ad hoc group on the defendant's frame, and then off the reel, said he to indignation, if he's wrong, the police can arrest him so, just don't talk about the examination opinions. Listen to more than ten minutes, a marginal nor, so I interrupted him: "Liu Moubai's lawyer talked so long, I didn't catch what you said is what mean, please direct your published evidence on the nature of evidence." Yang answered: "good." Then a "passion, indignation, acoustic shock house"(Note: "Shuangfeng".)Free, and not associated with young's "body language", the scene was remarkable, but still not to the point of discourse. I think in the heart: Yang counsel is acting talent. The bailiff where seen this type, have set aside the defendant, the defendant in the back surrounded the semi round, like watching Yang lawyer speak like see the monkey, from time to time pointing fingers, communicate with each other. To this end, I pointed out: "please pay attention to take good care of the police accused his escort, don't just see defender performances." Yang lawyer immediately said: "I am not the performance." I replied: "I'm sorry, speech, speech." Oh, do the hard, the court must talk insincerely speech. Yang lawyer said about three, forty minutes, until he have nothing to say now, but I did not hear some real examination opinions. 

The public prosecutor said: "although have been listening carefully, but I believe that all of the people and the public prosecutor, most did not understand the defenders say what mean, now understood part of the response." Yang lawyer is very cute, immediately refuted: "I am the mouth of the cave, you are in Shuangfeng, could not understand how could that be?" Zhang Lei lawyer more lovely in the "Shuangfeng", said: "may be due to the defender language speech, may also be the defender rich body language to attract attention, leading to the public prosecutor only understand part." The public prosecutor of the heart, not the law, do not understand, do not understand or not. In Chinese map, Shuangfeng and Dongkou almost in the same spot, for what language do not know the reason?

(twenty-eight) the variable

The burden of evidence for four or five days, just after the underworld crime, according to the schedule, we may keep counsel in Shuangfeng have the Spring Festival. As saying after the typhoon there is always sunny, the same court, after the meeting of wind and clouds more than 10 days, side pressure came. Start a crime proof time, lawyer Yang Da suddenly found me, ask us before December 25th will be the case, said he and Chen Guangwu went to Shanxi to appear in court No. 26. I'm so false as surprised: "how is that possible, according to the current schedule, the burden of proof must be held by February 8th, you have proof, and debate." Yang Xianran anxious: "why not? Evidence only read directory and witness for the name, lawyers are refer to the volume, read no significance. Our evidence to the court, only talk about the main idea about the debate, each round, I speak for forty minutes, an hour at most, other people say a few minutes." I put Zhu Mingyong lawyer views back to him: "the defendant not scoring, what evidence?" Yang Da: "that's bullshit, defendant know matter what card?" I suggested: "other defenders don't agree?" Yang said: "we that few people have been unified views, other lawyers and the parties work by Guo Zhenfeng and me to do." I again asked: "when a defendant to incomplete evidence on the grounds of appeal read how to do?" Yang replied: "we keep this on the grounds of appeal." I said that he would sign the opinion, see I have not let go, Yang big lawyer raised his voice: "you just don't agree, Shanxi court I and Chen Guangwu is sure to go, when we get back to the court, February 8th." I figured, that can be done, and promised him. Although the law in order to money can change position, can also give up the oath, but we can never be in court "as a mere formality", so I put forward: the evidence certainly not read directory, to read and explain the key ideas, but every day to work, not to rest. Yang agreed.

So Yang counsel by recess time, respectively, to the other defenders, do the work, at the same time from cigarettes, perhaps we all agreed, Yang big lawyer went to the front to colleagues hand over the tribute, see, Yang big lawyer's face or peers in the.

The same time conflict, Yang Da lawyers not secretly run away, Yang Jinzhu had to admit, is a fairly honourable man.

 

(twenty-nine) by storm

Since it is the proof, nature of both sides, the defender for appearing in court as a witness is not free. As already mentioned, Guo Zhenfeng lawyers in strict accordance with the law application in writing several witnesses;Wang Xingda lawyers in the day before the court also gives us some names of witnesses, trial process and added some witnesses and the basic situation of the contact, the remaining himself on the cross; and there were few defenders for individual witnesses. 

The case is the court to inform the witnesses, because some witnesses did not appear, be buckled bar "to do the work does not appear in court the hat", Guiyang                 In not far, hat is too heavy, we can not afford to wear, he had to find another path. So we are entrusted with the case is irrelevant and within easy reach of the Xinhua court for delivery notice to appear. Regrettable results, two witnesses did not successfully delivered, the receipt of state, including a mobile phone can not get through, the other in Huaihua, not to. At the same time to inform people, a few people notice is not received, we are often encountered, sometimes we drove day subpoena, and are looking for a person not to some, believe that peer would have had the same experience. However, unfortunately, we met a group of things one hundred percent successful people, they asked us to do it 100% success. Before the court for a few minutes, I have to tell Yang Jinzhu. Yang Jinzhu cling to one's view, is certainly Xinhua court did the work, specially to the two men not to, also said I was the mastermind. A session, Yang Jinzhu lashed out at the court in Xinhua, said the court in Xinhua is the manufacturing case of accomplice, and said the court in Xinhua can not contact witnesses later they contact, went to Huaihua to witness the first day in Xinhua and so on. There are big lawyer present our service is not valid. After listening, I can not stop and angry, loudly replied: "I don't know the defenders attack there is no bottom line, the public prosecutor, your daily attack, now even irrelevant Xinhua court are you attack, excuse me, Xinhua court is necessary to do the work? They do the work and for what? Said I was responsible, I tell you, even the Xinhua court's shadow not seen. We have entrusted to you, is to prevent the plant, not unrelated person you will attack. Other service laws the regulations, you will know. Using mobile phone people should know, mobile phone can not contact is constant some thing, sometimes is the reason for the signal, is sometimes plate reasons, sometimes causes of mobile phone, then you can contact is normal, why not disappear after you can contact. Congenital in second days in Xinhua to Huaihua strange? At present the traffic, the time of day the world race. How far is it from Xinhua and Huaihua? More than two, three hundred kilometers." Yang Jinzhu said: "to say you are still legal, is the mastermind of pretrial make fun of say, can not take it seriously." I replied: "you are before the court said, but there are so many people, a defendant, a bailiff, a bystander, a prosecutor, loud, everyone heard, I must clarify."

Yang did not say what, otherwise the defender believes to Huaihua to witness is in obtaining Marquis examine period, can not go out. I answer: witness against the guarantor Marquis examine rules out, handled by the public security organs, we now are based on the receipt of service description of the circumstances, if the defender insists to notice to appear in court, the defenders can contact.

After the adjournment, Yang Jinzhu said to me: "you're cunning." I replied: "you deal with this person, no cunning, how line?"